Podcast: Macro Waves
Negative nominal interest rates: causes 10/28/2019

In the first part of this podcast, William De Vijlder analyses the causes of negative rates while explaining how they can brought about the “paradox of thrift”. What does this concept cover? And how could negative rates foster the emergence of such a paradox?

TRANSCRIPT // Negative nominal interest rates: causes : October 2019

Part 1 - Negative nominal interest rates: causes

Before starting to discuss the causes of negative interest rates, we should explain what the paradox is about.

The paradox of thrift or of saving has been made popular by John Maynard Keynes, although it goes back far in time. It means that when people decide to increase their savings, which may make sense at the individual household level, it has a negative impact in the aggregate because it slows down consumption and hence economic growth.

Why devote a podcast on this topic and why now?

The topic is important: if the paradox exists, monetary policy will fail to stimulate growth and inflation. This is a problem, not only for the central bank but for all of us.

Why for all of us?

If growth slows, that mean income growth will slow and job creation will slow as well. Moreover, the ECB might decide it has no other option than to become even more aggressive in its monetary policy, meaning even lower rates than today.

Why discuss the paradox now?

With rates being very low and often negative, it increases, at least theoretically, the risk of becoming confronted with this paradox.

So savings’ behaviour is the thing to monitor. How do economists actually calculate savings and the savings rate?

Saving is the part of the gross disposable income which is not spent as final consumption expenditure.

The household savings rate is defined as gross household saving divided by gross disposable income, therefore, the savings rate increases when gross disposable income grows at a higher rate than final consumption expenditure.

Saving rates can be measured on either a gross or net basis. Net savings rates are measured after deducting consumption from fixed capital (depreciation of dwellings).

Household savings can be used for household capital formation (essentially the purchase and renovation of dwellings) and for financial savings.

Moving to interest rates now. Why are some of them negative?

There are various reasons and the explanatory factors may differ depending on whether we look at short term or long term interest rates.

So long term rates can be negative as well?

Oh yes. Some time ago, Germany issued a 30 years bond with a negative coupon, although there was little investor enthusiasm.

In explaining the causes of negative interest rates, it is useful to look at the neutral interest rate. The real neutral (or natural) rate of interest is the rate at which GDP is at its potential and hence inflation is stable provided there are no shocks to demand (which would hit realised GDP) and supply (which would hit potential GDP).

To put it differently, it’s the interest rate at which the economy is in equilibrium.

"Conceptually one of the most important variables in modern macroeconomics, r* is the real rate of interest that brings output into line with its potential or natural level in the absence of transitory shocks (in the case of semi-structural models) or nominal adjustment frictions (in the case of DSGE models). r* thus closes the output gap and stabilises inflation, either eventually or concomitantly depending on the type of model. Numerous factors, such as demographics or technological progress in the long run, or changes in risk aversion in the short run, affect r*". (ECB)

Why is this neutral rate the logical starting point?

First, it reminds us that the neutral rate can rise or decline for structural reasons, which have little or nothing to do with monetary policy. This is an important point. It means that a central bank is not the only cause and perhaps not even the major reason why the rates are low.

Second, the neutral rate anchors the official rate of interest set by the central bank: the policy rate will be set having in mind the neutral rate. This anchoring should not be interpreted in a strict sense: estimating the neutral rate of interest in real time is fraught with issues, a bit like real-time estimates of the output. Hence the neutral rate is more a reference, with a confidence band around it, rather than a precise estimate.

If the official rate is higher than the neutral rate, policy is not in an accommodating stance, even though the policy rate can be low.

"Central banks can influence the short-term real interest rate relative to its equilibrium value by changing the short-term nominal interest rates, thereby influencing the real economy and inflation developments. If the key interest rate less the expected inflation rate is below the natural interest rate, it may be expected that households will use the opportunity of loans at relatively favourable rates to expand consumption; enterprises thereupon invest more, produce above potential in the goods market and raise their prices, which leads to an increase in the rate of inflation. If, on the other hand, the key interest rate less expected inflation is higher than the natural interest rate, capacity underutilisation and falling inflation would be expected." (Bundesbank)

Where is the neutral rate now?

One assume that it is around 0% in the eurozone.

These are very low numbers. How come?

As mentioned before it’s a combination of various factors:

"Our estimates show a declining trend in r* in the advanced economies starting in the 1980s, driven by lower trend growth and demographic factors. Risk aversion and flight to safety are shown to have contributed to a further decline in the wake of the global financial crisis."(ECB)

But monetary policy also played a role?

Indeed. Traditional interest rate policy, QE and forward guidance have contributed to a decline in long-term bond yields, either by lowering expectations for the policy rate or by ‘duration extraction’. This drives down the term premium, i.e. the premium for taking duration risk.

