eco TV Week

Spain: the debate on pension reform arises again


On the political front in Spain, the start of the year has been marked by a vigorous debate on pension reform, and more particularly on the question of a possible change in the calculation of pensions.

Guillaume DERRIEN

TRANSCRIPT // Spain: the debate on pension reform arises again : February 2021

On the political front, the start of the year in Spain has been marked by a lively debate on the pension system, and more particularly on the question of a possible change in the way pensions are calculated. Tensions that occurred within the coalition Government itself, between the Social Security Minister José Luis Escrivà and the Deputy Prime Minister Pablo Iglesias.

These discussions are important, given that spending on pensions accounts for more than 12% of GDP today. This figure is likely to increase further in the coming years, as the aging of the population continues.

The question of an overhaul of the pension financing system needs to be asked in Spain. The country is, in fact, one of the developed economies where the long-term trajectory of the pension system seems the least viable. Two main elements contribute to this: (i) a replacement rate, which is one of the highest among OECD countries (ii) a dependency ratio which will increase in the coming years comparatively faster than in other developed countries.

This issue will become even more important in the coming months as the European Commission would require Madrid to guarantee the sustainability of its financing system in order to validate the payment of part of the sums allocated via the European Recovery Fund.

Even if fiscal policy will remain very expansionary in Spain in 2021, a return to more controlled public spending will be necessary in the long term. However, the European Commission estimates that Spain's structural deficit will continue to widen above 7% of GDP in 2022, even as the structural balance of most other European countries will tend to improve.

With the hope of a gradual normalisation of activity as the vaccination campaign progresses, the pressure on Madrid to move faster on its structural reform agenda will intensify. Changes on the pension system is only part of this agenda but will certainly be one of the most politically sensitive.

View more videos Eco TV Week

On the Same Theme

A slow improvement 4/12/2021
The barometer improved in March, driven by the manufacturing sector, where growth continues to pick up strongly. According to the purchasing managers index (PMI), confidence in the Spanish manufacturing sector has increased to 56.9, the highest level in more than 14 years. 
A recovery slow in the making 4/9/2021
Economic growth remains extremely fragile in early 2021. In addition to the Covid-19 pandemic, Spain was hit by Storm Filomena in early January, which has had a direct negative impact, notably on consumption: both automobile and retail sales plummeted this winter. We now expect GDP growth to be flat in Q1. Even so, the economy could rebound strongly either this spring or more certainly by summer, although we cannot completely rule out the downside risks associated with the UK variant and a possible fourth wave of the coronavirus in Spain. We are forecasting real GDP growth of 5.9% in 2021 and 5.6% in 2022, following a record contraction of 10.8% in 2020.
Grounds for hope, despite a glum first quarter in 2021 3/5/2021
Although our barometer generally improved in March, economic growth is set to remain weak in the first quarter of 2021. New car sales were still 40% lower in February 2021 than in February 2020, although the data can be volatile from a month to another...
Catalonia regional election: independence no longer the key issue? 2/11/2021
Elections polls point towards a breakthrough by the Socialist Party and the far right to the detriment of the centre-right Ciudadanos party. Although political risks continue to persist in Catalonia today, the economic downturn caused by the Covid-19 crisis could weaken the momentum for the pro-independence movement and increase support for the Central Government. The Covid-19 crisis has accentuated Catalonia’s dependence on the Central Administration and Europe more broadly.
The epidemic is worsening but confidence shows resilience in January 1/29/2021
Spain’s health situation is still alarming. The pandemic continues to spread, forcing the public authorities to tighten restrictive measures, notably in the Madrid and Valencia regions. Yet the most recent confidence indicators have shown a certain resilience in January, notably the European Commission economic sentiment index.
Towards a protracted increase in the public deficit? 1/21/2021
Strong fiscal support is currently key to limit the impact of the coronavirus shock on growth and employment. But in the long term, the question of public finances control will be asked. In its November forecast, the European Commission predicts that Spain’s structural public deficit will widen to 7.2% of GDP in 2022. This would be the biggest deficit since 2010 – 2009 being a record high – and the largest within the Eurozone. Spain will not stabilise its primary structural deficit, which could surpass 5% of GDP by 2022. Nevertheless, the impact on public expenditures will be softened by low sovereign rates. Three major obstacles – some of which will be amplified by the Covid-19 crisis – will limit any decline in the public deficit ratio: 1) rising unemployment and poverty, 2) the impact of the ageing population on pension financing, and 3) the sluggish level of potential growth.
A fiscal stimulus monitored closely by Brussels 12/17/2020
Forecasts made at the start of the year will probably turn out to be accurate. Spain is set to be the Eurozone’s economy hardest hit by the Covid-19 epidemic. We forecast GDP to shrink by 11.8% in 2020 before rebounding by 7.0% in 2021. The social situation has worsened again this year, forcing the government to introduce new large-scale welfare benefits (e.g. minimum living income), which will be reinforced in 2021. Spain’s huge €140 billion stimulus plan will support the recovery, should raise the country’s potential growth and create jobs. But the structural budget deficit is widening. Once the Covid-19 crisis is over and the recovery underway, Brussels will intensify the pressure on the Government to speed up certain key reforms, and in particular regarding the country’s pension system.
All eyes on the employment figures 11/27/2020
The barometer provides a perfect illustration of the diverging trend observed between manufacturing and services activities. On average over the past three months, the manufacturing purchasing managers’ index (PMI) index has moved above its long-term average, while the indicator for services remains well below this trend...
Spain: 2021 budget unveiled amid health emergency 10/30/2020
The Spanish government presented on October 27 the 2021 budget. This budget, built to face the current crisis, will amount to a record EUR 239 bn, approximately 10% higher than the initial budget for 2020. It contains significant reinforcements on both the social and investment sides. However, the worsening health situation and the introduction of new restrictive measures may force the government to proceed to further budget adjustments in the weeks or months to come.
Slowdown in the economic recovery 10/16/2020
The economic recovery slowed down in September. That said, and as clearly shown on our barometer, the 3-month trend has continued to improve for most indicators – a logical process with the catching-up effect during the summer period...

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 2682 articles and 705 videos