In Q1 2024, business insolvencies in France reached nearly 15,000 units. This is only slightly less than in Q4 2023, which was marked by a sharp rise. Although the construction and retail trade sectors are facing a significant increase in the number of businesses affected, insolvencies in these sectors remain below historic highs. On the other hand, records were set in business services and in transport and storage services.
Key figures for the French economy compared with those of the main European countries, analysis of data on the population and the French labour market, activity by sector, publication administration figures, inflation, credit and interest rates, corporate and household accounts.
In the United States, economic policy uncertainty, based on media coverage, fell significantly in February, following a rebound in January. The index fell from 124 to 97, the lowest level since July 2023, when the policy rates were last raised. With US growth and the labour market continuing to hold up well, the economic outlook appears to be brighter and less uncertain. This gives greater credit to the scenario of a soft landing for the economy, and greater comfort for the Fed’s cautious stance and to take its time before cutting rates.
After the youth unemployment rate (15-24 years old) hit its lowest level for more than 30 years at the end of 2021, standing at 16.4% of the working population, it has risen slightly since then, with a figure of 17.5% in Q4 2023 (compared to 16.7% in Q1 2023). Despite being almost 3 points above the Eurozone average, this rate is still substantially lower than the 2019 one (20.8%).
To achieve its climate goals, the European Union (EU) should cut by 90% its greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 (compared to 1990 levels), according to a recent recommendation by the European Commission. This means rapidly increasing investment in renewable energies, electricity grids, transport infrastructure and thermal renovation of buildings. The result is a substantial financial burden (estimated at between 58 and 66 billion euros per year in France), but also a heightened quest for technological and human resources. For its ecological transition, the Old Continent is looking for computer scientists, civil engineers, electromechanics, building and public works managers, plasterers, electricians, roofers and more.
With zero growth in the last quarter of 2023, the Eurozone has narrowly escaped recession, but economic activity is still hanging by a thread. Over 2023 as a whole, the increase in real GDP just reached 0.5%, and the carry-over effect for 2024 is null, as a result of a second half that was even weaker than the first one. Nevertheless, our Nowcast currently indicates growth of 0.3% q/q in Q1 2024, which is higher than our December forecast.
January's business confidence surveys showed signs of improvement. The composite PMI index points to an expansion in activity (51.5), driven by the ongoing solid performance of the services sector (52.1). The manufacturing sector is also seemingly enjoying a bit more tailwind at the start of this year. After ten months of contraction, the associated PMI is showing signs of recovery (49.2; +3.1 points), with Spanish companies reporting a lesser deterioration of all sub-indices, with the exception of the sub-index relating to suppliers' delivery times (44.5; -3.5 points).
The economic situation in the UK continued to deteriorate in Q4 2023. Real GDP contracted 0.3% q/q, after falling 0.1% q/q in Q3. Although economic activity remained marginally in positive territory for 2023 as a whole (with 0.1% growth), it deteriorated throughout the year, resulting in a negative carry-over effect for 2024. The growth outlook for 2024 is even more unfavourable, as economic activity is expected to stagnate in H1 before a sluggish recovery from summer onwards.
Japan entered a technical recession in H2 2023. The first estimate of Q4 GDP indicates a modest contraction of -0.1% q/q following a more significant downturn of -0.8% q/q in the previous quarter. More symbolically, Japan lost its ranking as the world's third largest economy (in nominal GDP) to Germany. Nevertheless, the strength of economic activity in H1 2023 had given the Japanese economy a significant growth carry-over, allowing the average annual growth rate to reach +1.9% for the year (compared to +0.9% in 2022).
After a short respite in December, uncertainty about US economic policy, based on media coverage, rose again in January. This resurgence in uncertainty was likely caused by the latest US inflation figures, which proved more persistent than expected: it remained above 3% in January (3.1% year-on-year, according to the BLS Consumer Price Index) and turned out to be higher than consensus expectations (2.9%). During its mid-December meeting, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) made it clear that it would not be appropriate to cut rates in the absence of certainty as to whether inflation was on a sustainable downward path towards its 2% target.
French growth weakened in 2023, as evidenced by the low figures for the business climate indicators in December. However, 2024 should kickstart the road to recovery. The major drop in energy prices from the levels seen at the start of 2023 will contribute to inflation continuing to fall, which is not expected to be jeopardised by most of the price-cap mechanism still in place for electricity being removed. The upturn in real wages, the healthy state of the aeronautics sector and the continued greening of the economy should enable a soft landing for growth in 2024, with an annual average figure of +0.6%. The expected slight rise in unemployment and the more pronounced increase in business insolvencies pose downside risks, however.
The Bank of Japan’s latest Tankan survey, published in December, highlights the country’s significant labour shortages and recruitment challenges. These are affecting all sectors and are even reaching record levels in almost a quarter of them. In order to facilitate the interpretation, the data in this table are converted in Z-score, which measures the number of standard deviations separating each index from its long-term average (1974-2023 period).
