Eco Perspectives

The slowdown continues

10/09/2019

During the summer months, the US economy continued to slow although it seemed to be fairly resistant to the headwinds affecting world trade. The annual GDP growth rate dropped to 2%, one point below the 2018 level, which is still an enviable performance when seen from Europe, where recession is looming in countries like Germany, Italy and the UK. Yet, taking a closer look, the US economic slowdown is more severe than it might seem. The only factors limiting the fall in year-on-year GDP growth were public spending and inventory building in anticipation of new tariffs imposed by President Trump. Foreign trade provided a negative contribution, but the bulk of the slowdown was essentially due to domestic factors. It can be attributed to the decline in private investment, which was first seen in residential construction, and then spread to all sectors with the exception of software. Although consumption and employment are both resilient, they seem to be losing momentum. Lastly, business surveys are depressed and do not signal any improvements in the near future.

Downgraded prospects

Growth and inflation

The drop in the Institute for Supply Management (ISM) index for the manufacturing industry, as well as the reversal of the capacity utilization rate, suggest a further decline in capital goods spending. The drop could be particularly severe in the very capital-intensive oil and shale gas sectors, where the first signs of over-investment have emerged (chart 2). With production volumes at an all-time high of 8 million barrels per day (b/d), the profitability of new wells can no longer be taken for granted. Producing less than expected after being drilled too close to one another and operated by heavily-indebted industry players, the number of new wells is trending downwards[1].

Downturn in the investment cycle

US household consumption – which at USD 14,000 billion a year is five times higher than French GDP – is by far the most powerful driving force of domestic demand. In 2018, the combination of tax cuts, job creations and consumer credit created a rather high-octane fuel, but the mixture has weakened in 2019. Companies are not only re-assessing market outlets and scaling back investment, they are also slowing the pace of hiring. Net job creations have fallen to a monthly average of 161,000 between January and September, the lowest number in nine years. Given the population inflow into the labour market (1.8 million on average in 2018), job creations hardly suffice to bring down the unemployment rate, already standing at all-time low (3.5% in September). Farmers and purchasing managers are no longer the only segments of the population suffering from President Trump’s trade war. Even though consumer goods are not affected much, higher import tariffs are having a non-negligible impact on inflation (see box 3). Faced with higher prices for capital goods and inputs manufactured in China, there has yet to be a significant shift in demand towards other countries[2]. US companies are bearing the costs, modulating the efforts granted by suppliers and their reactions to exchange rates. In the end, the impact on prices paid by end consumers is estimated at a few tenths of a point[3]. After holding to a slowing trend recently, core inflation rebounded to 2.4% in August. This has lowered the growth of real disposal income for US households.

Escalation of the US-China trade war

Consumer credit is also less buoyant, which is not unusual at this stage of the business cycle: household non-mortgage debt has increased 55% from the 2009 low, coming back to relatively high levels as regard of disposable incomes. Car sales have matched all-time highs, so that the fleet has been largely renewed. Lastly, banks are tightening lending conditions at a time when transformation conditions have deteriorated due to the inversion of the yield curve (Wheelock, 2018)[4].

More key rate cuts

In the months ahead, the Federal Reserve (Fed) will need to steepen the yield curve, which means further monetary policy easing. The Fed funds target rate has already dropped from 2.5% to 2%, and we think it could be lowered further, to 1.75% at end-2019 and 1.25% at end-2020.

Of course, the official position remains cautious and does not signal such a move. Having foregone “forward guidance”, Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell has linked any policy changes to upcoming economic publications. He also pointed out that monetary easing phases can sometimes be very short[5]. Yet he did not cite the most pertinent example: the Fed cut its key rates in the fall of 1998 to counter the potentially systemic effects of the quasi-bankruptcy of an entire hedge fund[6], not to accompany a cyclical downturn, as now seems to be the case.

[1] The Wall Street Journal (2019), Shale Boom Is Slowing Just When the World Needs Oil Most, Sept. 29

[2] French Treasury (2019), Impact of first US-China trade tensions, Lettre Trésor-éco n°244, September

[3] Jean S. & Santoni G. (2018), How Far Will Trump Protectionism Push Up Inflation?, CEPII Policy Brief n°23, December. The two authors estimate that the sanctions already imposed on China (25% tariffs on USD 250 billion in annual imports) triggered a 0.25%-0.38% increase in inflation.

