Eco Perspectives

In search of a majority

07/09/2019

Solid growth is bound to slow

As survey data suggests, Spanish growth has proven to be quite resilient to the downturn in the international environment and the European slowdown in early 2019. Activity even accelerated slightly on a quarterly basis, with Q1 GDP up 0.7% q/q, the strongest growth since year-end 2017. Moreover, the breakdown of growth is favourable, and better balanced that we expected. First-quarter growth benefited from a net rebound in productive investment (+6.8% y/y in Q1 2019), and seems to be less dependent than we feared on household consumption (+1.4% y/y) and residential investment (+3.8% y/y), which is still looking upbeat.

Growth and inflation

Foreign trade, in contrast, has continued to contract, a trend that began in H2 2018. Although the decline in exports of goods and services (-0.5% y/y) was limited by the strong performance of tourism, there has been an increasingly sharp drop in imports (-1.2% y/y), which limits the widening of the trade deficit observed last year.

Slowdown ahead Purchasing Manager Index (PMI, points)

All in all, Spanish growth reached 2.4% y/y in Q1, compared to a eurozone average of 1.2%. According to the most recent survey data, a slowdown is very probable as of spring. This slowdown could extend somewhat into the quarters ahead, since the erosion of confidence is no longer limited to manufacturing and has now spread to the services sector. In general, however, GDP growth should have no trouble surpassing an average annual rate of 2% in 2019.

Under this environment, job creations have been very dynamic so far, up 2.5% y/y in Q1 2019, the biggest increase since year-end 2017. After employment bottomed out in late 2013, Spain has created 2.5 million jobs. The unemployment rate has just fallen below 14% of the active population for the first time in ten years, after rising above 26% in 2013, and it should continue to decline in the quarters ahead, albeit at a somewhat slower pace. Job creations, combined with mild inflation (which boosts household purchasing power), are the main source of resilience of domestic demand.

Seeking a majority to govern

Unsurprisingly, Pedro Sanchez came in first in the early legislative elections held on 28 April, with 28.7% of the votes cast. PSOE, the Spanish socialist party, won 123 of the 350 seats in the Chamber of Deputies, the lower house of parliament. This is nearly twice as many as its main opponent, the People’s Party (66 seats), whose support evaporated with the milder wing shifting its support to the centre-right party Ciudadanos (57 seats) and the more radical wing to Vox, the extreme right party (24 seats).

The PSOE victory will not necessarily reinforce Spanish political stability. In its new configuration, the Chamber of Deputies is no less fragmented than the previous one, and the party leader benefits from only 35% of the seats in parliament[1], compared to 39% for Mariano Rajoy and the People’s Party following the 2016 elections.

Seeking a majority Political groups in the lower house of parliament after the 28 April 2019 elections (number of seats

In this situation, Pedro Sanchez has patiently awaited the outcome of the European elections as well as the municipal and local elections before starting the necessary deal making to form a new executive team. The elections revealed that the leader of Ciudadanos, with whom a majority coalition is numerically possible, has rather decided to join the opposition alongside the People’s Party, and was prepared, in some cases, to lend its support to local candidates of the Partido popular who were also supported by Vox.

On the left, no majority coalition is possible without the support of the Republican Left group, which includes the Catalan independentism representatives of the ERC. Apparently, Pedro Sanchez would prefer to form a minority government based solely on the Socialist party, while seeking extra support from different sources depending on the issue. Yet this project runs against Podemos’ plans to integrate the government as part of an official coalition with the Socialist Party. So far, nothing has been decided yet and the two parties are exploring the creation of a “co-operation” government. A first investiture vote is scheduled on July 23rd, but we cannot rule out the possibility that talks will extend beyond the summer break[2]. Despite his electoral victory, Pedro Sanchez’s future government may well have to rely on the support of a coalition as fragile as the one that backed the previous administration.

A smaller deficit despite the lack of a 2019 budget

Fiscal outlook % of GDP

Note that it was precisely after the previous parliament was unable to adopt a 2019 budget that Pedro Sanchez was forced to call April’s early elections. Consequently, the 2018 budget has been automatically renewed for 2019, at least for now, and a series of additional measures were adopted by decree, notably in December 2018.

In terms of spending, these measures validated a general 1.6% increase in pensions, which is well above the legal minimum of 0.25%, and bolstered social welfare and local spending (including the extension of paternity leave, better benefits for unemployed seniors, and an extra boost for small pensions). According to the stability programme submitted to Brussels, increased spending will total about 0.4 percentage points (pp) of GDP, and will be financed by a slightly higher increase in revenues (0.5 pp) through higher social contributions and other taxes.

