Japan is heading for a year without quarterly growth. Domestic demand is still constrained, with nominal wages rising at a slower pace than inflation. In addition, the trade policy of the United States, Japan’s largest export market, poses a downside risk.
The upward trend in nominal wages continued in January, with contractual wages scheduled to rise by 3.2% y/y, a record since 1992. However, the real wages index fell sharply to -1.8% y/y in January (-2.1 pp), its lowest level since March 2024. At the same time, the unemployment rate was stable at 2.5%.
According to the Jibun Bank PMI survey, the Japanese economy has started 2025 in different directions. The manufacturing PMI fell to 48.7 in January (-0.9 pp, the lowest since March 2024), against a backdrop of a wider deterioration in production and new orders. By contrast, the services PMI accelerated according to the flash estimate, with Business Activity rising from 50.9 to 52.7.
The Japanese economy continues to be characterised by weak growth, which slowed in Q3. The positive momentum in inflation and wages is in line with the Bank of Japan's objectives. This picture should enable the Bank to continue its gradual monetary tightening. However, domestic political developments (general elections resulting in a loss of political strength for the government), as well as external ones (Donald Trump's victory) are not helping stability.
The Japanese economy slowed down in the third quarter, with GDP growth declining to +0.2% q/q (-0.3 pp) – a pace that is expected to continue in the fourth quarter. However, it is worth highlighting the acceleration in private consumption (+0.9% q/q, +0.2 pp). Conversely, investment figures were negative, both for the residential component (-0.1% q/q, -1.5 pp) and the non-residential component (-0.2% q/q, -1.1 pp). The largest negative contribution (-0.4 pp) came from net exports, with growth in imports (+2.1% q/q) significantly exceeding the exports one (+0.4% q/q).
Activity surveys were negative in October. Jibun Bank’s preliminary survey reported a decline in the manufacturing PMI to 49.0 (-0.7pp). The decline was more pronounced for activity in the services sector, with the corresponding PMI losing 3.8pp to 49.3, contracting for the first time since June. According to the Bank of Japan’s (BoJ) quarterly Tankan survey, the overall business climate improved slightly in Q3, but remained stable for large manufacturing companies. We expect growth to fall to +0.3% q/q in Q3 (-0.4pp compared to Q2 2024), due to the dissipation of the technical upturn that had buoyed it in the previous quarter.
The Bank of Japan is continuing with its incremental and cautious monetary tightening, with a single policy rate hike in Q3, which is expected to precede further movement in December, while the July decision has contributed to major financial market volatility. At the same time, the economy is recovering from a turbulent start to the year and inflation is still above the 2% target. In addition, the country has a new Prime Minister and early general elections are now scheduled for October 27th.
Japan's economic growth should benefit from a technical upturn in Q2: we expect growth of 0.5% q/q after the contraction in Q1 (revised downwards to -0.7% q/q). The outlook remains negative – particularly for demand, despite the tax cuts introduced in June – while household consumption spending contracted by -1.8% y/y in May. Furthermore, while wage increases (excluding bonuses) reached their highest level since 1993 in May (+2.5% y/y), a sign of the growing transmission of negotiated wage increases (+5.1% y/y according to the Rengo trade union), real incomes are still not rising (-1.4% y/y).
While quarterly growth and inflation are expected to rise in the second quarter, the Bank of Japan is proceeding cautiously following its decision in March to end negative interest rates. A new plan for the pace of bond purchases will therefore be presented in July, while we expect just one further rate hike this year, probably in September. In addition, the domestic currency has continued to deteriorate, prompting the authorities to intervene in the foreign exchange market and fuelling fears of imported inflation.
In line with our expectations, the Japanese economy experienced a 0.5% q/q contraction in GDP in Q1 2024. This contraction was likely linked to the disruptions caused by the earthquake on 1 January on the Noto peninsula and the temporary closure of car manufacturing plants amid a safety scandal. GDP components pointed to a broad weakness in the economy with, primarily, a fourth consecutive contraction in household consumption, which was the main driver of the fall. In addition, the release was accompanied by growth in Q4 2023 being revised down to +0.0% q/q (from +0.1% previously). However, activity is expected to rebound in Q2, with our forecasts pointing to a growth rate of +0.8% q/q.