[4] Wheelock D. (2018), Can an Inverted Yield Curve Cause a Recession?, Federal Reserve Bank of Saint Louis Blog, Dec. 27

[5] Powell J., Press conference following the Monetary Policy Committee meeting of 18 September 2019

[6] In this case, Long Term Capital Management (LTCM)

THE EXPERT ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Global growth slowdown intensifies

Global growth slowdown intensifies

The slowdown of global growth has gathered pace, forcing the Federal Reserve to cut the federal funds rate on two occasions, whereas the ECB has announced a comprehensive easing package. Nevertheless, the slowdown is expected to continue [...]

Read the article
China
Difficult policy choices

Difficult policy choices

Since Q2 2018, Beijing has let the yuan depreciate against the dollar each time the US has raised its tariffs on imported goods from China [...]

Read the article
Japan
The export sector is a source of concern

The export sector is a source of concern

Japanese GDP growth was stronger than expected in early 2019. Despite the current troubles in the export sector, for the moment domestic demand - both public and private - is picking up the slack [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
The ECB opts for more monetary support: how effective will it be?

The ECB opts for more monetary support: how effective will it be?

At its September monetary policy meeting, the European Central Bank delivered a strong message. Through the broad mobilisation of its unconventional monetary policy tools, it aims to fulfil its mandate and reach its inflation target [...]

Read the article
Germany
Unchanged policy despite stagnation

Unchanged policy despite stagnation

Weak data and business cycle indicators suggest that German economy would be in a mild technical recession. The weakness is mainly in the manufacturing sector and has hardly affected the rest of the economy [...]

Read the article
France
Proven resilience

Proven resilience

The French economy continues to show proof of resilience judging from the stability of its GDP growth?–?at an annualised rate of just over 1%?–?and the relatively strong showings of confidence surveys and of the labour market [...]

Read the article
Italy
A long lasting stagnation

A long lasting stagnation

The new Government has approved the update of the economic and financial document, planning to raise the deficit to 2.2% of GDP in 2020. The 2020 Budget Law is estimated to amount to EUR 30 bn [...]

Read the article
Spain
Back to the ballot box

Back to the ballot box

Spanish voters will be called back to the ballot box on 10 November, but there is no certainty that the election results will pull the country out of its current impasse. The political landscape is still too fragmented to produce a lasting coalition [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Domestic demand under pressure to keep delivering

Domestic demand under pressure to keep delivering

Belgian GDP growth is expected to come down from last year’s 1.4% to a mere 1% in 2019 and 0.7% in 2020. This reflects a further slowdown in international trade, which is only partially offset by resilient domestic demand [...]

Read the article
Austria
Vote of confidence in conservative policies

Vote of confidence in conservative policies

After its electoral success in late September, the conservative party (ÖVP) is expected to form a new government. To obtain a majority, the party could turn again to the FPÖ (far right) [...]

Read the article
Portugal
Renewed confidence

Renewed confidence

The economic slowdown has been very gradual so far, but it is expected to progressively spread during the second half of 2019 and in 2020 [...]

Read the article
Finland
Growth slows

Growth slows

Finnish growth had only just regained some momentum in 2015 before slowing again in 2018. GDP growth is expected to weaken further in the quarters ahead [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
Brexit update

Brexit update

As we approach 31 October 2019, the latest deadline for the British exit from the European Union (Brexit), who can say where the UK is heading? Probably not the Prime Minister itself, Boris Johnson, who lost his majority in the House of Commons in an attempt to suspend discussions and fuelled scepticism among his European partners by presenting a take it or leave it ‘compromise’ on the Irish backstop that is hardly applicable nor acceptable. This would leave the Brexit end-point with no deal, although this has been prohibited by a law, or the more likely, but by no means guaranteed, outcome of a new extension accompanied by an early general election.

Read the article
Norway
Resilient growth

Resilient growth

The Norwegian economy is expected to report robust GDP growth through the end of 2019, thanks to dynamic oil sector investments in Norway and abroad. Growth is expected to slow thereafter in a less favourable international environment [...]

Read the article