Industry stalls, services resist. The May PMI flash estimate for services returns in expansion territory (50.2). However, the flash composite index remains below this threshold (49.4) due to a deterioration in industry (-0.3 points to 45.1). Industrial production fell by 0.7% m/m in April.
The EU-UK summit on 19 May marks a new phase in economic rapprochement, more than five years after the Brexit, which has undeniably weakened the UK economy. The structural challenges facing the UK – high inflation, sluggish business investment, low productivity – partly result from this event.
Business climate is deteriorating: the services PMI (48.9) catch up the industrial PMI (45.4) in contraction territory in April, as does the composite PMI (48.2). The index of new export orders in the manufacturing sector (not taken into account in the calculation of the manufacturing PMI) plunges and approaches the lows reached during Covid.
Although the United Kingdom has been penalised less severely than its European neighbours, it has not escaped the 10% tariff floor on US customs duties. The negative impact on activity will add to the pre-existing domestic brakes.
The GfK index rose in February (+2 points to -22), but did not erase January's fall. The balance of opinion on the one-year financial outlook is back in positive territory. Retail sales rebounded by 1.6% m/m in January, after four months of decline. This upturn was confirmed by the BRC/KPMG survey, which showed retail sales (smoothed over three months) up by 2.2% y/y in February.
In France, we could think that the increase of public debt is a general consequence of the Covid-19 crisis. However, the chart we are commenting here shows that it is not.
Les dynamiques de consommation et de production industrielle restent défavorables. Les ventes au détail (hors carburant) ont reculé de 0,5 % m/m en décembre et de 1,1 % au T4 par rapport au T3. La production industrielle qui a enregistré, entre septembre et novembre, trois mois de baisse successifs demeure sur une dynamique très difficile au démarrage de l’année 2025. Certes, le PMI manufacturier s’améliore (+1,3 point à 48,3) tout comme l’enquête mensuelle du CBI, mais l’enquête trimestrielle du patronat britannique chute à nouveau lourdement au T1
The labour market in the UK continues to deteriorate. According to tax data (PAYE) published on 21 January by the ONS, the number of employees in the UK fell by 46,922 (-0.2% m/m) in December, the largest one-month decline since November 2021, which followed a drop of -0.1% in November. The year-on-year change drops drastically and falls below zero (-8,407) for the first time since April 2021.
The British example tends to suggest otherwise. Its impact on monthly payments remains modest compared to that of interest rates and rising property prices, and is offset by the higher total cost of the loan. In addition, longer loan maturities are likely to fuel the rise in property values.
While the Bank of England's (BoE) decision to keep its key rates unchanged at 4.75% on December 19th was in line with market expectations, the vote by three MPC members in favour of a 25 basis point cut was less so. This week, which has had a wealth of economic indicators in the UK, will certainly have shifted the lines, between rising inflation in November and heightened fears that an overly restrictive monetary policy could derail the economic recovery. Indeed, the BoE has revised its growth forecast for Q4 downwards, from 0.3% to 0.0%.
The UK’s policy mix (a combination of fiscal and monetary policies) is expected to be more accommodative in 2025. Its positive effects will be limited, however, given the very gradual fall in interest rates and the introduction of more restrictive budgetary rules. After GDP growth in the third quarter of 2024 fell short of expectations (+0.1% q/q), activity is expected to strengthen in Q4 (+0.3% q/q) before stabilising around this level in 2025 (between 0.3% and 0.4% q/q). The United Kingdom, which has a trade balance almost in equilibrium with the United States and exports mainly services to the US, also seems to be in a better position than its European neighbours to avoid the rise in US tariffs.
The decline in the PMI indices is less pronounced in the United Kingdom than in the eurozone, but it has been well underway since this autumn: the composite PMI fell by 1.8 points to 49.9 in November, with a deterioration in both the manufacturing sector (-1.3 points to 48.6) and in services (-2 points to 50). In addition, industrial production hit a post-Covid low in September, on a three-month moving average basis. As with industry, the residential construction sector remains depressed, with the PMI down 4.9 points to 49.4 in November. This follows a further contraction in housing construction (excluding social housing) of 0.7% in Q3, after a decline of 2.2% q/q in Q2.
Since July, the three main rating agencies have upgraded the Turkish government's medium-term and long-term debt ratings. Macroeconomic fundamentals have really improved over the past twelve months, despite the tightening of monetary policy and the resulting slowdown in growth due to positive real interest rates for households and businesses. The slippage in the core budget deficit is still under control and the debt ratio is at an all-time low. The current account deficit has fallen sharply and the recovery in portfolio investment has helped with rebuilding official foreign exchange reserves. Finally, the de-dollarisation of bank deposits has continued and bank credit risks are generally under control
The Autumn Budget, unveiled by Rachel Reeves on October 30th, attempts to reconcile fiscal adjustment, support for public services and strengthening of UK’s potential growth.
