eco TV Week

What 2019 tells us about 2020


The topics which have characterised 2019 are expected to remain very relevant in 2020: slow growth, elevated uncertainty, low inflation, low interest rates.


TRANSCRIPT // What 2019 tells us about 2020 : December 2019

The key takeaways from 2019

It’s that time of the year again: as the festive season approaches, economists polish their crystal ball and produce an outlook for next year.

In gauging what 2020 may bring, 2019 actually offers many insights, so looking in the rear view mirror is actually a useful exercise.

Let’s start with the key takeaways of the year which is almost over.

Firstly, global growth has slowed down. It started with exports, then moved to manufacturing and eventually impacted services, though this sector has been quite resilient.

Secondly, uncertainty has been a very frequently used word although assessing the impact on growth is difficult. It did not stock markets in having a superb performance, so they have climbed a wall of worry, with the help of lower interest rates. Corporate investments have weakened in the US but were strong in the eurozone.

Thirdly, monetary policy has been eased further by the ECB and the Fed changed direction. This reflects that these central banks, cognisant of their limited room for manoeuvre, are risk averse: if you want to reach your inflation target, make sure to avoid a big growth slowdown. Yet there is now a feeling that the limit has been reached or that we’re at least close to it. Hence the renewed interest in fiscal policy but also the strategy review conducted by the Fed and soon to be started by the ECB.

Finally, climate change has moved to the top of the agenda, at least of households and companies, less so unfortunately for certain governments, witness the disappointing COP25 summit in Madrid.

2020: more of the same

Next year will probably bring more of the same in a number of areas.

Growth is expected to remain on the slow side. The stabilisation of survey data in recent months creates hope that, on the back of the supportive monetary/fiscal policy mix, some growth pick-up would materialise. In the absence thereof, disappointment would follow, leading to even slower growth.

To some degree this depends on what happens to uncertainty. Trade tensions may ease (think of US versus China) but will not disappear. They may actually intensify (think of US versus the European Union). On Brexit, difficult negotiations about the future relationship mean that hard Brexit fears will not disappear.

Inflation is expected to remain low or, in the eurozone, too low. Slower growth implies slower wage growth which makes an acceleration in inflation a more remote possibility.

Official interest in the US and the eurozone will remain very low. Christine Lagarde has said that even 1.6% inflation in 2022 would not be satisfactory, which should be read as ‘does not justify a rate hike’. In the US we actually expect two rate cuts in the first semester in reaction to slower growth.

2020: year of change

Next year may bring change in at least two areas.

The results of the strategy review of the Fed about its objectives, its tools and its communication will be eagerly awaited in the first half of 2020. Any hint at ‘low for longer’ would have an impact on financial markets and the dollar. It will also trigger speculation about whether the ECB, which will also be conducting a strategy review, will follow the Fed’s change in emphasis should there be one.

Hopefully, next year will bring significant change in terms of how to address the huge challenge of global warming. The disappointment of the COP25 in Madrid last week makes the COP26 crucially important and we have to hope that the British government will come up with an ambitious agenda as organiser of the summit.

The recently announced Green Deal of the European Commission with the ambition to make the EU carbon neutral by 2050 has raised expectations of policy measures such as a carbon border tax in order to create a level playing field between production in the EU (and the associated emission regulation) and imports from countries with a looser regime.

In this respect, the ECB will also be watched carefully: Christine Lagarde has made it clear that she was ready to make aggressive strides toward environmental objectives. Howevern, in the ECB’s governing council, opinions are divided as many fear that that the ECB might enter a political minefield.

Thank you for watching EcoTV Week and I invite you to join us again next week.

