In Q3 2023, Spanish growth eased slightly to 0.3% q/q. It was primarily driven by household consumption, which was itself supported by the resilience of the labour market and the increase in real wages. After an increase in H2 (from 1.6% y/y in June to 3.3% in December according to the harmonised price index), inflation is expected to fall again in 2024 and drop below the target of 2% in Q3. We expect growth to remain moderate at the end of 2023 and in early 2024 (0.2% q/q), before returning to positive territory. Spain will remain one of the drivers of the euro area for another year, with expected growth of 1.5% on an annual average versus 0.6% for the euro area.
The country fell into recession during 2023, like in Germany across the border, but 2024 is expected to be better as the future government will have the financial resources to revitalise the economy. A little bit of patience will be needed though for things to settle down. The Dutch economy remains heavily exposed to the global environment, which is very tense at the start of this year.
The Belgian economy looks set to grow at its current trend rate for the next few quarters. Despite a challenging international environment, characterised by restrictive monetary tightening combined with economic slowdowns in key trading partners, the economy has held up remarkably well. Consumer spending, supported by wage indexation, and robust investment are leading the charge. Capex expenditures are directed towards automation and climate transition in the wake of energy and labour costs hikes.
Greece is expected to enjoy economic growth once again in 2024, but activity showed signs of slowing down in the second half of 2023. Real GDP stagnated in Q3 2023 and employment fell by 0.5% q/q. While strong tourism activity, against a backdrop of high inflation, is boosting tax revenue, its impact on real GDP is more muted. The sharp drop in the unemployment rate (which is now below 10%), the drastic improvement in public finances and the decline in public and private debt testify to Greece’s solid recovery, which has been welcomed by the rise in equity and bond markets, and by the sharp tightening of spreads between Greek sovereign debt and the German Bund
The UK economy is flirting with recession. The downturn in activity in the second half of 2023 is expected to continue until spring 2024 before an expected sluggish recovery, which nonetheless will be supported by the Bank of England (BoE) beginning its monetary easing cycle. Despite an uptick in December 2023, inflation remains on its downward trajectory, which is clearly reflected in production prices and CBI surveys. The turnaround in the labour market, which is still muted, is helping to reduce upward pressures on wages. While this is good news for inflationary momentum, it is also weakening private consumption. The BoE has little room for manoeuvre, with an initial policy rate cut expected to occur in June 2024
The combination of rising inflation and the monetary tightening to combat it led the Swedish economy into recession. Declining household consumption and residential investment were the main drivers. Although the situation is not expected to deteriorate further in 2024, this does not mean that a dynamic recovery is to be expected. However, although Sweden is experiencing significant difficulties, it still has many assets to support activity in the medium term.
The rate hikes cycle is coming to an end. The further weakening of economic activity and lower inflation that we expect to see by the end of this year should prompt the Fed, like the ECB and the BoE, to stop raising their policy rates. However, a further tightening cannot be ruled out. Interest rate hikes would not be followed immediately by cuts: to continue the fight against inflation, monetary response is expected to hold policy rates at their current high level for an extended period, until mid-2024 according to our forecasts. The first rate cuts would then occur to accompany the sharper fall in inflation and offset its positive impact on real policy rates. From this point of view, monetary policy would remain restrictive until the end of 2024.
The US economy keeps growing and postponing the occurrence of a recession that is still likely, but not in 2023 and in a circumscribed way. While households’ consumption has so far proven resilient to the monetary tightening, the delayed and cumulative effects should eventually impulse a recessionary dynamic. The first fallout is already visible on the real estate market and the labour market has exhibited signs of easing. If rate hikes are probably over, the restrictive stance is not.
After some hesitation, the Chinese authorities finally stepped up their stimulus measures over the summer. The recent slight upturn in economic growth is set to continue in Q4 2023. However, action by the central bank and the government remains constrained, cautious and measured, while internal and external obstacles to economic activity are still powerful. In the real estate sector, even if activity stabilises in the short term thanks to support measures, it is likely to remain hampered by the financial fragility of developers and weak buyer sentiment.
