Based in Paris, BNP Paribas' Economic Research Department is composed of economists and statisticians:
The Economic Research department’s mission is to cater to the economic research needs of the clients, business lines and functions of BNP Paribas. Our team of economists and statisticians covers a large number of advanced, developing and emerging countries, the real economy, financial markets and banking. As we foster the sharing of our research output with anyone who is interested in the economic situation or who needs insight into specific economic issues, this website presents our analysis, videos and podcasts.
+ 33 1 42 98 26 77 stephane.colliac@bnpparibas.com
The INSEE business climate indicator saw a moderate downturn in April. This suggests that the upturn seen at the beginning of the year will not last.
In Western Europe, in Q4 2022, the number of business insolvencies returned to levels close to those seen at the end of 2019. This increase conceals national disparities. The United Kingdom and Sweden saw it earlier, as weakening growth and tightening of monetary policy occurred earlier in these countries (and more significantly for the United Kingdom) than in the eurozone. In the eurozone, the increase in insolvencies remains partial, but is likely to continue.The situation in the various sectors reflects these differences. As a result, the increase is almost across all sectors in the United Kingdom and Sweden, particularly in construction and even more so in trade.In France, business insolvencies are approaching their pre-Covid levels but are still 6.1% lower in Q1 2023
Evidence of falling housing prices remains patchy. After a sustained rise throughout 2021, residential housing prices in the main European countries continued to resist the tightening of credit conditions in the fourth quarter 2022, with the notable exception of Sweden and Germany. A generalisation of real estate price declines in 2023 is a significant possibility.
Germany is the Western European country where GDP growth was the most negative in Q4 2022 (-0.4% q/q). Furthermore, economic indicators, although improving, remained relatively downgraded weak at the beginning of 2023. A further contraction in GDP in Q1 2023 therefore remains our central scenario. However, more favourable signals (peak inflation exceededslight disinflation, reopening of China, reduced supply shortages in the automotive sector) could lead to a return to growth from Q2. This has already been reflected in household confidence, although the weakness of growth in the euro area, since Q4 2022, could limit the intensity of this recovery.
The energy crisis was less severe than initially feared during the autumn and winter. This prevented negative growth during Q4 2022 (+0.1% q/q) and provided grounds for relative optimism, as reflected in the rise in the INSEE business climate indicator from December to February. While the growth carry-over naturally led us to revise our growth forecast for 2023 upwards, growth is still low and reflects the sustained downturn in demand, particularly in household investment. In addition, while inflation is expected to decrease, it is still being buoyed by food prices, which, in turn, is adversely affecting household consumption.
The UK economy avoided recession in H2 2022 thanks to corporate investment and public and private consumption. Inflation figures in February surprised on the upside and remained at an exceptionally high level, which should continue to erode household purchasing power. As a result, the recession may only have been postponed. We now expect GDP to contract by -0.3% QoQ in Q1, then by -0.2% in Q2 2023. Faced with this situation, the Bank of England (BoE) is not expected to raise its key rate beyond a final hike of 25 basis points in March. This, plus accelerating disinflation, would allow a rebound in growth from H2 onwards.
The upturn in the INSEE business climate indicator in February was not confirmed in March although, despite the downturn noted, this indicator remains above levels seen between September 2022 and January 2023. Although the March survey highlights forthcoming disinflation, this drop remains relative and is not general. At the same time, we are seeing continued pressure from household demand, with the confirmed weakness of retail trade (excluding automotive) and the renewed deterioration of the business climate in construction.
With a peak in inflation last autumn and fears of energy shortages during the winter, the IFO’s index hit an historic low in October 2022. This index has recovered to normal levels, as winter turned out better than had been feared. However, following the poor performance of Q4, all signs point to this being just a “technical” rebound in activity.
Industrial activity saw a clear upturn in January (+3.5% m/m), after a significant downturn in December (-2.4% m/m). For example, intermediate goods and construction, which fell sharply in December, returned to a level of production close to that of November.
In February 2023, although to a lesser extent, INSEE’s business climate survey rebounded, by 1 point to 103, reaching its highest level since August 2022. It was supported by the services sector and by industry.
