Eco Perspectives

Competitiveness threatened

07/06/2021
PDF

The very accommodative policies implemented by the Federal Council and the Swiss National Bank have been very successful in limiting the economic consequences of the pandemic. In 2020, economic activity contracted by 3%. The latest business cycle indicators point to a strong rebound in the second half of the year. The recovery is broad-based. Private consumption will be one of the main engines of growth, as households will spend part of the savings accumulated during the crisis. The breakdown of the negotiations between the Swiss Confederation and the EU, and the possible introduction of a global minimum corporation tax rate are likely to undermine the country’s competitiveness in the medium term.

Very accommodative macroeconomic policies

GROWTH AND INFLATION (%)

To ease the impact of the pandemic on the economy, the Federal Council (FC) had spent CHF 15 bn (2% of GDP) in 2020, mainly on the short-time working scheme (CHF 10.8 bn) and loss of earnings compensation (CHF 2.8 bn). In addition, in collaboration with the Swiss National Bank (SNB), a loan guarantee programme was put in place. As tax receipts declined due to the contraction in output, the 2020 government budget showed a deficit of 2.6% of GDP, after having showed surpluses in excess of 1% of GDP since 2017. The debt-GDP ratio increased to 40% of GDP.

Fiscal policy is set to remain very accommodative in 2021. In its 2021 budget, the FC has reserved CHF 24.4 bn for expenses related to the pandemic. The budget envelope is very large on purpose to make it possible to react quickly if necessary. It is likely that the ultimate budget deficit in 2021 will only increase to 3.5% of GDP.

The monetary stance will remain very accommodative. The SNB is expected to keep its policy rate at -0.75%, and might intervene in the foreign exchange market to counteract strong upward pressure on the CHF. The easy monetary stance has led to strong price rises in real estate markets.

Strong rebound but risks on the horizon

These policies were very effective, as GDP contracted by 2.7% in 2020, which compares favourably with the neighbouring countries. From September 2020 onwards the country was confronted with a second wave of Covid-19 infections, which forced the FC to re-impose lockdown restrictions. The economy contracted by 0.5% in Q1, after a meagre 0.1% growth in the preceding quarter. However, the decline was much less than in Q2 2020, as growing activity in the manufacturing sector partly offset the sharp decline in services.

From March onwards, business activity picked up again as the authorities gradually removed the restrictions. In May, the KOF economic barometer once again reached a historic high, signalling a strong recovery from the middle of 2021, provided that the containment of the virus continues to progress. The recovery is broad-based as the manufacturing sector is profiting from growing external demand, whereas services are benefitting from the removal of the lockdown restrictions. Private consumption will be one of the main drivers, as households are expected to reduce part of their accumulated savings during the lockdown period. In 2020, household savings amounted to 21% of net disposable income, compared with 16% before the crisis. Economic activity is likely to exceed the pre-pandemic level in the second half of 2021.

Two major risks are threatening the economy in the medium-term. Recently, the Swiss confederation broke off negotiations with the EU on a framework agreement that should regulate the relations between them. The immediate consequences are limited as the 100 and more bilateral treaties remain in force. However, the absence of a framework agreement creates uncertainty for investors on the future relationship. Moreover, it will also hamper the expansion of cooperation in new areas.

The second risk is the movement towards a worldwide minimum corporation tax. In most of the Swiss cantons, the corporation tax is lower than 16%. It is an important argument for attracting new business. If a worldwide minimum tax is agreed, the Swiss cantons will lose this important tool.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Looking beyond peak growth

Looking beyond peak growth

The first half of the year has seen a broad-based improvement in business and consumer sentiment in advanced economies but elevated levels of business surveys reduce the likelihood of further significant increases [...]

Read the article
United States
Is inflation back?

Is inflation back?

With GDP growth of nearly 7% this year, the US economy is in the midst of a spectacular but uneven recovery, erasing the losses generated by the pandemic, but also leaving numerous workers behind [...]

Read the article
China
The economic recovery is still mixed

The economic recovery is still mixed

Economic growth rebounded very rapidly following the Covid-19 shock, but this rebound has also been characterised by mixed performances between sectors and between demand components [...]

Read the article
Japan
A lagging economic recovery

A lagging economic recovery

The Covid-19 pandemic did not hit the Japanese economy as hard as the other advanced countries. In 2020, GDP growth did not contract as much as in other places [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
A stronger recovery, higher inflation and an accommodating ECB

A stronger recovery, higher inflation and an accommodating ECB

The Eurozone economy is bouncing back. From a macroeconomic perspective, the region is closing the gap on the losses accumulated since spring 2020 more quickly than expected just a few months ago [...]

Read the article
Germany
Change in climate

Change in climate

After a sharp contraction in Q1 2020, the economic climate improved significantly in Q2, as the domestic economy gradually opens up [...]

Read the article
France
Robust rebound

Robust rebound

Based on May and June business confidence surveys, the French economy has been rebounding more vigorously than expected from the third lockdown. We have raised our Q2 growth forecast, from near zero to near 1% QoQ [...]

Read the article
Italy
The recovery is gaining strength

The recovery is gaining strength

At the beginning of 2021, the economic growth surprised on the upside. In Q1, real GDP rose by 0.1%. Private consumption declined, reflecting the disappointing evolution of income and a still high propensity to save, investment rose by almost 4% [...]

Read the article
Spain
Economic acceleration in sight

Economic acceleration in sight

Just when the lights seemed to be turning green on the health front, the spread of the Delta variant in Spain, as elsewhere in Europe, is a cause of concern [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Strong recovery, but at the cost of higher public debt

Strong recovery, but at the cost of higher public debt

The Belgian economy grew at an above-potential rate in the first quarter of this year, and looks to be on course to maintain this pace throughout the year. Full year growth is expected to come in at 5.1% [...]

Read the article
Finland
Resilient

Resilient

Although Finland was one of the European countries hit the least by the Covid-19 pandemic, its economic recovery was nonetheless pushed back by a third wave of contaminations in late winter 2020 and early spring 2021 [...]

Read the article
Greece
Mixed signals

Mixed signals

The Greek economy is proving resilient, with the recovery through to Q1 2021 being faster than in most other Eurozone members. This has been driven primarily by the very significant increase in goods exports [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
A poor start

A poor start

No sooner had the divorce agreement with the European Union been signed than the UK started disputing its terms [...]

Read the article
Norway
An economy ready for take-off

An economy ready for take-off

Largely spared by the Covid-19 pandemic, Norway reported one of the mildest recessions in Europe in 2020 (-2.5%) [...]

Read the article