The economic picture during November and December reveals some divergence between Europe, on the one hand, and the US and Japan, on the other hand.
The end of the year is shaping up to be a difficult one for the eurozone, as displayed by the flash PMI indicators for December. The composite index, fell by 0.6 points to 47, and remains below the threshold of 50 (in contraction territory) for the seventh month in a row. The employment index has not plummeted, but has been gradually declining since April, reaching 49.6 in December, its lowest level in three years. At 6.5% in October, the unemployment rate in the eurozone stabilised at a historically-low level, which is increasingly looking like a floor. We expect the jobless rate to rise slightly over the next few months, in line with current trends in the PMI indices. The unemployment rate for young people (under 25) has already risen by one percentage point in six months, to 14
The business climate indicators highlight a still deteriorated situation, raising fears of another quarter of contraction in activity (-0.1% q/q in Q4 according to our forecasts), following four quarters of stagnation or decline (including -0.1% q/q in Q3). Indeed, the indices linked to current conditions in the IFO and ZEW surveys remained close to historical lows, in both industry and services. Expectations of a small improvement are based on the anticipation of the ECB’s monetary easing in 2024, which remained uncertain for the time being.
The signs of the French economy cooling down intensified in December, with a further fall in the flash composite PMI to 43.7 (44.6 in November). The manufacturing PMI has been below 50 for 11 months and hit a new low in December, as did the services PMI.
Economic growth is slowing down in Italy. After contracting by 0.4% q/q in Q2, economic activity only grew by 0.1% q/q in Q3, almost standing still in that quarter. This small rebound was led by consumer spending (+0.6% q/q, contribution of 0.4 percentage points) and foreign trade (+0.8 points). Nevertheless, these positive developments were counterbalanced by significant destocking. For its part, investment recorded a quarterly change of -0.1% in Q3.
Contrary to the trend observed in the other three major eurozone countries, Spain recorded a more moderate fall in inflation in November. According to the INE, the growth in the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) slowed by 0.2 pp to 3.3% y/y this month (while the decline reached 0.7 points in France and Germany, and 1.1 points in Italy). Based on recent trends in the producer price index, which recorded its eighth consecutive month of deflation in October (-7.8% y/y), this consumer price slowdown is set to continue, and even accelerate, over the coming months.
The ISM Report on Business showed an improvement in non-manufacturing activity in the United States in November, with the corresponding index rising to 52.7 (+0.9pp). Conversely, the ISM Manufacturing index was stable (46.7), as the improvement in new orders was offset by a deterioration in production and employment. This result is consistent with our forecast of a slowdown in the US economy in Q4, with the GDP growth rate edging down to +0.4% q/q according to our forecast (versus +0.6% for the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow estimate, and +1.3% in Q3). However, the prospect of a recession is gradually receding, and we now expect a single quarter of contraction in 2024 (-0.3% q/q in Q2, with Q1 expected to be flat).
With the more pronounced disinflation of consumer prices and wages, the Bank of England’s decision to keep the bank rates unchanged at its meeting on 14 December was widely expected. Nevertheless, as in the euro area, the signal for a monetary pivot did not come. In fact, the three members of the MPC in favour of a rate hike in November maintained their position in December.
The revision of Japanese growth figures was unfavourable, resulting in a greater decline in GDP in Q3 than initially estimated (-0.7% q/q versus -0.5% q/q). The downward adjustment is largely due to greater destocking: the negative contribution was increased from -0.3 percentage points (pp) to -0.5 pp. Other significant revisions came from residential investment (from -0.1% q/q to -0.5% q/q), private consumption (0.0% q/q to -0.2% q/q) and public investment (-0.5% q/q to -0.8% q/q). Low household consumption can be explained by the contraction of real wages for the 19th consecutive month in year-on-year terms (-2.3% y/y in October). Overall, private demand reduced quarterly growth by 0.6 pp in Q3.
Business insolvencies continued to rise in October and are now 10% higher than their pre-COVID level (2019 figures) in cumulative terms over the last three months, according to data from Banque de France.
After several quarters of high job creation (89,000 on average between Q2 2022 and Q1 2023), Q3 confirmed the loss of momentum observed in Q2 (37,000 new jobs after 27,000). Payroll employment in construction and the temporary employment sector are contracting. However, industry continues to create jobs (12,000), as do non-temporary trade services (34,000).
The momentum of private payroll employment has recently slowed in the euro area, as evidenced by job destruction in France and Germany in Q3. This destruction can be partly explained by cyclical sectors, particularly construction. It is a sign that demand constraints are increasingly impacting companies and the labour market.However, labour shortages remain high in the northern countries of the euro area and in Central Europe and, in general, in sectors where demand is not falling (aeronautics and building renovation in particular). Beyond an economic slowdown, which we expect to last until spring 2024, impacting employment, the low level of unemployment and historically high labour shortages should continue to characterise the European economy.