View more videos Eco TV Week

On the Same Theme

New restrictions weigh on the services sector 1/22/2021
The effect of the restrictions can be seen in the latest Google Mobility Report, published on 19 January, which summarises customer traffic for a large number of countries, using multiple indicators. The Google mobility indicator shows a significant fall in visits to retail and recreation outlets, although less than seen last spring in most countries...
The puzzling disconnect between Treasury and Bund yields 1/15/2021
Yields on US Treasuries and German Bunds tend to be highly correlated but since the end of August, Bund yields have been essentially stable whereas treasury yields have increased.This spread widening is explained by a rising real rate differential, to a large degree due to a decline in German real yields. This could reflect a more gloomy view of bond investors about the growth outlook in Germany and, by extension, the Eurozone. Another, more likely, interpretation is that the real rate risk premium has declined in Germany due to the asset purchases of the ECB. In such case, investors will become increasingly nervous about the prospect that in a post-pandemic world the ECB will eventually have to stop the net purchases under its PEPP.
Uncertainty: lower but still elevated 1/15/2021
The latest readings of our indicators show a decline of uncertainty. Starting top left and moving clockwise, the decline of the media coverage based indicator continues but momentum is slowing and the level remains high. This is unsurprising given the newsflow on new infections. Uncertainty based on company surveys has recently declined somewhat in Germany but, again, the level remains very high. The same applies to the US with respect to sales revenue growth expectations... 
Mobility: What impact from another lockdown and new restrictions on mobility? 1/15/2021
Faced with the resurgence of the pandemic and the discovery of a new, highly contagious variant of the coronavirus, many countries have imposed strict or partial lockdowns to curb the progression of the virus. As a result, there has been a sharp drop in the momentum of retail and leisure traffic flows during the first week of January, as shown by the latest Google Mobility Report dated 10 January...
Why the level of public indebtedness matters: a market perspective 1/11/2021
It is quite likely that, going forward, fighting recessions will be the remit of governments with central banks facilitating this task by creating cheap financing conditions. As a consequence, public indebtedness may very well remain high.One should wonder whether this could end up having negative consequences. A possible transmission channel is the pricing of government debt via a sovereign risk premium. Another factor can also play a role. Since 2015, when German bond yields increased, the rise in Italian yields has been even bigger -so the spread widens- whereas French yields has increased in line with German yields. These results suggests that, even in an environment of public sector securities purchases by the ECB, the high level of Italian debt influences the reaction to movements in Bund yields. Clearly, in the absence of QE, one would expect this effect to be at least as powerful.
New Covid-19 infections continue to cause swings in purchasing managers’ indices 1/11/2021
In order to get a feel about how the Covid-19 pandemic has influenced activity in 2020, it is sufficient to look at one single chart, the composite PMI. Data plunged globally in March and troughed at very low levels in April. The third quarter saw strong activity with readings above the crucial 50 level in most countries. Under the influence of a new wave of infections, sentiment dropped again in the eurozone in November. In the US on the other hand, the index remained well above 50...
Mobility: The year 2021 starts under pressure 1/11/2021
The year 2021 starts under pressure from the rising number of Covid-19 cases in numerous countries. In Europe in particular, countries have had to tighten their health restrictions to contain the spread of the virus. In the weeks ahead, these new restrictions are bound to have a further negative impact on consumer traffic flows in the retail and leisure sectors...
Climate change is accelerating 1/6/2021
The world is rapidly warming up. Between 2010 and 2020, the average temperature increased by around 0.3°C, taking the global warming up to 1.2°C since the pre-industrial time. At this pace, global warming will exceed the Paris objective of 1.5°C before the end of this decade. The impact of global warming has already been felt in many parts of the world: devastating fires in California and Australia, inundations of coastal areas, and prolonged droughts in already dry places. An annual average of 21.5 million people have been forcibly displaced by weather-related sudden onset hazards – such as floods, storms, wildfires, extreme temperature – each year since 2008 (Source: UNHCR). This number could reach 150 - 200 million by 2050. By the end of the century, climate-related deaths may exceed the number who die today from all infectious diseases combined. The Stern report (2006) estimates that on a “business as usual” policy world GDP could be 20% lower by the end of the century compared to a scenario in which global warming is limited to 2°C. The only solution for avoiding this bleak scenario is to speed up the phasing out of fossil fuels. The current sanitary crisis could provide an opportunity for a push in this direction. In Europe, the stimulus plans put an emphasis on green investment. It also makes the climate conference COP26, which will be held in Glasgow in November, crucially important. On this occasion, the countries should agree on a further tightening of greenhouse gas emissions. However, success is not assured, as for many countries the economic cost of the energy transition are an insurmountable obstacle.
The narratives of 2020 12/18/2020
Narratives – the stories people tell about events – may influence behaviour. In future years, several narratives may very well be used when looking back at economic developments in 2020. Big, unanticipated shocks do happen. In terms of monetary policy, a ‘whatever it takes’ attitude prevails. This also applies increasingly to fiscal policy. In terms of financial markets, the dominant attitude towards risky assets is to buy rather than to say ‘bye bye’. With Next Generation EU, the European Union has again demonstrated that, under pressure, it can make big leaps forward. Finally, attention to sustainable growth has become ubiquitous. Some of these narratives provide comfort but several also come with a warning.  
Mobility: between lockdowns and restrictions, the dynamic is stagnating 12/18/2020
At the approach of the holiday season and fearing another resurgence in the coronavirus pandemic, several European countries have tightened their lockdowns to contain the level of contamination. We can expect that in the weeks ahead, these new restrictions will have a clear impact on the momentum of retail and leisure traffic flows.  Over the past week, momentum was already stagnant in most of the European countries, as illustrated by the Google Mobility Report released on 13 December...

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 2609 articles and 681 videos