The Bank of Japan has made an admittedly expected, yet nonetheless historic, decision to end its so-called Negative Interest Rate Policy (NIRP), against the backdrop of an almost unprecedented long-term rise in the general price level. However, monetary normalisation will be an incremental process, with the current weak business activity, illustrated by an expected negative growth rate in the first quarter of 2024 and low expectations for the entire year, leaving no scope for any significant tightening.
March saw an improvement in activity in Japan, according to the Jibun Bank PMI survey. Both the manufacturing index (48.2, +1.0pp), thanks to a widespread rise in the main sub-components, and the non-manufacturing index (54.9, +1.3pp) recovered, allowing the Composite index to reach its highest level since August 2023 (52.3, +1.7pp).
Japan entered a technical recession in H2 2023. The first estimate of Q4 GDP indicates a modest contraction of -0.1% q/q following a more significant downturn of -0.8% q/q in the previous quarter. More symbolically, Japan lost its ranking as the world's third largest economy (in nominal GDP) to Germany. Nevertheless, the strength of economic activity in H1 2023 had given the Japanese economy a significant growth carry-over, allowing the average annual growth rate to reach +1.9% for the year (compared to +0.9% in 2022).
Faced with a natural disaster and a political crisis, 2024 is off to a rocky start for Japan. However, the economic impacts of the earthquake that struck the country’s west coast on 1st January 2024 are expected to be fairly limited due to the authorities’ effective preparations and quick response in dealing with this type of event. After an expected growth of +0.4% q/q in the fourth quarter of 2023, activity should slow in the first quarter of 2024, although it will remain positive at 0.2% q/q. The fall in inflation and bond yields at the end of 2023 is providing some breathing room for the BoJ, which is expected to end its negative interest rate policy in March or April
The Bank of Japan’s latest Tankan survey, published in December, highlights the country’s significant labour shortages and recruitment challenges. These are affecting all sectors and are even reaching record levels in almost a quarter of them. In order to facilitate the interpretation, the data in this table are converted in Z-score, which measures the number of standard deviations separating each index from its long-term average (1974-2023 period).
The revision of Japanese growth figures was unfavourable, resulting in a greater decline in GDP in Q3 than initially estimated (-0.7% q/q versus -0.5% q/q). The downward adjustment is largely due to greater destocking: the negative contribution was increased from -0.3 percentage points (pp) to -0.5 pp. Other significant revisions came from residential investment (from -0.1% q/q to -0.5% q/q), private consumption (0.0% q/q to -0.2% q/q) and public investment (-0.5% q/q to -0.8% q/q). Low household consumption can be explained by the contraction of real wages for the 19th consecutive month in year-on-year terms (-2.3% y/y in October). Overall, private demand reduced quarterly growth by 0.6 pp in Q3.
The preliminary GDP estimate for Q3 shows a contraction of -0.5% q/q, while the most recent economic surveys have confirmed the slowdown in activity. The composite PMI fell 1.6 points in October, but remained in expansionary territory, standing at 50.5. This deterioration is due to the decline in the services PMI, which was down by 2.2 points (51.6 compared to 53.8 in September). The manufacturing PMI stabilised in contraction zone at 48.7.
Monetary policy desynchronization between the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Japan (BoJ) has become huge. This has caused a significant weakening of the yen. Higher US yields have also exerted upward pressure on JGB yields, which in turn has forced a gradual adjustment of the BoJ yield curve control policy (YCC). Inflation developments in Japan increase the likelihood of a policy rate increase but policy normalization is a delicate task for domestic reasons as well as international spillovers. The BoJ has chosen a cautious approach, with very incremental steps, but in the meantime the yen has continued to weaken, creating the risk of a snapback once policy is tightened. Acting sooner rather than later seems to be the recommended route for the BoJ.