After sustained growth in H1 2023, driven by external demand, the Japanese economy is beginning to slow down. Private demand (household consumption, corporate investment) is offering little support for growth. Although inflation has stabilised at around 3%, it is eroding household purchasing power, which is still not benefitting from significant wage increases. Nevertheless, according to the Ministry of Finance data, corporate profits hit a new record in Q2. Fostering a better redistribution of profits to wages remains a priority for Fumio Kishida’s government, which is preparing a new wave of budgetary measures in October
Eurozone company surveys (PMI, European Commission) continued to deteriorate throughout the summer, although a slight improvement was observed in September for the PMI. The rise in policy rates by 25 basis points in September – the last one according to our forecast – will amplify this phenomenon. We do not expect a recession in the euro zone as a whole in 2023, but moderate growth at 0.5%, mainly due to a favourable carry-over effect in 2022. After a slightly positive first semester, eurozone activity is likely to stall in the second semester. Significant growth differentials are expected between the Member States.
The German economy is affected by the transmission of the inflationary shock to household consumption. However, the underperformance of the German economy also reflects more structural difficulties, reminding the “Standort Deutschland[1]” debate. These difficulties began in 2018 shortly before the first European regulations aimed at adapting the automotive sector to climate change were implemented. Manufacturing output has never returned to the November 2017 peak and production capacity in the sector has declined. Against a backdrop that is still difficult, we expect another recession in the second half of 2023.
The French economy is characterised by a dichotomy. Household spending – consumption and investment – has decreased in volume (-1.4% and -6.6% in Q2 compared to Q4 2021), while corporate investment has increased (+6.7% between Q4 2021 and Q2 2023). This factor, combined with the reduction in constraints on the production of transport equipment, has enabled high growth in Q2 (0.5% q/q). While these factors should continue to support economic activity in the medium term, growth may be constrained in the coming quarters by the fall in demand against the background of high household savings.
In Q2, real GDP declined by 0.4%, driven by weakening domestic demand. Investment in machinery and equipment fell, reflecting the worsening of firms’ economic and financial conditions. Consumption slightly recovered in real terms. Italian households suffer, however, from both higher consumer prices and increasing interest rates. In Q2, there was a contraction across many sectors. Services value added unexpectedly declined, reflecting the slower recovery of tourism. Inflation is slowly falling: in September it grew +5.7% y/y. Contrary to most predictions, in Q2 2023 house prices increased by 2.0% q/q.
Until this summer, the Spanish economy had proved resilient to the interest rate shock. Private consumption and investment were up respectively, 2.7% y/y and 2.0% in Q2 2023. The positive trend in the labour market and the savings accumulated during the pandemic supported household spending, along with the decline in inflation, which allowed purchasing power to stabilise. However, these supports are falling off. Economic activity will slow in H2 2023 but will not come to a standstill. However, with growth now forecast at 2.2% in 2023 as a whole, Spain will remain one of the drivers of the euro zone this year.
Negative revisions to GDP figures have darkened the mood of the Belgian economy. We expect GDP to remain flat throughout the second half of this year as monetary policy does its job. Short-term volatility in inflation numbers looks likely, resulting in a temporary bout of deflation near year’s end. The labour market remains in good health, suggesting a soft landing is in the cards. Successful government bond emissions could tempt some last-minute pre-election spending by the De Croo-government, but the long-term outlook for public finances remains bleak.
The UK economy shows increasing signs of deterioration. An upturn in unemployment is visible, and the PMI employment data fell sharpy in September. The consequences of monetary tightening are spreading and no sector has been spared; first and foremost, the housing market and even the public sector, recently shaken by the bankruptcy of several councils, including the city council of Birmingham, the country’s second largest city. While inflation in the UK is falling, it remains high compared to its European neighbours, notably due to stronger wage increases. However, the Bank of England is not expected to raise the Bank rate again, even though the vote in September (when a hike was expected) was decided by a single vote
In the major OECD economies, the slow pace of disinflation is expected to continue, while the slow slowdown in growth will eventually lead, because of the monetary tightening (particularly rapid and significant), to a recession in the United States and stagnation in eurozone GDP. Various supportive factors should limit the extent of the reversal, but the ensuing recovery would be equally limited. The slow convergence of inflation towards its 2% target would force central banks to maintain a restrictive policy despite the start of rate cuts in the first half of 2024.