Business insolvencies started to increase again in Western Europe during 2022. In the United Kingdom and Sweden, where growth has deteriorated since the start of 2022, these insolvencies were even higher than their pre-Covid level, with a more significant increase in retail and wholesale trade. In the Eurozone, insolvencies are still below pre-Covid levels, but the current tightening of credit conditions raises the risk that they will reach those levels during 2023. This also applies to France, where there is a risk of wider negative consequences, in particular because these insolvencies take the form of liquidations to a greater extent than before Covid.
The European Commission survey of consumer confidence has found, over the past four months, a marked improvement amongst German consumers, driven by an upturn in their expectations for the general economic situation. Conversely, French consumer confidence remains depressed and is still not showing any sign of improvement. Assessments of the past situation are also diverging, with that in Germany also improving, albeit to a lesser extent.
In 2022, the contribution of French foreign trade to GDP growth was one of the most negative in its history (-0.8 percentage points), hindered by deterioration in three areas.
Business climate indicators show relative improvement (for example, the IFO rose from 84.3 in September 2022 to 91.1 in February 2023), attesting to better than expected business activity, particularly as fears of a worsening energy crisis did not materialise. However, these indicators are still below normal, in line with negative growth in Q4.
According to Insee, the business climate in the French manufacturing industry was stable over the last few months. Deterioration was seen in services, albeit gradual, with the index sliding from 107 in August to 104 in December, before climbing back up to 106 in February. This picture is in keeping with a slower pace of growth, while avoiding recession.
The improvement is evident in the services sector, manufacturing industry and in the automotive retail trade. However, the construction sector is an exception, against a backdrop of a downturn in activity in new housing. Inflationary pressures are expected to increase in the retail sector.
According to our estimate, the trade deficit (goods) reached almost EUR 160 billion in 2022, after 85 billion in 2021. This sharp deterioration is mainly due to the rise in the prices of French energy imports, including oil. However, it seems that the balance on manufactured goods has also continued to deteriorate, including when viewed in terms of volume.
GDP growth surprisingly increased in the 4th quarter, reaching +0.1% q/q (after +0.2% q/q in the 3rd quarter), compared with -0.2% based on our forecast. Corporate investment was one of the factors behind this relative resilience, with a further rise of 1.2% q/q (having already grown by 3.8% q/q in the 3rd quarter). Conversely, consumer spending was undoubtedly the weak link in demand, with a drop of 0.9% q/q.
The French economy is exposed to both negative and positive factors. The recession risk is significant, as inflation acceleration has weighed and should continue to weigh on consumer appetite. However, some factors may drive growth, as e.g. the gradual recovery of their output to pre-Covid levels. Many sectors have already reached this target, but the manufacturing sector (particularly automotive and aeronautics) still experiences various factors limiting their production. If these bottlenecks ease, growth may well surprise on the upside.
Business climate indicators in recent months have been affected by the significant impact of the energy shock, as well as by fears that this shock will get worse during the winter. The difficulties linked to the international context (before China’s economy opened up again) have also hurt the German economy.
The gradual deterioration in the business climate suggests a slowdown in French growth, which may even have fallen into negative territory in the 4th quarter, a contraction which would be consistent with the decline in the balance of opinions about production in the economic survey in industry.
In France, business insolvencies reached 41,020 units in 2022, according to the provisional estimate of the Banque de France. Over the year as a whole, they were up sharply compared to 2021 (+49%) but remained 20% below their 2019 level.
Outlook for GDP growth, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates
The figure zero should define French growth in 2023. The carryover should be zero, due to a second half-year 2022 in which the positive performance observed in the third quarter should be cancelled out by negative growth in the fourth quarter (with a key contribution of a further drop in household consumption). The quarterly growth momentum recorded in 2023 is not expected to provide any further support. A further contraction in GDP is expected in the first quarter, mainly due to a further acceleration in inflation and the probability of lower inventories in companies. The upturn expected to occur from the second quarter should be moderate, limited to offsetting the drop in the first quarter
The construction output index is defying the most pessimistic outlook. In October, it reached its best level since January 2021, up 1.1% month-on-month and 2.6% year-on-year, while new orders are eroding. However, the cumulative order books (8.7 months according to INSEE, close to the historical level of 9 months) remain substantial and their implementation is lagging behind.
