eco TV Week

Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand?


With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months.


TRANSCRIPT // Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand? : January 2020

With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months. The core of the reform – the introduction of a universal point-based system – has not changed, but some key parameters have been adjusted significantly.

Let’s begin with the first generations to be affected. For those already working and affiliated with the current general pension scheme, the first to be affected would be those born in 1975, instead of 1963. But they will still begin to pay into the new system in 2025. Another novelty concerns younger generations, born after 2004, and who will first enter the labour force in 2022: they will begin paying directly into the new system at that time.

The “pivot age” of 64, another emblematic measure of the reform which was hotly debated, was eventually withdrawn from the draft bill. This was the government’s preferred option for absorbing the projected deficit of the current pension system in 2027. It is now up to a “financing conference”, created specifically for the occasion, to reach an agreement on a new set of alternative measures by the end of April.

However, the reform proposal still contains the notion of an “age of equilibrium” (which corresponds to the age of retirement at full benefits) as well as the bonus/malus system associated with it. This age of equilibrium is also expected to move in line with life expectancy gains. Its starting level must still be determined when the new system takes effect, based on the recommendations of the board of directors of the future National Universal Pension Fund.

Also concerning the system’s financial equilibrium, another key feature is that it includes a golden rule imposing a cumulative positive or neutral balance over a 5-year period. The multi-annual trajectory will be updated each year and the necessary adjustment measures would be taken in case of non-compliance.

The government is also beginning to deal with a series of outstanding issues, notably the specifics of the transition period and the convergence of the parameters of the special and professional pension schemes. Discussions have also begun on the bonus for difficult working conditions and the end of careers, which are some of the other sensitive points of the reform.

To conclude, the presentation of the reform bill to the Council of Ministers is a key step, but much still remains to be done. This can be seen in the positive, albeit critical opinion of the Council of State as well as in the critics about the impact study. Negotiations promise to be fierce when the reform bill is debated in the National Assembly, starting in February. A vote on the reform bill is still expected this summer. Thanks for watching. Tune in again next week for another three minutes of economic news.

View more videos Eco TV Week

On the Same Theme

Robust rebound 7/7/2021
Based on May and June business confidence surveys, the French economy has been rebounding more vigorously than expected from the third lockdown. We have raised our Q2 growth forecast, from near zero to near 1% QoQ. In Q3, the mechanistic rebound would bring growth to about 3% QoQ. Growth is expected to ebb thereafter as the catching-up effects dissipate, although it should remain high, bolstered by the fiscal impulse. The downside of the vigorous upsurge in demand is that it is squeezing the supply side, which is less responsive. The ensuing supply chain constraints, higher input prices and hiring difficulties are all sources of friction that must be monitored since they could hamper the recovery. GDP growth could average 6% in 2021 (an optimistic forecast that is a half point higher than the June 2021 consensus), and will remain strong at an estimated 4.6% in 2022. In our eyes, the economic risks are balanced: the unlocking of forced savings that have accumulated over the past year is an upside risk, while supply-side tensions and pricing pressures are downside risks. Although the Covid-19 pandemic has diminished significantly, the health risk has not completely disappeared given the rapid spread of variants. 
Business sentiment at the highest level since summer 2007 6/28/2021
Our Pulse continues to show a significant improvement in France’s economic situation in recent months compared to the previous three months. For activity indicators, the blue area largely surpasses the area marked by the dotted line, whereas for the confidence surveys, it exceeds or is very close to the grey hendecagon that delineates the long-term average.
France: economy has the wind of optimism in its sails 6/18/2021
The economic indicators available at this mid-point of the year suggest that the French economy is bouncing back strongly as it comes out of its third lockdown. Granted, there are a few negative numbers in the mix. But these are economic activity data from April, most of which still bear the traces of lockdown.
France: a majority of State-Guaranteed Loans to SMEs were taken on a precautionary basis 6/9/2021
One year after the introduction of State-Guaranteed Loans (SGLs), 39% of managers of the SMEs that took them out have indicated that they have made little or no use of the funds, whilst barely one-third stated that they had used the majority of their loan. This precautionary behaviour led companies to hoard all or part of their SGL in order to build up a liquidity reserve under favourable terms. Meanwhile, the share of managers who expect to repay their loans in full over several years has increased (41% in September 2020 to 56% in April 2021), whilst the proportion expecting to make at least partial repayment in 2021 has decreased (from 36% to 23% respectively). The proportion of companies considering that they will not be able to repay their loan in full has remained fairly stable since the mechanism was introduced (5% in April 2021). With the final subscription date set at 30 June 2021, the EUR 20 bn in Recovery Participatory Loans (“prêts participatifs Relance”) and the Recovery Bonds (“obligations Relance”) will ensure – for eligible companies and until 30 June 2022 – that there is a smooth transition to the ending of Covid support measures for company financing
France: start of the recovery and crisis exit strategy 5/21/2021
At the same time as France’s economic recovery is taking shape, the government is also developing its crisis exit strategy, i.e. the way in which the safety net of emergency measures will be gradually withdrawn as the recovery progresses. This will be a tricky task.
France: ECB rate has less of an impact on the remuneration of NFC sight accounts 5/19/2021
Having been rising for several years now, non-financial company (NFC) sight deposits have been boosted to new record levels in the euro area under the influence of the health crisis and government measures to support company financing. Their outstanding amount reached EUR 2,591 bn for the euro area as a whole in March 2021 (of which 26% in France, 23% in Germany, 14% in Italy and 11% in Spain). Meanwhile, and in keeping with the decrease in deposit facility rate by the ECB, the average return on these deposits continued to decline until 2017, to a greater or lesser extent depending on the country, before stabilizing in the recent period - except in Germany where banks pass more negative rates on to their large corporates and private clients, especially since the further lowering of deposit facility rate from -0.40% to -0.50% in September 2019. In France, the average interest on sight deposits remains positive and significantly higher than in other euro area countries.
April’s lockdown had a mildly negative impact on overall economic activity 5/17/2021
Our barometer shows a marked improvement in France’s economic situation in recent months compared to the three previous months. Yet the improvement is helped by a very favourable base effect. In April 2021, the base effect should be favourable again, despite another lockdown.
Recovery in France: slowed before it started? 5/12/2021
The increase in supply side difficulties identified by INSEE’s economic surveys in April 2021 requires a closer look. It is to be hoped that it will not hold back a recovery that is only just beginning to take shape. The rise has been particularly noticeable in the industry sector and has mainly been blamed on procurement problems that significantly exceed average levels from past years. In the construction sector, a shortage of labour has been the main difficulty (as it was before the crisis) but procurement constraints have also increased sharply. In the services sector, supply side difficulties relate primarily to health protections measures. In this sector however, demand side problems are  affecting a greater number of companies. Procurement issues were also highlighted by the Banque de France in its economic update on 10 May. They were mentioned by slightly over a quarter of companies in the industry and construction sectors, although it is noteworthy to add that they have not so far affected these companies’ own prospects of an improvement in activity levels. This is reassuring and  suggests that if these difficulties do hold back the recovery, the effect will be moderate. This said, a rapid easing of the supply side difficulties will be needed. For those relating to health protection measures, this will come from the lifting of lockdown measures. For the problems in procurement and recruitment the way out is less clear.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 2766 articles and 733 videos