While manufacturing activity in the United Kingdom, like elsewhere in Europe, is in a difficult state, the situation is less worrying across the Channel. Industrial production rose by 1.1% m/m in August, returning to its April levels. The year-on-year fall in output has almost completely subsided (-0.3% y/y). This situation is in line with the manufacturing PMI for October, which was down on the previous month (-1.2 points, to 50.3), but is still in expansion territory. The services PMI fell by 0.6 points to 51.8, and therefore also contributed to the decline in the composite index, which dropped by 0.9 points to 51.7 in October.
The presentation of the budget on 30 October will be the first real test for Rachel Reeves. The deteriorating situation of the public accounts and the September 2022 mini-budget crisis, which is on everyone's minds, are leaving the Chancellor of the Exchequer with little room for manoeuvre. UK growth is expected to slow in the second half of 2024 (+0.3% quarter-on-quarter). The two policy rate cuts by the Bank of England (BoE) that we expect in 2024 (August and November) would enable growth to come close to its potential level during this year and in 2025.
In H2 2024, Swiss growth is expected to ease slightly (0.3% q/q in Q3 and 0.2% q/q in Q4 according to our forecasts). The persistent weakness of the country's main trading partners will continue to weigh on its growth, but the lagged impacts of the monetary easing initiated by the SNB in March 2024 should play out more favourably. We expect the SNB to make two further policy rate cuts by the end of the year, due in particular to the favourable developments seen in inflation in recent months.
In the second quarter of 2024, Turkish growth fell below 3% year-on-year for the first time since 2019. On a quarterly basis, GDP even remained stable. Without the positive contribution of foreign trade and inventories, GDP would even have fallen.
Growth and inflation figures in the UK have surprised favourably since the beginning of the year. These results are of course welcome, but they do not reflect a genuine recovery in the economic situation across the Channel.
The newly elected Labour Party has set a target of 1,500,000 extra homes in five years, or 300,000 a year, in an attempt to stem the crisis in England's housing sector. This is not a new figure; it was already the one put forward in the Conservative Party manifesto when Boris Johnson was elected in 2019.
The rise in activity is welcome news for the recently elected Labour Party. According to the ONS, the monthly figures for real GDP (or, to be more precise, real value added) show that UK activity rose by 0.4% m/m in May, following a levelling-off in April. Although the manufacturing sector (+0.4% m/m) and construction (+1.9% m/m) were more supportive of growth than services (+0.3% m/m) in May, it is the latter that have been driving activity over the past year, with a rebound in transport and logistics (+7.3% y/y) and a clear acceleration in ‘professional, scientific and technical’ activities (+4.1% y/y).
In Central Europe, 5-year government bond yields have broadly toned down since the last peak observed in 2022, amidst acute geopolitical uncertainties.
The party that wins the general election on 4 July will inherit an economy running out of steam. The scenario of a slowdown in growth in Q2 (+0.2% q/q), and over 2024 as a whole, remains our central forecast. Surveys data (PMI, GfK consumer confidence index) and investment have recovered, but household consumption remains depressed. While disinflation supports purchasing power, rising unemployment and the persistence of high interest and savings rates are limiting its effects. The rise in mortgage payment arrears indicates that the refinancing shock is continuing to spread. The return of inflation to 2% in May will support the Bank of England in its decision to initiate a first cut in key rates in August, according to our forecasts, which will give households (little) breathing space.
The preliminary growth estimate for Q1 has not dispelled doubts about the state of domestic demand in the UK. Although inflation has fallen and real wages and household confidence have improved, British consumers are still cautious. Household consumption rose only by 0.2% q/q in Q1, offsetting a small part of the contraction recorded in the previous two quarters (-1.0% cumulatively). In addition, retail sales surprised on the downside in April, falling by 2.3% m/m in volume, following a slight drop in March (-0.1% m/m). Real GDP rose by 0.6% q/q in Q1, underpinned by positive net exports. However, the underlying dynamic was disappointing, as import volumes fell more sharply than exports.
Since the local elections on 31 March, financial conditions have stabilised. Markets reacted favourably to the defeat of the ruling party at local level. The result of the elections is not expected to change the economic stabilisation programme of Finance Minister Mehmet Simsek. The Monetary Policy Committee maintained its key rate at its last meeting in April, a rate which it had raised again in March. Household consumption continues to drive growth, which will remain sustained this year unless fiscal policy becomes very restrictive, which is unlikely. The rebalancing of growth components is underway, although it is not yet sufficient to curb the non-energy current account deficit.
