Based in Paris, BNP Paribas' Economic Research Department is composed of economists and statisticians:
The Economic Research department’s mission is to cater to the economic research needs of the clients, business lines and functions of BNP Paribas. Our team of economists and statisticians covers a large number of advanced, developing and emerging countries, the real economy, financial markets and banking. As we foster the sharing of our research output with anyone who is interested in the economic situation or who needs insight into specific economic issues, this website presents our analysis, videos and podcasts.
+ 33 1 55 77 71 89 guillaume.a.derrien@bnpparibas.com
The Italian economy began 2022 on a wrong footing, with a 0.2% q/q contraction in real GDP in the first quarter. The country has been hit hard by the war in Ukraine and by lasting disruption in world trade. These factors are having a particularly strong effect on economies with a large industrial base, as is the case in Italy. Inflation, which was 6.3% y/y in April (down from 6.8% y/y in March), has also had a significant negative effect on household confidence. According to the European Commission, consumer confidence increased very slightly in April (the balance of opinion rose 1.9 points to -22), but March had been the worst month since January 2014.
The sharp rise in energy prices since April 2021 has been the main driving force behind the current surge in Eurozone inflation. The outbreak of war in Ukraine on 24 February accentuated this trend, sending the energy component of the harmonised index of consumer prices (HICP) up 44.4% y/y in March 2022. Faced with this situation, the governments of the four main Eurozone economies under review in this article have acted to try to buffer the shock on economic players, and notably on household purchasing power, via direct subsidies, tax cuts, price regulations and measures to boost nominal incomes
Latest inflation figures give the Spanish government a little respite. Having approached 10% in March (9.8%), consumer price inflation fell to 8.4% in April. Measures taken by the authorities to stem the rise in energy prices – mainly through subsidies and tax cuts – had a beneficial effect. However, food price inflation rose to 10.1% y/y in April. In addition, its contribution to overall inflation (1.98 percentage points) is now roughly the same as other energy-related components of expenditure, i.e., transport (1.98 points) and electricity, gas and other fuels (2.30 points).
The Spanish housing market is building momentum again after its deep correction between 2008 and 2013, which erased part of the excesses created over the early 2000s. In 2021, transaction volumes hit their highest level for twelve years. House prices have been growing at an average of 5% per year over the past six years. Housing activity is now benefiting from multiple sources of support: the post-Covid economic recovery, higher levels of household savings, growth in employment, low borrowing rates. Rising housing prices are driven by limits on housing supply, which are likely to persist, given rising construction costs as a result of higher materials expenses
After the World Trade Organisation (WTO), the International Monetary Fund also revised significantly lower its forecast for global trade for 2022. Exports are now expected to rise by 4.4%, compared with an estimate of 6% in October. This is above the WTO’s projections of 3% growth in 2022. Given the sharp rebound seen in 2021 – an increase of 9.8% – a lower rate of growth in goods exchange was expected. However, the war in Ukraine and the difficulties facing China in terms of its economy and the public health situation are important headwinds to growth. Some signs of this slowdown can already be seen: the global manufacturing PMI index for new export orders dropped sharply in March (-2.8 points to 48.2), reaching its lowest level in 18 months (chart 2)
Inflation in Italy reached 6.7% y/y in March, the highest level since July 1991. In addition to the spectacular rise in energy prices (electricity, gas & fuel) – up 50.9% y/y – there are now significant increases in prices for food products (+5.8% y/y), furniture (+8% y/y), as well as for the hotels & restaurants sector (+4.6 % y/y). That said, two consumption items are still in deflationary territory: education (-0.5% y/y) and communication services (-2.9% y/y). Nonetheless, the hardest part has yet to come: the latest PMI survey for March showed once again a significant increase in input prices, which was the strongest on record (+6.7 points to 81.5). This will feed through to higher consumer prices: this PMI index is indeed very well correlated with the CPI.