More Podcasts

On the Same Theme

International trade: a few signs that tensions are easing 6/27/2022
Although some signs of improvement are visible on certain trade routes—notably between China and the West Coast of the US—the overall situation is still far from a return to normal. The lockdown in Shanghai will continue to have significant repercussions for the operation of ports in China and elsewhere in Asia throughout the second half of 2022.
The worrisome cost of worrying about recession 6/12/2022
The global economy has been hit by multiple shocks this year: new Covid-19 cases in China, the war in Ukraine, rising interest rates. Financial market behaviour and the US Survey of Professional Forecasters point to mounting concerns about the risk of a recession. These worries come with a cost to the economy and may cause growth to slow down further. Some degree of concern is welcome because it enhances the effectiveness of a restrictive monetary policy. There is a tipping point however, beyond which slowdown fears become self-fulfilling. Addressing these would be difficult if by then inflation has not yet converged sufficiently to target.
OECD weekly indicator suggests slowing activity in advanced economies 6/12/2022
The Covid-19 pandemic continues to slow around the world. According to the latest figures from Johns Hopkins University, 3.3 million new cases were recorded around the world in the week of 1 to 7 June, a 4% drop on the previous week. On a regional level, the epidemic continues to ease in Africa (-24%) and Asia (-18%), whilst the number of new cases in Europe has stabilised after two months of substantial falls. New case numbers in South America continued to rise strongly (21%), whilst North America also posted a small increase. Meanwhile, 67% of the world’s population has now received at least one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine.
PMI: resilience of employment data but new export orders continue to deteriorate 6/6/2022
The global manufacturing PMI continues its sideways movement since March, when it had declined due to the war in Ukraine. May saw a weakening in the US and the euro area, where in particular Italy recorded a considerable decline. In Australia the PMI recorded a big drop. China saw a rebound following the easing of mobility restrictions. In India the PMI has been stable at a high level for several months and Vietnam saw a sizeable improvement in May. The services PMI was down in the US and the euro area, where in particular Germany was confronted with weaker data, although still well above the 50 mark. In the UK, the index recorded a huge drop. Japan is benefiting from better data and in India the already elevated index moved higher again in May.
Covid-19 pandemic: the situation continues to improve in most regions of the world 6/6/2022
The epidemiological situation arising from the Covid-19 pandemic continues to improve in most regions of the world. For the first time since mid-November 2021, the number of new cases has dropped below the symbolic level of 3.5 million per week (7-day moving average). Over the same period, visits to retail and leisure facilities held at pre-pandemic levels in Belgium, Germany and France, and are approaching normal levels in Italy. Retail and leisure mobility still falls short of pre-pandemic levels in the other countries (United States, Spain, the UK and Japan).
Inflation: shifting focus, shifting concerns 5/29/2022
Historically, there is a close relationship in the US and the euro area between, on the one hand, a measure of price pressures based on survey data on manufacturing delivery times and input prices, and, on the other hand, core inflation. The recent flash purchasing managers’ indices show that price pressures may be peaking, thereby providing hope that inflation will follow in the not-too-distant future. This will focus the attention to the speed of decline in inflation. A very slow process would be highly discomforting, raising fears that ever-higher interest rates would end up causing a recession. Everybody wants slower growth to bring inflation under control, but nobody wants the growth engine to stall.
Economic uncertainty edging higher 5/29/2022
Our different uncertainty gauges are complementary, in terms of scope and methodology. US economic policy uncertainty based on media coverage has eased slightly after a significant increase, reflecting concern about the impact of aggressive monetary policy tightening. In the US, business uncertainty about sales revenue growth has been stable but uncertainty about employment growth has rebounded somewhat, probably reflecting ongoing difficulties in filling vacancies. The European Commission’s uncertainty index, after having jumped following the war in Ukraine, has stabilised.
International trade: slowdown confirmed 5/29/2022
Global PMI numbers point to a significant slowdown in global economic activity. The new export orders sub-index dropped to 48.1 in March, below the threshold for expansion, and was unchanged in April. More specifically, new export orders for Taiwan recorded a heavy fall (down 17.2% m/m), the biggest drop for fourteen months. Although a pullback was expected, following a strong rise in March (21.6%), the scale of the decline was surprising.
Covid-19 pandemic: the situation in Europe continues to improve rapidly 5/22/2022
According to the latest data from Johns Hopkins University, more than 4 million new cases were recorded around the world between 12 and 18 May, an increase of 5% on the previous week. This represents the first weekly increase since the beginning of February. Looked at on a regional level, the situation in Europe improved significantly (-20%), and that in Africa stabilised. However, case numbers continued to climb in North and South America (17%). Asia saw the first increase after two months of virtually continuous falls. Meanwhile, 66% of the world’s population has now received at least one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine.
Back to pre-pandemic levels in (almost) all developed economies 5/15/2022
The downward trend in the weekly number of new cases of Covid-19 continued in most regions of the world. For the first time since mid-November 2021, the number of new cases for the week fell below the symbolic level of 4 million on average for a moving seven-day period. Some 3.6 million new cases were recorded between 5 and 11 May, a fall of 11% on the previous week. On a regional basis, case numbers continued to fall drastically in Europe (-20%) and Asia (-17%), but rose in Africa (42%), North America (24%) and South America (10%). The sharp rise in Africa in recent weeks is linked to soaring cases in South Africa. Meanwhile, 66% of the world’s population has now received at least one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine. Over the same period, visits to retail and leisure facilities remained strong in the developed economies.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 1785 articles and 354 videos