eco TV
After the holiday season, mounting challenges 9/11/2018

The protectionist threat has been grabbing headlines but this hasn't stopped Wall Street from reaching new highs, supported by growth in earnings and the perception of a dovish Fed.

TRANSCRIPT // After the holiday season, mounting challenges : September 2018

François Doux: As we approach the last part of 2018, we will now talk about the economy with William de Vijlder. Hello.


William de Vijlder: Hello François.


François Doux: As the chief economist of BNP Paribas, you must also keep an eye on what is happening in the financial markets. Wall Street keeps breaking records. Is there an economic justification for the financial markets’ record highs?


William de Vijlder: That has been the subject of lots of debate. On the one hand, Wall Street’s record highs clearly show the role played by monetary policy and the Federal Reserve’s extremely cautious approach, which for market operators, has inspired a lot of confidence. Another major point is the very strong cyclical position of the US economy, which is driving earnings. The only sour note in this bullish market is that protectionist threats do not seem to have had an impact yet. That means that if the situation deteriorates, it could trigger an even bigger impact on Wall Street.


François Doux: Will strong US economic growth end up fuelling a little too much inflation?


William de Vijlder: We expect to see more inflation. As an economist, I would even say we are growing somewhat impatient.

As a market operator, however, it is a big relief that there is no inflation. Moreover, Mr. Powell, who has headed the Federal Reserve for the past several months, repeated at Jackson Hole that he was rather serene when it comes to inflation. The Federal Reserve’s message is extremely subtle. On the one hand, it is saying that it will continue to tighten monetary policy gradually, and that it will remain vigilant.

And on the other hand, it is also saying that monetary policy depends enormously on economic data. Why? Because it would be extremely risky to restrict its hand to a few easy formulas, such as the equilibrium interest rate or natural unemployment rate.


François Doux: So what is your scenario for the Fed?


William de Vijlder: We continue to foresee two more rate increases this year and an additional one in early 2019. Thereafter, it will all depend on how the economy evolves. From this perspective, it is important to keep in mind that the impulse, driven by higher public sector spending and tax cuts this year, will be smaller in 2019.

We must also keep in mind that higher interest rates will eventually have an impact, on activity in the construction sector, for example. The stronger dollar could also curb exports somewhat. I would say that the first quarter, and even the first half, will be extremely important for evaluating whether the Federal Reserve will adapt its policy rates.

For the moment, the Fed continues to say that there will be several more tightening moves, even in 2019.


François Doux: One last question on the US President Donald Trump, who talks a lot about trade sanctions. Protectionism is on the rise. As an economist, do you see this movement as having a negative impact on growth in the short to medium term?


William de Vijlder: The classic response is: that depends. But concretely, what can we observe? For the moment, the impact has been extremely small. There was a dip in the assessment of export orders, but that must be seen in the light of the global economic slowdown in the first half of the year.

Based on German business surveys, for example, companies do not seem to be much more worried. Another factor worth keeping in mind is that the United States and Mexico have managed to reach a trade agreement. The Canadians are under strong pressure to come on board, and there was also a message for Europe to accelerate things. Even so, let’s keep our feet on the ground: the real focus of attention is on trade relations between the United States and China. Negotiations are bound to be long and tough, and there is a risk that this situation could have a much more significant economic impact.


François Doux: We will keep this analysis in mind in the months ahead. Thank you, William De Vijlder. In a moment we will talk about the emerging markets, and Turkey in particular.

View more videos Eco TV

On the Same Theme

Globalization: an historical perspective 12/20/2018
First episode of three dedicated to Globalization. What made globalization possible?  In this first episode, William De Vijlder, the chief economist of BNP Paribas, distinguishes four drivers of globalization and discusses its limits. Interview conducted with François Doux.
Globalization today: from multi to bilateralism 12/20/2018
Second episode of series of three dedicated to Globalization. William De Vijlder analyses the transition from multilateralism to bilateralism, in the USA-China relations in particular. What are the consequences of growing bilateralism and uncertainty for trade, capital flows? Interview conducted with François Doux
Globalization tomorrow: the inclusion challenge 12/20/2018
Third and last episode of the series dedicated to Globalization. In past episodes its limits were mentionned, but what's new for the future of globalization? William De Vijlder discusses three levels of globalization sustainability:  inclusion, environment, financial stability – major challenges for economic policy. Interview conducted with François Doux.
Bank debt leverage: ten years later 9/5/2018
Following the 2007-2008 financial crisis, international regulators considerably strengthened the capital adequacy requirements for banks. Since then, the average bank leverage ratio (book value of equity/consolidated assets) has increased sharply in the eurozone and the United States, to 7.3% and 10.1%, respectively, at year-end 2017, compared to 4% and 6.9% in 2008. Looking beyond these trends, the relative ratio levels must be seen in terms of the very different financing means of the two economies and the structure of savings. First, in the United States, the economy relies more on capital markets than on loans reported on bank balance sheets. The securitisation of mortgage loans benefiting from Federal guarantees helps reduce the size of bank balance sheets. As a result, there is a partial transfer of banking system leverage towards less regulated entities. Second, bank liabilities account for a smaller share of household savings in the United States. Then, at the economic level, the probability that bank equity will serve as a buffer between any potential asset losses and savings is undoubtedly lower in the United States than in the eurozone.  
The cost of the protectionist threat 5/11/2018
Even if in reality nothing changes, worrying about protectionism may nevertheless act as an economic headwind because threats and counter-threats increase uncertainty.
How the willingness to take risk can evaporate 7/28/2017
News about monetary policy news influences asset prices via changes in expected cash-flows, the risk-free rate of interest and the required risk premium. Big fluctuations in the risk premium explain why asset prices are more volatile than news about ‘fundamentals’. These fluctuations reflect the heterogeneous nature of market participants. To go further Read the paper by William De Vijlder: How the willingness to take risk can evaporate
Doomed if you do, doomed if you don’t? 6/30/2017
Monetary policy normalisation is a balancing act: tighten too early could trigger a recession, hike too late could mean an inflation overshoot and a need to raise rates more aggressively. To go further Read the paper by William De Vijlder: Monetary tightening: Doomed if you do, doomed if you don’t?
Global: Synchronised surprises 1/11/2017
Recent economic data have been robust and have surprised to the upside: the numbers have been better than expected in the US, the Eurozone and in emerging markets (a universe which covers 20 countries). These synchronized surprises (all three indicators being in positive territory) do not occur that often. The recent experience may reflect that by coincidence things have improved simultaneously albeit for country specific reasons or it may show the impact of a common factor, like the prospect of fiscal stimulus in the US. The next several months will tell. Another striking element is the recent strong increase in the Eurozone surprise index which has now reached a level which makes it increasingly difficult to continue to surprise to the upside.
A weak euro for long 1/6/2017
The euro is very low again vs. the dollar. A situation that is likely to persist.
2017: A critical year for the climate negotiations 1/6/2017
In November 2016, the Paris agreement on climate change came into force and the countries even decided to accelerate the agenda for its implementation. However, the Trump presidency casts a shadow on further progress.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 1998 articles and 549 videos