Based in Paris, BNP Paribas' Economic Research Department is composed of economists and statisticians:
The Economic Research department’s mission is to cater to the economic research needs of the clients, business lines and functions of BNP Paribas. Our team of economists and statisticians covers a large number of advanced, developing and emerging countries, the real economy, financial markets and banking. As we foster the sharing of our research output with anyone who is interested in the economic situation or who needs insight into specific economic issues, this website presents our analysis, videos and podcasts.
+331 58 16 03 63 helene.baudchon@bnpparibas.com
In January 2023, according to S&P Global PMI data, the business climate continued to improve for the third month in a row, bringing the composite index just above the 50-point expansion mark for the first time since June 2022. This recovery applies to both the manufacturing sector and services, and it is good news. We regard it as a sign of relief following over-pessimism at the end of 2022 fuelled by fears about energy supply and soaring prices. A relapse cannot be ruled out.
Signs from the ISM business climate surveys were contrasting in January, with a further decline in the manufacturing sector index, going deeper into the contraction zone at 47.4, while the non-manufacturing sector made a strong rebound to 55.2, cancelling out almost its entire December fall.
Following a 0.5% m/m fall in GDP in December according to the ONS, activity in the UK deteriorated in January before making a strong rebound in February according to the PMI survey, particularly in the service sector. The PMI was 49.2 for the manufacturing sector and 53.3 for services. Among the bad news, company insolvencies (up 59% y/y in 2022) reached their highest level since 2009.
While goods disinflation is expected to increase, or even turn into deflation in the coming months, services inflation is expected to show more inertia (due in particular to the shelter component), slowing the overall decline in inflation.
Surprisingly, according to European Commission surveys such as the Standard Poor's Global PMIs, the business climate improved quite significantly in the Eurozone despite the accumulation of setbacks. The improvement was evident in all activity sectors as well as in relation to advanced components (for new orders). However, the level of the surveys remains relatively depressed.
Outlook for GDP growth, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates
It seems highly likely that for the eurozone, 2023 will bring an easing in inflation, a contraction in GDP and a peak in the ECB’s policy rates. The uncertainties lie in the scale of disinflation and of the recession, and in the level and timing of the peak in rates. According to our forecasts, the fall in inflation will be rapid on the surface (with headline inflation dropping from around 10% y/y in Q4 2022 to 3% in Q4 2023), but this will mask a slower fall in core inflation, which we expect to remain above 2% in a year’s time, from 5% at present. In the face of this persistent inflation, we expect the ECB to hike its deposit rate by 100bp, to 3%, by the end of Q1 2023 and then maintain this restrictive level throughout the year, despite the recession
An update of the GDP Growth and inflation data, interest and exchange rates
Following in the footsteps of the US inflation figures for October, Eurozone inflation also surprised favourably by coming in below estimates. Eurostat’s flash estimate of an annual rate of 10% in November was lower than the consensus figure of 10.4%. This raises hopes that Eurozone inflation has finally peaked, and indeed this looks likely. It is our scenario, but considerable uncertainty remains and caution is required.
Harmonised inflation in the Eurozone surprised again unfavourably in October, reaching 10.7% year-on-year according to Eurostat’s preliminary estimate, compared to the Bloomberg consensus forecast of 10.2%. It was the second month in a row of such a large acceleration in prices (+0.8 points). This was not the only bad news: half of this acceleration can be attributed to core inflation, 0.3 points to food inflation and 0.1 points to the energy component. Inflation therefore continues to spread and to strengthen. While the persistent and common component of inflation (PCCI) seems to have peaked in May this year (at 6.4%), its decline since then (5.5% in September, latest available figure) is not yet visible in the other measures of inflation.
Dark clouds are continuing to gather over the Eurozone economy. The first set of data available for September is not positive and this can be seen in our Pulse. Looking at the survey data, the blue area (recent conditions) is shrinking when compared to the dotted line (conditions four months earlier) and even, on some indicators, when compared to the grey dodecagon (the long-term average). The opposite is true for the inflation data. In fact, inflation reached a new level, at 10% y/y in September according to Eurostat’s preliminary estimate. Not only did inflation reach double figures – which was predictable, but still bad news – but its 0.9–points rise compared to July was broad-based across all its main components.
The current unprecedented combination of shocks (inflation, health crisis, geopolitical issues, energy crisis, climate, monetary issues) is likely to overburden the Eurozone resilience and push the region into recession over the coming quarters. The deterioration in confidence surveys this summer provides an early indication of this likely outcome. However, we expect the recession to be limited in scope, in large part due to budgetary support. This recession should be followed by a moderate recovery as the various shocks start to ease. Faced with the continued surge in inflation, the ECB has moved up a gear
An exceptional response to exceptional circumstances. There is a high probability that the ECB will raise its policy rates by 75 basis points at its meeting on 8 September. The fact is that the ECB has little choice but to respond with extraordinary measures to the continuing surge in inflation, despite the increased risk of recession. This is putting into practice the hawkish statements of Jackson Hole and the unconditional determination displayed to maintain price stability.
On the economic front the eurozone has seen a succession of similar-looking months, with inflation continuing to rise and confidence surveys continuing to fall to different extents. Although there is a clear deterioration in the economic situation and outlook, its scale and duration remain uncertain. A recession is getting more likely but is not (yet) a certainty, first because activity levels remain strong and not all the economic indicators are flashing red (particularly when it comes to the labour market) and secondly because growth has some tailwinds or, at the very least, shock-absorbers.