While the US Federal Reserve has begun raising its policy rate, the Bank of Japan continues to pursue a very accommodating monetary policy. The sharp depreciation of the yen leaves the BoJ less manoeuvring room to pursue its yield curve control policy. Some adjustments in its policy are expected. Economic support – both monetary and fiscal – will be maintained in 2022 in an environment that is especially tough for Japanese industrial companies, hard hit by global supply chain disruptions and the economic slowdown in China.
Although Spain is not the European country with the highest “structural” exposure to the war in Ukraine, it has been hard hit by the energy price shock. Inflation will certainly exceed 10% year-on-year this spring. Higher petrol prices have triggered protests that have spread across the country, disrupting economic activity even though the impact on growth should be modest. Job creations were still resilient in Q1. Household confidence as well as business expectations of future orders both dropped sharply with the outbreak of the war in Ukraine, which will have an impact the dynamics of hiring. The recovery of the tourism industry will partially offset the loss of consumer spending due to the erosion of household purchasing power in Spain.
The large victory of António Costa’s Socialist party in February’s legislative elections provides some welcome political stability in the current economic environment. Even though the inflationary shock in Portugal is not as strong as in most of the European countries, and despite support measures introduced by the government, confidence surveys declined sharply in March. It remains to be seen how much this deterioration will alter hiring dynamics. So far, the job market is still on a positive trajectory, with an unemployment rate this winter close to the levels reported in the early 2000s.
Rising inflation has eroded household confidence in Spain, which in March reported the sharpest drop since the European Commission’s statistical series began in July 1986. So far, business confidence is holding up better according to PMI and European Commission surveys. Yet there are clear signs of an economic slowdown to come: the new orders component of the PMI index has declined due to a sharp deterioration in external demand. Another notable change is the extension of goods delivery times in the manufacturing sector (the PMI index was down 9.1 points to 22.4). It is now at approximately the same level as in November 2021, the worst month on record for the current statistical series.
In Spain, the change in house prices and the transaction volume are highly correlated. In an upswing, the latter will be supported by attractive borrowing conditions and confidence in the economic outlook, thereby causing a rise in house prices, which in turn can fuel expectations of further increases and hence raise the transaction volume. Real estate activity in Spain rebounded sharply in 2021 following a drop in 2020 due to the health crisis. The number of housing transactions exceeded 674,000 last year, the highest level since 2007. Even so, this was nearly 30% below the 2006 peak. Demand is still buoyed by historically low borrowing costs and a rising number of Spanish households. As a result, house prices rose significantly in 2021 (at annual rate of 3
Countries neighbouring Russia and Ukraine are more exposed than those in Western Europe. Among the latter, there are differences, with Germany and Italy being more dependent on Russian gas than France, Spain or Portugal. The countries that import the most from Russia are also the most dependent on Ukrainian imports. The exposure of European countries to Russia and Ukraine, and their vulnerabilities to the economic repercussions of the war between these two countries, result primarily from the high weight of their imports of Russian energy supplies and Ukrainian food and agricultural products
Given the obstacles piling up for the global economy, there was concern that the consensus forecast of a significantly weaker Tankan survey would end up being too optimistic. Upon its release, it turned out not to be the case, with some series below consensus and other slightly better. The overall conclusion is clear however: the report was indeed less positive than in the previous quarter.
Bottlenecks in shipping transport are already intense and could get worse. First, it is becoming very difficult, not to say impossible, to move merchandises by rail and road networks between China and Europe, because of the routes crossing Russia and the conflict zones in Ukraine. Furthermore, many Chinese production lines, and logistics around the country’s ports, have been disrupted by a resurgence of Covid-19 cases and the authorities’ ‘zero-Covid’ policies.
Italy’s industrial output fell 3.4% month-on-month in January. There is now a high risk that GDP will contract again in Q1 because of the war in Ukraine and the impact of surging commodity prices on Italy’s economy. Italy is particularly dependent on Russian gas, with almost 45% of its imports coming from this country. Even if Rome is planning to carry out a drastic shift in its gas imports – sourcing gas from other countries like Algeria and Azerbaijan – and to increase its LNG consumption, these changes will take time to materialise.
