eco TV Week

Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand?

1/31/2020

With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months.

Hélène BAUDCHON

TRANSCRIPT // Pension reform proposal in France: where do things stand? : January 2020

With the presentation of the pension reform proposal to the Council of Ministers on 24 January, we thought it would be an opportune moment to provide a progress report and update on some of the changes made in recent months. The core of the reform – the introduction of a universal point-based system – has not changed, but some key parameters have been adjusted significantly.

Let’s begin with the first generations to be affected. For those already working and affiliated with the current general pension scheme, the first to be affected would be those born in 1975, instead of 1963. But they will still begin to pay into the new system in 2025. Another novelty concerns younger generations, born after 2004, and who will first enter the labour force in 2022: they will begin paying directly into the new system at that time.

The “pivot age” of 64, another emblematic measure of the reform which was hotly debated, was eventually withdrawn from the draft bill. This was the government’s preferred option for absorbing the projected deficit of the current pension system in 2027. It is now up to a “financing conference”, created specifically for the occasion, to reach an agreement on a new set of alternative measures by the end of April.

However, the reform proposal still contains the notion of an “age of equilibrium” (which corresponds to the age of retirement at full benefits) as well as the bonus/malus system associated with it. This age of equilibrium is also expected to move in line with life expectancy gains. Its starting level must still be determined when the new system takes effect, based on the recommendations of the board of directors of the future National Universal Pension Fund.

Also concerning the system’s financial equilibrium, another key feature is that it includes a golden rule imposing a cumulative positive or neutral balance over a 5-year period. The multi-annual trajectory will be updated each year and the necessary adjustment measures would be taken in case of non-compliance.

The government is also beginning to deal with a series of outstanding issues, notably the specifics of the transition period and the convergence of the parameters of the special and professional pension schemes. Discussions have also begun on the bonus for difficult working conditions and the end of careers, which are some of the other sensitive points of the reform.

To conclude, the presentation of the reform bill to the Council of Ministers is a key step, but much still remains to be done. This can be seen in the positive, albeit critical opinion of the Council of State as well as in the critics about the impact study. Negotiations promise to be fierce when the reform bill is debated in the National Assembly, starting in February. A vote on the reform bill is still expected this summer. Thanks for watching. Tune in again next week for another three minutes of economic news.