The US economy continues to grow and create jobs, albeit at a gradually slower pace, and the Federal Reserve has not quite finished with rate hikes. We continue to anticipate a recession, from Q3 2023 until Q1 2024, under the effect of monetary tightening. Having opted for the status quo in June on the back of inflation continuing to fall and in order to take time to assess the effects of the monetary tightening implemented to date, the Fed is expected to make a final 25 bps increase in July, bringing the Fed funds range to 5.25-5.50%.
China’s economic growth recovered rapidly following the abandonment of the zero-Covid policy, but it is also running out of steam faster than expected. Domestic demand is held back by a significant loss of consumer and investor confidence, and export momentum is stalling. The authorities are cautiously easing monetary policy, and additional stimulus measures are expected in the short term. They should, among other things, aim to encourage youth employment.
Inflation in Japan continues to rise, spreading to all the items in the consumer price index. Inflation expectations remain anchored around the 2% target and price increases should remain at this level in the medium term. We expect the Bank of Japan (BoJ) to raise the 10-year sovereign rate ceiling to 1% in July, before ending its yield curve control policy by the end of 2024. Real GDP grew by 0.7% q/q in Q1 (+2.7% in annualised terms), mainly supported by household consumption and non-residential investment. The return of foreign tourists (+71% q/q in Q1) also enabled activity to rebound after two disappointing quarters. Although slowing, growth should continue in Q2 (+0.5% q/q) and throughout the second half of the year, reaching 1.1% in 2023.
The eurozone entered a technical recession in Q1 2023, with Eurostat having revised lower its estimate of quarterly GDP growth for Q1 from +0.1% to -0.1%, i.e. the same pace of contraction as in Q4 2022. These results do not profoundly change our assessment for 2023: weak or slightly negative economic activity, quarter-on-quarter, although growth for 2023 as a whole should be more positive thanks to the favourable carry-over growth effect. Our current forecasts are based on a terminal refinancing rate of 4.5%, which would be reached at the monetary policy meeting on 14 September. Nevertheless, the scenario of harsher tightening cannot be completely ruled out, given the ongoing inflationary momentum and still high inflation generalisation indices.
Germany experienced a technical recession in Q4 2022 (-0.5% q/q) and in Q1 2023 (-0.3% q/q), driven by a contraction in household consumption (-1.7% then -1.2%). Although the main cause of this recession was not its industrial core, the German economy showed signs of weakness which hindered growth. While disinflation should allow household consumption to recover in Q2, economic surveys however, are pointing to a further deterioration, which once again exposes the German economy to a risk of recession in H2.
After a second half-year 2022 during which growth weakened markedly, Q1 2023 saw a relative rebound, which should be confirmed in Q2: a rebound rather concentrated in some sectors, mainly transport equipment and tourism. However, economic surveys have deteriorated since March, reaching relatively low levels, particularly in manufacturing. Housing, business services and exports are all areas of concern which, taken together, are likely to have a more pronounced negative impact in the second half of 2023, both in terms of growth and job creation, which are continuing for the time being.
Following a mild contraction in the last three months of 2022, Italian GDP rose by 0.6% in Q1 2023. The carry-over for 2023 is +0.9%. In Q1, domestic demand excluding inventories added 0.7 percentage points to growth, while the contribution of both net exports and inventories was negative. Investment rose by almost 1%, reflecting the improvement of economic and financial conditions for Italian firms. Italian households benefited from the strong recovery of nominal income, but still suffered from the purchasing power loss due to inflation. This latter remains among the highest in the euro zone, at 8% y/y in May (harmonised measure).
EcoPerspectives is the quarterly review of advanced economies (member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) and China.
It provides an outline of several advanced economies using indicators for the past quarter and it looks ahead in order to better understand and anticipate the main economic problems of the countries in question.
For EcoPerspectives, economists from the advanced economies team regularly monitor the key economic indicators of selected countries. In particular, our experts use the quarterly forecasts provided by BNP Paribas (for growth, inflation, exchange rates, interest rates and oil prices). Each economist analyses the economic situation of one or more countries, based on the available indicators, in order to see how they change, including the industrial production index, quarterly gross domestic product (GDP) and inflation forecasts, the consumer price index (CPI) and the producer price index (PPI), and employment and unemployment figures. How various stakeholders’ views evolve is also studied and analysed closely (e.g. household confidence and business climate). The author comments on the main factors that influence and determine the economic activity of the country concerned and the economic outlook for the coming quarter.