Japanese economic surveys are sending out mixed signals. On the positive side, the business condition index from the Tankan survey improved from 8 in Q2 to 10 in Q3, driven by services: business confidence in the sector was the highest since 1991. The PMI for services is also proving resilient. Although down 0.5 points in September, it remains in expansionary territory at 53.8. Conversely, the manufacturing PMI fell further into the contraction zone for the fourth consecutive month (-1 point to 48.5). As a result, the composite PMI dipped to 52.1 in September. The Economy Watchers Survey dropped from 3.7 points to 49.9 points in September.
In recent decades, Japanese companies have extended significantly their activity abroad. According to the Ministry of Industry data, a quarter (25.8%) of the total turnover of Japanese manufacturers is now coming overseas subsidiaries.
After sustained growth in H1 2023, driven by external demand, the Japanese economy is beginning to slow down. Private demand (household consumption, corporate investment) is offering little support for growth. Although inflation has stabilised at around 3%, it is eroding household purchasing power, which is still not benefitting from significant wage increases. Nevertheless, according to the Ministry of Finance data, corporate profits hit a new record in Q2. Fostering a better redistribution of profits to wages remains a priority for Fumio Kishida’s government, which is preparing a new wave of budgetary measures in October
Japanese economic surveys remain positive overall, despite contrasting results for August: the composite PMI was up 0.4 points to 52.6, while the Economy Watchers Survey fell by 0.8 points, returning to its June level of 53.6.
The Japanese economy continued its post-pandemic recovery in May and June, although this remains fragile. According to the final estimate for May, industrial production contracted by 2.2% m/m but increased by 4.2% year-on-year. At the same time, activity in the tertiary sector grew by 1.2% m/m and 1.8% y/y. The latest PMI survey also indicates that economic activity expanded in June (composite index in expansion at 52). Nevertheless, a distinction must be made between the manufacturing sector index, which fell back into the contraction zone (49.8), and the services index, which continued to grow (54), although at a slower pace than in May.
After inflation, would it be the turn of wages to change gear in Japan? The report published by the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare on July 7th shows indeed a notable increase in (scheduled) base wages in May, up 1.0% m/m, the largest monthly increase since the start of current statistics in 1990.
Inflation in Japan continues to rise, spreading to all the items in the consumer price index. Inflation expectations remain anchored around the 2% target and price increases should remain at this level in the medium term. We expect the Bank of Japan (BoJ) to raise the 10-year sovereign rate ceiling to 1% in July, before ending its yield curve control policy by the end of 2024. Real GDP grew by 0.7% q/q in Q1 (+2.7% in annualised terms), mainly supported by household consumption and non-residential investment. The return of foreign tourists (+71% q/q in Q1) also enabled activity to rebound after two disappointing quarters. Although slowing, growth should continue in Q2 (+0.5% q/q) and throughout the second half of the year, reaching 1.1% in 2023.
Japan is the world’s fourth largest economy. The country has one of the largest financial systems in the world. The country experienced remarkable growth after WW2, which ended with the bursting of the asset price bubble in the early 1990s. It was followed by a period known as the ‘lost decade’. Real economic growth dropped and inflation started to inch down, turning negative in the latter half of the 1990s. Fiscal stimulus and loose monetary policy were not successful in reviving the economy, but resulted in huge government debt.
The election of Shinzo Abe in 2012 has led to a reinforcement of loose monetary and fiscal policy to reinvigorate the economy. The so-called Abenomics strategy was built around three arrows: fiscal stimulus, a very loose monetary stance and structural reforms.
Progress on structural reforms needs to be further intensified to raise the economy’s potential growth and tackle significant demographic challenges. Progress has been made, for example, in increasing women’s participation in the workforce. However, one of Japan’s most serious structural problems is the rapidly ageing population. According to official projections, the Japanese population could shrink by over 25% in the next 40 years. This would have a significantly negative impact: in addition to negative effects on productivity and potential growth, for example a rise in the dependency ratio will reduce the tax base and limit the reduction of the primary deficit.
