Eco Week

Call options as lottery tickets: does it matter?

01/29/2021
PDF

When buying lottery tickets, one should expect to lose money on average. Still, lotteries are popular because people are repeatedly willing to give up some money, hoping for a –very unlikely- outsized gain. In statistical terms, it means they expect a positive skewness in the distribution of possible outcomes. In Finance, similar behaviour has been noticed already many years ago giving rise to an abundant literature on ‘stocks as lotteries’ -in particular for stocks with a very low price, the so-called penny stocks- and ‘single stock call options as lottery tickets’. Investors are very much aware they can lose some money –when a call option expires out-of-the-money- but they nurture the hope of a very big gain[1]. To some extent, the share price behaviour in recent days of companies like GameStop provides a concrete illustration of such thinking. It has given rise to extensive media coverage but has also had ripple effects on the rest of the market, witness the rise in the VIX index[2].

GAMESTOP SHARE PRICE AND VIX

Can the recent events end up having broader repercussions? To a large degree, the answer depends on the breadth –how many stocks are concerned- and the intensity of the feedback loops. Consider a company with a small market capitalization and a low share price. Investors expecting the share price to go down have built considerable short positions. In addition, call options have been issued on the underlying stock. Suppose that some investors start to buy call options. This may trigger more purchases from others –herding behaviour- who have spotted the positive momentum or read about it on social media. The issuer of the call option needs to hedge his position and hence buys the underlying stock. If the share price increases enough, stop-losses may be triggered for those with short positions, further pushing up the price of the stock. If this happens simultaneously for several stocks, hedge funds that had shorted these stocks may decide to reduce their leverage[3], causing a share price decline of companies where they had long positions. In such a scenario, equity market volatility would increase, which in turn could influence other asset classes such as government bonds. The price of the latter typically rises when equity volatility spikes. It could also lead to a breakdown in the correlation between large cap equity indices and small cap indices.

If this is a one-off event, it should a priori not have any lasting consequences. If it becomes a recurrent phenomenon, certain effects could last. It might lead to a reluctance to short certain stocks, which would reduce the informational efficiency of equity prices[4]. Stock pickers would need to take it into account as well. It could influence the decision of asset allocators whether to invest in small or large companies, in equities versus bonds. It could increase the required risk premium and influence the cost of capital of companies.

[1] Such investors consider the distribution of possible outcomes to be positively skewed: “there is some probability to gain huge profits that can cover all the frequent small losses” (Source: https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com).

[2] The VIX index “represents the market’s expectation of 30-day forward looking volatility”. It is derived from the prices of the S&P500 index options. Source: Investopedia.

[3] On 28 January, Bloomberg TV reported hedge funds had been deleveraging at the fastest pace in 14 years.

[4] According to Boehmer and Wu, “stock prices are more accurate when short sellers are more active”. Source: Ekkehart Boehmer and Juan Wu, Short selling and the price discovery process, The Review of Financial Studies, 2013.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Germany
Diverging fortunes for services and industry

Diverging fortunes for services and industry

The economic pulse for Germany highlights the dichotomy that characterises the economy at the moment. The lockdown announced in early November and drastically tightened in mid-December is heavily weighing on the household sector and services. [...]

Read the article
France
Some pleasant surprises in Q4 2020

Some pleasant surprises in Q4 2020

2020 closed with a quarter-on-quarter (q/q) fall in GDP of 1.3%, according to the first estimate of the Q4 national accounts published on Friday 29 January [...]

Read the article
Italy
Political risk arises again

Political risk arises again

Italy is one of the rare European countries whose propagation of the epidemic is still under control at the end of January, although the situation is still very delicate. On top of these health uncertainties, political risk is also on the rise again [...]

Read the article
Spain
The epidemic is worsening but confidence shows resilience in January

The epidemic is worsening but confidence shows resilience in January

Spain’s health situation is still alarming. The pandemic continues to spread, forcing the public authorities to tighten restrictive measures, notably in the Madrid and Valencia regions [...]

Read the article
Global
Declining mobility and global acceleration of vaccination campaigns

Declining mobility and global acceleration of vaccination campaigns

The biggest world-wide vaccination campaign in history began in 2020 Q4. According to the latest figures, released by Our World in Data on 27 January, more than 80 million doses have been given in 66 countries. [...]

Read the article