Abundant job creations in the Eurozone helped bring down the unemployment rate to a historically low level in 2021, but this has also led to hiring difficulties and labour shortages. Labour shortages seem to be having the most restrictive impact in Germany (in all sectors), given the already low unemployment rate. They seem to be weakest in Italy where the job market is less dynamic, and this hierarchy was confirmed regardless of the sector. In France, labour market tensions are the highest in the construction, and comparatively less important in the manufacturing and services sectors. Production constraints due to labour shortages have reached a record high in the services sector, especially in Germany
After a spectacular rebound in 2021, global trade in goods is likely to see slower growth this year. The World Trade Organisation’s latest forecasts show that trade in goods will rise by 4.7% this year, following a jump of 10.8% in 2021. The global PMI manufacturing new orders index also fell below the 50 threshold in January, for the first time in a year and a half. That said, the slowdown will not be visible in all sectors. Indeed, demand for semiconductors remains very high, and this dynamic largely explains why Taiwan continues to record rapidly rising export orders.
In Japan, possibly more than anywhere else, it is important to distinguish the dynamics between headline and core inflation. Headline inflation – at 0.5% in January – is bound to rise further, led by higher energy prices. By contrast, core inflation is still deeply in deflationary territory, and this trend is amplifying. Excluding perishable food products and energy, the consumer price index (CPI) declined by 1.2% year-on-year in January, the biggest decline since March 2011. The services sector even has reported the strongest deflation since 1970 (-2,8%), mainly due to the sharp drop in mobile phone charges, down more than 50% since March 2021. Medical services were also down (-0.8% y/y), as was durable household goods (-3,0% y/y), and leisure goods (-1.1% y/y)
Concerning the Italian economy, now that the presidential election is behind us, attention has focused again on the risks associated with surging inflation and the upcoming start of the normalisation process of ECB monetary policy. 10-year Italian government bond yields have risen by nearly 50 basis points since early February, and they could reach the 2% threshold very soon.
As shown on our Pulse, the sharp increase in inflation has continued in January, with the harmonised index of consumer prices (HICP) up 6.1% y/y in January. Although the details of last month’s inflation have not yet been revealed, energy prices should remain, unsurprisingly, the main driver of higher consumer prices. The energy element of the HICP recorded a jump of 40.2% y/y in December 2021, whilst the sector’s production prices nearly doubled (+95.9% y/y) between December 2020 and December 2021.
Although Germany is not the eurozone country experiencing the highest inflation rate, the trend is nevertheless uncomfortable. Consumer prices posted another hefty rise in January (+5.1% y/y, harmonised index), although this was less than in December 2021 (+5.7%). The end of positive base effects – caused by the end of the VAT rate cut in place in the second half of 2020 – did not therefore result in a marked fall in inflation.
2022 will be another tense year for international trade. Although some of the tensions are easing, visibility is still limited and supply-chain bottlenecks will probably continue for much of the year, affecting the outlook for growth and inflation.
With less than two weeks to go before Italy’s presidential election – the first round of voting takes place on 24 January – a candidacy of the current Prime Minister, Mario Draghi, remains a distinct possibility. If Mr Draghi becomes Italy’s president, this would probably have repercussions for the current governing coalition, although it is not currently possible to predict what they might be. In the meantime, Covid-19 cases are continuing to surge, with around 170 000 new contaminations recorded in mid-January. This has prompted the government to make vaccinations compulsory for people aged over 50.
The fairly substantial upgrade to Spain’s Q3 GDP figures underlined again the problems that the Spanish statistical office (INE) is currently facing when collecting data. To recap, third-quarter growth was revised up from 2.0% q/q to 2.6% q/q and this follows a large downgrade for Q2, from 2.8% q/q to 1.1% q/q. Employment will remain in the spotlight in 2022, since it offers a parallel measurement of economic activity and one that is currently more accurate than GDP.
The indicators currently available for the end of last year suggest that Germany recorded weak growth at best in Q4 2021: a GDP contraction cannot be ruled out. Industrial orders remained at a relatively strong level, but production continued to be held back significantly by supply problems for certain components.