On the whole, fiscal policy will be slightly restrictive this year according to the authorities, and virtually neutral according to the European Commission. Once again, deficit reduction will be ensured through economic growth and the decline in interest charges. The decline, estimated at 0.1 pp compared to 2018 (interest charges declined from 2.5% of GDP to 2.4%), could be even bigger than expected given recent developments: Spanish 10-year sovereign rates have fallen sharply in recent weeks to 0.4% at the end of June.

All in all, the executive branch expects Spanish public finances to reach a primary balance in 2019, with the public deficit as a whole narrowing to about 2% of GDP, from 2.5% in 2018. In the stability programme submitted to Brussels last spring (prepared by the outgoing interim government), the authorities intended to strengthen structural adjustment measures over the course of the 2019-2022 fiscal programme (for a cumulative total of 1.5 pp of GDP over 4 years), and to reach a public finance equilibrium by 2022 (chart 4). In 2020, fiscal savings measures have already been announced for a total of 0.5 pp of GDP[3], but it is uncertain whether the upcoming minority or coalition government will be in a position to pass them.

[1] The PSOE benefits from an absolute majority in the Senate, where most of the Senators are elected via a majority vote.

[2] In this first vote of confidence, an absolute majority is required to appoint the head of government. In the event of failure, a new vote is held two days later, where only a simple majority is required. If, within two months of this first election, no candidate has won the nomination of the Congress, new elections will be held.

[3] Including corporate tax reforms to limit the fiscal optimisation of major corporations and to lower the rate applied to SME (0.1 pp); a financial transaction tax (0.1pp); an income tax on digital activities (0.1pp) and measures to fight tax evasion (0.1).

THE EXPERT ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Growth concerns on the rise

Growth concerns on the rise

A sigh of relief followed the publication of first quarter GDP data. However since, growth concerns have picked up again on the back of a collection of new economic data but also — and perhaps more importantly — due to continued high uncertainty [...]

Read the article
United States
Monetary policy at a turning point

Monetary policy at a turning point

Although household consumption remained rather buoyant at springtime, foreign trade as well as investment may have weakened. In June, the business survey results were lacklustre, while the Federal Reserve opened the door to cutting interest rates [...]

Read the article
China
Hard blow

Hard blow

With the export sector hard hit by US tariff measures and private consumption growth weakening, investment growth has slowed [...]

Read the article
Japan
Risks on the rise

Risks on the rise

Although Japan’s economic openness is relatively limited, the high concentration of Japanese exports to China, and the other Asian countries in general, creates a major external risk for the dynamics of Japanese growth [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
The ECB lends its support again

The ECB lends its support again

The months pass but nothing seems to change. Growth in the manufacturing sector is struggling to accelerate in a persistently uncertain international environment, while buoyant domestic demand is boosting activity in services [...]

Read the article
Germany
Ebbing confidence

Ebbing confidence

As international trade slows, the economy is mainly supported by expansionary fiscal and monetary policies and real disposable income growth. After a mild contracted in Q2, the economy is expected to grow modestly in the second half of the year [...]

Read the article
France
Growth continues

Growth continues

The signs of stabilisation seen at the beginning of the year have been followed by improvements in confidence surveys. The upturn in consumer confidence has been the most marked and the most encouraging of these [...]

Read the article
Italy
A moderate recovery, in a mixed scenario

A moderate recovery, in a mixed scenario

In Q1 2019, Italy came out of recession. The overall scenario remained mixed. The GDP annual growth rate was negative. Imports strongly declined and exports slightly increased, with a positive contribution of net exports [...]

Read the article
Netherlands
Slowing towards potential

Slowing towards potential

GDP growth is slowing due to the strong deceleration in global trade [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Household spending stabilises growth

Household spending stabilises growth

Over the next quarters economic growth will remain stable. Rising labour market capacity constraints and a lower contribution by net international trade are weighing on the overall outlook [...]

Read the article
Greece
A new majority takes over

A new majority takes over

The economic recovery continues. Growth is accelerating and for the moment it has reached the lower range of expectations [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
Brexit update

Brexit update

Brexit has been behind thirty-seven resignations from the government responsible for managing the process, the latest being that of Prime Minister Theresa May herself [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Growth slows

Growth slows

The robust GDP growth reported in 2018 is bound to slow this year. Sweden’s main trading partners have been hit by slowdowns, which is having a negative impact on export momentum. The slowdown in job creations will also strain household consumption [...]

Read the article
Denmark
Steady growth

Steady growth

Denmark’s small open economy is bound to be hit by the economic slowdown affecting its main trading partners in the quarters ahead. Household consumption will remain the main growth engine thanks to job creations, wage growth and mild inflation [...]

Read the article