View more videos Eco TV Week

On the Same Theme

Business confidence in free fall in March 3/27/2020
Judging by the indicators on our radar screen, the picture for the French economy is deteriorating, albeit, it should be remembered, from a relatively strong position...
France’s 2019 fiscal deficit: right at the 3% threshold 3/26/2020
In 2019, according to the preliminary INSEE estimate, France’s fiscal deficit came to 3% of GDP, which is good news, if only slightly better than the government’s target of 3.1% of GDP. The deficit widened by 0.7 points compared to 2018, the first increase since 2009. Attributable to the one-off fiscal cost of the transformation of the CICE tax credit into reduced employer contributions, the swelling deficit was expected to be only temporary, and would be followed by a substantial improvement in 2020. In the draft budget bill for the current year, the government was forecasting a deficit of 2.2% of GDP. Yet the Covid-19 pandemic has radically changed the situation. In the amended draft budget bill for 2020, presented on 18 March, the government is now forecasting a deficit of 3.9% of GDP, a preliminary estimate that is considered to be on the low end.
France: healthy state of the labour market in 2019 3/10/2020
The key metrics of the French labour market for 2019 are available and they paint a healthy picture, with strong job gains and a significant fall in the unemployment rate.
Stand-out labour market performance in 2019 3/2/2020
Employment and unemployment figures for Q4 2019 and the year as a whole in France were surprisingly strong, especially since growth weakened markedly, despite showing some resilience. The preliminary Q4 2019 growth estimate fell well short of expectations (GDP contraction of 0.1% q/q), but private payroll employment (up 0.2% q/q, preliminary estimate) and the unemployment rate (-0.4 points to 8.1%) were far better than expected. Growth averaged 1.3% over 2019 as a whole – nearly a half-point lower than in 2018. Conversely, private payroll employment barely lost any traction (up 1.1% after a 1.2% rise), and the drop in the unemployment rate was slightly larger in 2019 than it was in 2018 (-0.6 points to 8.4%, after a 0.4-point decline in 2018). The labour market’s strong showing, broadly consistent with resilient growth, has also gained succour from the slower increase in the labour force, the structural downtrend in labour productivity gains and measures to ensure growth creates more jobs. In 2020, we expect the same causes to produce the same effects. Based on a forecast of a minor weakening in growth, we expect only a moderate easing in the pace at which employment rises and unemployment falls. However, this forecast carries a downside risk linked to the economic impact of the coronavirus outbreak. The target of an unemployment rate of 7% in 2022 is achievable, but it is based on an ambitious assumption of growth holding up fairly significantly above 1%.
Despite tiering, the rate of the deposit facility still costs French banks EUR 1.5 billion 2/19/2020
Tiering partially exempts excess reserves of the euro area banks from the negative deposit facility rate (-0.5%). It applies within the limit of an amount equal to six times their minimum reserves. Banks whose excess reserves do not exceed this multiple may, in addition, convert all or part of their deposit facility into excess reserves. The amount of the deposit facility of the 19 banking systems in the euro zone decreased by 59% between September and December 2019, falling back to its spring 2016 level. We estimate that tiering reduces the cost of negative interests by EUR 4.0 bn in the euro area and EUR 825 m in France[1]. The annual cost of negative interest amounts to EUR 4.7 bn for the euro area banks, including EUR 3.5 bn attributable only to excess reserves and EUR 1.1 bn to the deposit facility. While it offers a relevant vision of the hierarchy of costs between banking systems, our calculation provides only an immediate view, taking into account only direct costs. Taking into account each one’s net interbank position, most often of the same sign as the balance of transactions with the Eurosystem, tends to amplify the results obtained. [1] Estimates based on the ECB database at the end of December 2019 (excess reserves and deposit facility at the euro area level, current accounts and deposit facility by country) and of national central banks data at the end of October (minimum reserves by country). For certain countries (Netherlands, Ireland, Portugal, Greece), reserve requirements are estimated from stocks of demand deposits, time deposits of less than two years and deposits repayable at maturity of non-financial private agents with MFIs , as well as deposits from non-residents and debt securities less than two years old. For each banking system, excess reserves at the end of December are extrapolated by assuming the amount of compulsory reserves unchanged since October.
Healthy unemployment figures 1/31/2020
The economic indicators on our radar screen portray a French economy that is still looking rather strong and upbeat. In the recent period, most indicators are higher than their long-term and short-term averages, i.e. the momentum is slightly positive. Specifically, the signals from survey data (available through January) are more positive than hard data concerning activity (which are not as up to date, with November and December being the most recent months). A priori this augurs well for growth in early 2020...
2020: new year, same trends 1/24/2020
The year 2020 is expected to follow along similar lines as in 2019, a mixed performance marked by slow but resilient growth bolstered by the strength of final domestic demand. The economy is expected to keep running at about the same rate (1.1% after 1.3%). The rebound in household consumption should gather steam, fuelled by major purchasing power gains. The dynamic pace of investment, which looks hard to sustain, is expected to slow, while sluggish global demand will continue to curb exports. The intensity of several external downside risks declined in Q1 2020, including trade tensions, Brexit, and fears of a recession in the US and Germany. On the domestic front, upside risks continue to stem from supportive economic policies while the tense social climate constitutes a risk on the downside.
Home affordability trends in France: dichotomy between Paris and the provinces for the past decade 1/8/2020
Our home affordability index measures the ratio of the borrowing capacity of households (based on average household income, average fixed mortgage rates and average mortgage duration1) to the average existing home price per square meter (m2). Over the past ten years2, home affordability has increased by 30.4% in the provinces, but declined by 12.2% in Paris. Changes in average credit conditions (the average duration was extended to 18.8 years from 17.8 years, and mortgage rates declined to 1.30% from 4.30%) and disposable household income (+7.1%, notwithstanding differences in level) were relatively homogeneous at the national level, which means the differential can be attributed almost exclusively to the spread in existing home prices changes since 2009: home prices have increased by 64.2% in Paris compared to only 10.2% in the provinces. Moreover, this average figure masks significant price differentials from one region to the next. 1 In so far as home affordability is rebased, it reflects cases in which down payments account for a stable proportion of the transaction amount (homeowners who sell a home before buying another one), as well as those in which the down payment is negligible (i.e. for certain first-time homeowners and rental investors). 2  Between Q3 2009 and Q3 2019
France: dynamism and composition of business investment 12/18/2019
Although not as significant as during the 2004-2007 boom period (+4.8 % per year on average), the dynamism of French business investment has nonetheless been noteworthy since 2014 (+3.4%). In 2018, its contribution to GDP growth (0.5 percentage points) was slightly above the one of household consumption (this latter lacking itself in dynamism) and in 2019, according to our forecasts, it would be barely below. The outcome of business investment being the main engine of French growth is very unusual. Its breakdown by products and its evolution over the time are also noteworthy: the current dynamism is based up to 40% on investment in information and communication services, far above all other products and twice as much as its share during the 2004-2007 period. Given this composition and the ongoing digital transformation, the business investment dynamism could continue, and even increase if the other types of investment join forces as in the 2004-2007 period.
France – pension reform: the main points of debate 12/6/2019
The reform of the French pension system, currently being elaborated and discussed, is the major project for the second half of Emmanuel Macron’s five-year term. This is a wide and complex subject.

ABOUT US Three teams of economists (OECD countries research, emerging economies and country risk, banking economics) make up BNP Paribas Economic Research Department.
This website presents their analyses.
The website contains 2369 articles and 603 videos