eco TV
Weaker economic outlook for the eurozone 1/8/2019

After strong economic growth in 2017, the eurozone has been slowing down. Rising uncertainties in Europe and elsewhere weigh on the economic environment, in particular on Germany, the eurozone’s main growth engine.

Risks are building up for the economic outlook, but the labour market still remains a bright spot.

TRANSCRIPT // Weaker economic outlook for the eurozone : January 2019



François Doux: Three questions on the Eurozone economic situation.

Louis Boisset, hello.


Louis Boisset: Hello François.


François Doux: A key and obvious trend, the Eurozone economy is slowing, with growth of barely 0.2% in the third quarter of 2018. Economic indicators are also falling. What are the reasons for that?


Louis Boisset: Firstly, we should bear in mind that the slowdown was partly expected after strong economic performance in 2017. However, the extent of the slowdown has been surprising. There are several possible explanations for this poor performance. Firstly, increasing uncertainty has been a global trend, in both political and trade terms. But there are also more specific reasons, such as difficulties in the German auto sector in the third quarter, which dragged down growth. German Q3 growth was negative for the first time since early 2015. We saw slightly negative growth in Italy as well.


François Doux: For my second question, can you tell us about more secular indicators, Louis?


Louis Boisset: Yes, there are several of them, and increased trade tensions in particular are among structural risks, especially for countries like Germany that depend on their export sector. We can moreover note that foreign trade has weighed on Eurozone growth since the start of 2018, whereas it significantly supported it in 2017. Taking a wider view, we should keep in mind that escalation of trade tensions could weigh on economic agents – consumers and businesses – confidence and that would eventually cause a sustained drop in aggregate domestic demand, i.e. consumer spending and investment.


François Doux: Aren’t there some indicators that can give us a little optimism?


Louis Boisset: Absolutely. Firstly, the labour market is improving. The unemployment rate has been falling steadily and is now at its lowest level for 10 years. The employment rate has seen a sustained rise and is now above its pre-crisis level, while Eurozone wage growth has been accelerating since mid-2016. That acceleration in wages should support consumer spending, which would in turn be beneficial for jobs.


François Doux: My third and final question: what are your macroeconomic forecasts for 2019-2020?


Louis Boisset: We expect the slowdown to continue, with economic growth of 1.4% in 2019 and 1.2% in 2020. We expect inflation at 1.8% in 2019, and to fall slightly to 1.5% in 2020. However, core inflation should strengthen, because of faster wage growth.


François Doux: Louis Boisset, thank you.

View more videos Eco TV

On the Same Theme

Eurozone labour market: disparate improvements 1/10/2019
Employment in the eurozone has risen vigorously since 2013, and the unemployment rate has dropped to a 10-year low. Yet broader indicators suggest that labour market slack is still high in some countries, since the improvement has not been uniform across the board. In the midst of an economic slowdown, the big question is whether the rebound in wage growth will continue.
Credit impulse 12/21/2018
After stabilizing between July and September, the credit impulse declined in October, still reflecting an acceleration of loans to the private sector on a year-on-year basis, but less buoyant.
ECB: From quantitative easing to quantitative pausing 12/14/2018
As expected, the ECB Governing Council has decided to end the net purchases in the context of its asset purchase program. This new phase can be called quantitative pausing, before eventually moving to quantitative tightening, i.e. to shrink the size of the balance sheet. The end of net purchases increases the role of forward guidance as an instrument to control interest rate expectations. The enhanced forward guidance, i.e. continuing to reinvest for an extended period past the first rate hike, should be welcomed.
Signals less negative than expected, but downside risks to growth 12/14/2018
Even though most headline indicators exceeded downbeat expectations in November 2018, they remain on a declining trend. The PMIs for Manufacturing and Services, pulled down by the sharp decrease in the French PMI related to heightened social tensions, just managed to stay above the expansion line. Economic activity slowed to 0.2 % in Q3 2018, which actually reflects some divergent developments.
10-year record high wage growth in the Eurozone 12/12/2018
Nominal wage growth* in the Eurozone (« Labor compensation per employee ») has reached +2.5 % year-on-year in the 3rd quarter of 2018, a 10-year record high. Wage acceleration lasts since the 3rd quarter of 2016. At the same time, the unemployment rate has significantly decreased in the Eurozone since the sovereign debt crisis to hit 8.1 % in the 3rd quarter 2018. This is the lowest level since the end of 2008 and equals the potential level estimated by the European Commission for the year 2018. Upward trend of wage dynamics are experiencing by several member States. In a framework of historical low level of unemployment and despite the current economic slowdown, wage growth is particularly pronounced in Germany (+3.2 % in the 3rd quarter of 2018). *Total wage per employee, including social contributions (from employers and employees)
IFRS 9 first time adoption: Significant cost differentials amongst banks 11/28/2018
The adoption of IFRS 9 accounting standard on 1st January 2018 significantly changes the impairment model for bank assets. Expected credit losses (and not only incurred losses) are now recognised using a more prospective approach than previously required. IFRS 9 introduces an intermediary category for performing assets whose credit risk has nonetheless increased significantly since their initial recognition, even though no credit event has occurred. Such “phase 2” led banks to recognise additional provisions for impairment whereas the quality of their portfolios remained unchanged. The decline in common equity tier 1 attributable to IFRS 9 should not be interpreted as a decline in banks’ loss absorbing capacity. Some of the prior “unexpected losses”, previously covered by regulatory capital, are now covered by accounting provisions replacing the former.
Strengthening resilience 11/23/2018
Support seems to be growing for the proposal of France and Germany for a eurozone budget. This would contribute to a much needed enhancement of economic resilience, that is the ability to cope with shocks. Resilience can also be strengthened through private and public risk sharing and policies seeking to boost potential growth. Boosting resilience is all the more important considering that risks to global growth seem to be tilted to the downside.
Cooler sentiment 11/9/2018
Sentiment indicators continue their softening trend and the flash estimate points towards weak third quarter GDP growth. Yet drivers of final demand continue to point towards ongoing good growth in the upcoming quarters. Data in the coming weeks as well as developments concerning Brexit and US trade policy will be key to confirm or tune down this assessment. 
Eurozone: Credit pulse 10/31/2018
After a rebound in June, the pulse of lending stabilized in September. This dynamism is due to the continued acceleration of loans to non-financial corporations and, to a lesser extent, households. Loan demand by households remains more favorably oriented than that of non-financial corporations, while the credit conditions continue to ease but not as fast as in August.
Eurozone: heading towards slower growth 10/26/2018
Judging by recent macroeconomic indicators, beating consensus expectations is becoming increasingly challenging. Moreover, certain indicators are now close to or even below their long term average. These developments point towards a softer growth outlook. At yesterday’s ECB press conference, Mario Draghi described this as a loss of momentum whereby growth normalises, coming from a pace which was well above the potential growth rate. The view that it’s a normalisation and not a downturn is based on a combination of factors: income growth, corporate earnings growth, credit growth, low interest rates. Uncertainty has increased (Brexit, market volatility, Italy’s budget) but to quote the ECB “risks remain balanced”.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 1994 articles and 547 videos