Until May, Eurozone growth has been relatively resilient to the series of shocks that have swept the region, but its pace should slow more significantly in the months ahead. We cannot rule out the possibility of a recession, even though that is not our base case given the numerous sources of growth: post Covid-19 catch-up potential, surplus savings, investment needs and fiscal support measures. Our scenario appears to signal stagflation (inflation will be much higher than growth in 2022 and 2023), but with the big difference that the unemployment rate is not expected to rise much. The ECB is preparing to begin raising its key policy rates to counter the inflationary shock. We are looking for a cumulative 250bp increase in the deposit rate, bringing it to 2% by fall 2023.
At its 10 March meeting, the ECB paved the way for raising its key deposit rate, although the timing of the first rate increase remained uncertain at the time: the odds of a September move had declined compared to a few weeks ago and July was excluded, which left December. The wait-and-see approach still seemed appropriate given the increasing downside risks to growth, aggravated by the current inflationary shock, the war in Ukraine and China’s zero-Covid strategy. Yet economic data reported in the meantime, as well as the hawkish tone of several ECB members, seems to have accelerated the tempo. Concerning data, it is the combination of high inflation, a weak euro and relatively resilient growth that has moved forward the lift-off date.
In the space of just a few months, growth prospects in the eurozone have deteriorated markedly. So much so that the risk of a recession is looming this year. Between our growth forecast from early 2021 – when it peaked at 5.5% – and our current scenario, drawn up in mid-March 2022, expected growth has been about halved; we now expect a figure of 2.8%. As recently as November 2021, we were still forecasting 4.2%. This figure of 2.8% still looks very high, as it is well above the long-term trend rate of 1.6% per year on average between 1996 and 2019. However, it relies on an exceptionally high growth carry-over of 2.1% in Q1 2022 and, for the subsequent quarters, on projected weak but positive growth
The war in Ukraine compounds the ECB’s task of balancing the fight against inflationary risks with the need to support growth. At the monetary policy meeting on 10 March, inflation was the predominant concern and the central bank announced that net securities purchases under the Asset Purchase Programme (APP) would probably end in Q3. This paves the way for the first increase in the key deposit rate, although the timing of the move is still highly uncertain. The inflationary shock is spreading while growth faces ever greater threats. Even so, pre-existing cyclical momentum, excess savings, investment needs and fiscal support measures should all help ease the risk of stagflation.
Of the Eurozone’s four major economies, Germany has the least positive growth outlook for 2022. Its economy is expected to grow by around 2% this year, whereas we are forecasting around 3% in Italy and France, and around 5% in Spain. Germany also has a lower Q4 2021 growth carry-over, greater exposure to the economic repercussions of the war in Ukraine, and pre-existing supply-chain problems in its manufacturing industry. The fall in the ifo index in March, particularly the business expectations component, illustrates well these headwinds, and this decline serves as a recession alert.
Countries neighbouring Russia and Ukraine are more exposed than those in Western Europe. Among the latter, there are differences, with Germany and Italy being more dependent on Russian gas than France, Spain or Portugal. The countries that import the most from Russia are also the most dependent on Ukrainian imports. The exposure of European countries to Russia and Ukraine, and their vulnerabilities to the economic repercussions of the war between these two countries, result primarily from the high weight of their imports of Russian energy supplies and Ukrainian food and agricultural products
Eurostat’s flash estimate puts eurozone inflation for March at 7.5% y/y, representing another very substantial increase (up 1.6 points on the February figure). Inflation continues to be driven mainly by energy prices – the energy component contributed 4.9 percentage points to this figure, thus explaining 65% of the total – but the other components (food, manufactured goods, services) are also seeing increases and each contributed around one point. Thus, inflation is getting more widespread and all eurozone countries have been affected by its recent acceleration, albeit to varying degrees.
Abundant job creations in the Eurozone helped bring down the unemployment rate to a historically low level in 2021, but this has also led to hiring difficulties and labour shortages. Labour shortages seem to be having the most restrictive impact in Germany (in all sectors), given the already low unemployment rate. They seem to be weakest in Italy where the job market is less dynamic, and this hierarchy was confirmed regardless of the sector. In France, labour market tensions are the highest in the construction, and comparatively less important in the manufacturing and services sectors. Production constraints due to labour shortages have reached a record high in the services sector, especially in Germany
First of all, we will pay particular attention to the extent of the upward revision of the European Central Bank's inflation projections. We expect major revisions given the latest developments and the most recent inflation figures, which continue to rise (headline inflation hit 5.8% y/y in February, according to the Eurostat flash estimate, and core inflation was 2.7% y/y).
Usually close, French and German inflations, measured on a comparable basis by Eurostat’s harmonized index of consumer prices (HICP), have diverged sharply since the beginning of 2021, with inflation on the other side of the Rhine largely exceeding that in France. In November 2021, the gap reached +2.6 percentage points compared with an average of +0.2 pp since 1991. This difference is, for a part, due to a VAT effect: the decrease in the German rates in the second half of 2020 initially pulled down German inflation but the return to their previous level reverted that trend in 2021. In January 2022, with the end of this VAT effect, German inflation fell back quite significantly (to 5.1% y/y according to Eurostat’s flash estimate, from 5.7% in December) but is still very high
Economic newsflow was particularly rich last week. The first important items, looking in the rear-view mirror, were the first growth estimates for Q4 2021 in France, Germany and Spain. Performances were mixed, between the 0.7% q/q contraction in Germany, further strong growth of 2% q/q in Spain and, between these two, growth of 0.7% q/q in France.
