eco TV Week

Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand?


With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months.


TRANSCRIPT // Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand? : January 2020

With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months. The core of the reform – the introduction of a universal point-based system – has not changed, but some key parameters have been adjusted significantly.

Let’s begin with the first generations to be affected. For those already working and affiliated with the current general pension scheme, the first to be affected would be those born in 1975, instead of 1963. But they will still begin to pay into the new system in 2025. Another novelty concerns younger generations, born after 2004, and who will first enter the labour force in 2022: they will begin paying directly into the new system at that time.

The “pivot age” of 64, another emblematic measure of the reform which was hotly debated, was eventually withdrawn from the draft bill. This was the government’s preferred option for absorbing the projected deficit of the current pension system in 2027. It is now up to a “financing conference”, created specifically for the occasion, to reach an agreement on a new set of alternative measures by the end of April.

However, the reform proposal still contains the notion of an “age of equilibrium” (which corresponds to the age of retirement at full benefits) as well as the bonus/malus system associated with it. This age of equilibrium is also expected to move in line with life expectancy gains. Its starting level must still be determined when the new system takes effect, based on the recommendations of the board of directors of the future National Universal Pension Fund.

Also concerning the system’s financial equilibrium, another key feature is that it includes a golden rule imposing a cumulative positive or neutral balance over a 5-year period. The multi-annual trajectory will be updated each year and the necessary adjustment measures would be taken in case of non-compliance.

The government is also beginning to deal with a series of outstanding issues, notably the specifics of the transition period and the convergence of the parameters of the special and professional pension schemes. Discussions have also begun on the bonus for difficult working conditions and the end of careers, which are some of the other sensitive points of the reform.

To conclude, the presentation of the reform bill to the Council of Ministers is a key step, but much still remains to be done. This can be seen in the positive, albeit critical opinion of the Council of State as well as in the critics about the impact study. Negotiations promise to be fierce when the reform bill is debated in the National Assembly, starting in February. A vote on the reform bill is still expected this summer. Thanks for watching. Tune in again next week for another three minutes of economic news.

View more videos Eco TV Week

On the Same Theme

A V-shaped recovery for France? Not so fast 7/3/2020
Looking at France’s economic situation and prospects, there are grounds for both optimism and pessimism
Much brighter skies in June 6/26/2020
While the economic horizon cleared up a bit in May, the improvement was much bigger in June. Given its construction, our Pulse does not yet show any traces of this rebound, which is just as remarkable as the preceding plunge [...]
The Paris office market: a matter of yield 6/17/2020
As commercial real estate can be seen as a financial asset, analysing spreads between property and government bond yields is a proper way to better forecast price levels.
France: slightly brighter skies in May 5/29/2020
According to May business confidence surveys, France’s economic horizon has cleared up a bit.
The sharp rise in household inflation expectations in April, a signal to be put into perspective 5/6/2020
The sharp rise in household inflation expectations is one of the striking results of the April 2020 INSEE consumer confidence survey. This increase goes the opposite way of the fall in the balance of opinion on price trends over the past 12 months as well as in actual inflation. This large divergence is noteworthy in view of the usual relative proximity of the three indicators. This rise in expected inflation echoes the French people’s feeling, conveyed in the media, that significant price increases have occurred since the lockdown. This is probably the consequence of the composition effect of consumption baskets and not the warning sign of a widespread and substantial pick-up in prices in the making. The more regularly a product is consumed, the stronger the sensitivity to a rise in its price. And this sensitivity can be wrongly extrapolated to all prices. Currently, expenses are mainly incurred on food for which high price increases have precisely been reported as a result of the law of supply and demand. By contrast, because of the lower frequency of refueling, household inflation expectations do not reflect the plunge in oil prices.  
France: shocking figures reveal the extent of the shock 4/30/2020
According to preliminary INSEE estimates, French GDP contracted 5.8% in first-quarter 2020. This contraction gives us a first glimpse of the magnitude of the recessionary shock triggered by the Covid-19 pandemic.
The new government-guaranteed loan in France 4/24/2020
French banks may grant up to EUR 300 billion of government-guaranted loans (‘Prêts garantis par l’Etat’, or PGE) until December 31, 2020. This instrument, which is of an unprecedented scale, is dedicated to helping companies overcome cash-flow difficulties resulting from the coronavirus crisis.
France: historic recession 4/10/2020
We are now expecting a massive recessive shock for the French economy due to the covid-19 pandemic. This pandemic is a huge adverse shock, what we call a 'black swan' event, that is to say an unpredictable event, very unlikely, but with a huge cost.
Massive recessionary shock 4/8/2020
Clearly, 2020 will not be another year of slow but resilient growth as we were forecasting just last quarter. We must now expect a massive recessionary shock triggered by the Covid-19 pandemic. To date, the INSEE estimates the instantaneous loss of economic activity linked directly to confinement measures at 35%, which is equivalent to slashing off 3 points of annual GDP per month of confinement. In March, the business climate was in free fall, which gives us a first glimpse of its scope. A full arsenal of measures have been deployed to mitigate the shock as best possible. According to our estimates, French GDP could contract by 3.1% in 2020, more than the 2.8% decline reported in 2009, before rebounding by 5.4% in 2021. These forecasts are highly uncertain, with risks on the downside.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 2454 articles and 632 videos