The slowdown in activity in the second half of 2023 should be contained: real GDP growth would only decline, from +0.4% q/q in Q2 2023 to +0.3% q/q in Q3, and +0.2% q/q in Q4. The deterioration in the PMI surveys is continuing in both the manufacturing sector and the services sector.
The United States has observed an improvement in the business climate in August, which should postpone the risk of recession for a few more months. The ISM Manufacturing rose by 1.2 pp and reached 47.6. However, the index has been well in contraction territory since November 2022, the longest period since the GFC.
Growth in Q2 2023 was a positive surprise, with an increase in real GDP of 0.2% q/q, driven by corporate investment, and in particular by spending on transport equipment. Nevertheless, signs of deterioration in activity are multiplying and extending to all sectors.
Japanese economic surveys remain positive overall, despite contrasting results for August: the composite PMI was up 0.4 points to 52.6, while the Economy Watchers Survey fell by 0.8 points, returning to its June level of 53.6.
Economic surveys pointed once again to a downturn, including the ifo Business Climate Index (88.5 in June compared to 93.4 in April) and the ZEW Indicator of Economic Sentiment (-14.7 in July compared to 28.1 in February). The erratic momentum of factory orders, which were up 6.4% m/m in May (after a low point in April 2023 not seen since May 2013), underlines one of the constraints at work: the irregularity of activity in transport equipment, which remains subject to sporadic supply difficulties. This phenomenon is generating high volatility in production, both in the aeronautics sector and the automotive sector (lower in April with an upturn in May, as also seen in France).
The downturn in economic surveys highlights a drop in demand (contraction of balance of opinion on global and export order books), particularly in the manufacturing sector. The sectors most sensitive to the economic cycle (chemicals, plastics, metals, packaging, wholesale trade and transport services) are all experiencing a marked drop in their synthetic confidence index. In the construction sector, the balance of opinion on the activity in new housing fell again to -22.5 in July (-10.7 in April). By contrast, leisure-related services, information-communication, transport equipment and part of the construction sector (new building excluding housing, maintenance-renovation) are still growing.
Real GDP growth should halve in the second quarter compared to the previous quarter, at 0.3% q/q, before a further slowdown in Q3. Industrial production (down 0.5% over the first two months of Q2) and retail sales (slightly up by 0.1%) demonstrate the fragility of activity in the country. The composite PMI for new export orders also continued to deteriorate in June (-4.4 points to 43.3).
Although in May, the business climate might well have suggested a future recession, in June, things looked less clear. Admittedly, the further drop in the manufacturing ISM, to 46 in June, brought it to its lowest level since the 2008 crisis (excluding the Covid period). However, the message conveyed by the non-manufacturing ISM was noticeably different, with a rebound to 53.9 in June, compared to 50.3 in May.
The economic indicators for June and the second quarter of 2023 illustrate widespread sluggish economic activity. Chinese households are cautious and limit their spending. They are worried because of the lasting crisis in the real estate sector and the uncertainties surrounding employment opportunities.
In the major OECD economies, the slow pace of disinflation is expected to continue, while the slow slowdown in growth will eventually lead, because of the monetary tightening (particularly rapid and significant), to a recession in the United States and stagnation in eurozone GDP. Various supportive factors should limit the extent of the reversal, but the ensuing recovery would be equally limited. The slow convergence of inflation towards its 2% target would force central banks to maintain a restrictive policy despite the start of rate cuts in the first half of 2024.
The US economy continues to grow and create jobs, albeit at a gradually slower pace, and the Federal Reserve has not quite finished with rate hikes. We continue to anticipate a recession, from Q3 2023 until Q1 2024, under the effect of monetary tightening. Having opted for the status quo in June on the back of inflation continuing to fall and in order to take time to assess the effects of the monetary tightening implemented to date, the Fed is expected to make a final 25 bps increase in July, bringing the Fed funds range to 5.25-5.50%.
China’s economic growth recovered rapidly following the abandonment of the zero-Covid policy, but it is also running out of steam faster than expected. Domestic demand is held back by a significant loss of consumer and investor confidence, and export momentum is stalling. The authorities are cautiously easing monetary policy, and additional stimulus measures are expected in the short term. They should, among other things, aim to encourage youth employment.
Inflation in Japan continues to rise, spreading to all the items in the consumer price index. Inflation expectations remain anchored around the 2% target and price increases should remain at this level in the medium term. We expect the Bank of Japan (BoJ) to raise the 10-year sovereign rate ceiling to 1% in July, before ending its yield curve control policy by the end of 2024. Real GDP grew by 0.7% q/q in Q1 (+2.7% in annualised terms), mainly supported by household consumption and non-residential investment. The return of foreign tourists (+71% q/q in Q1) also enabled activity to rebound after two disappointing quarters. Although slowing, growth should continue in Q2 (+0.5% q/q) and throughout the second half of the year, reaching 1.1% in 2023.
The eurozone entered a technical recession in Q1 2023, with Eurostat having revised lower its estimate of quarterly GDP growth for Q1 from +0.1% to -0.1%, i.e. the same pace of contraction as in Q4 2022. These results do not profoundly change our assessment for 2023: weak or slightly negative economic activity, quarter-on-quarter, although growth for 2023 as a whole should be more positive thanks to the favourable carry-over growth effect. Our current forecasts are based on a terminal refinancing rate of 4.5%, which would be reached at the monetary policy meeting on 14 September. Nevertheless, the scenario of harsher tightening cannot be completely ruled out, given the ongoing inflationary momentum and still high inflation generalisation indices.
Germany experienced a technical recession in Q4 2022 (-0.5% q/q) and in Q1 2023 (-0.3% q/q), driven by a contraction in household consumption (-1.7% then -1.2%). Although the main cause of this recession was not its industrial core, the German economy showed signs of weakness which hindered growth. While disinflation should allow household consumption to recover in Q2, economic surveys however, are pointing to a further deterioration, which once again exposes the German economy to a risk of recession in H2.
After a second half-year 2022 during which growth weakened markedly, Q1 2023 saw a relative rebound, which should be confirmed in Q2: a rebound rather concentrated in some sectors, mainly transport equipment and tourism. However, economic surveys have deteriorated since March, reaching relatively low levels, particularly in manufacturing. Housing, business services and exports are all areas of concern which, taken together, are likely to have a more pronounced negative impact in the second half of 2023, both in terms of growth and job creation, which are continuing for the time being.
Following a mild contraction in the last three months of 2022, Italian GDP rose by 0.6% in Q1 2023. The carry-over for 2023 is +0.9%. In Q1, domestic demand excluding inventories added 0.7 percentage points to growth, while the contribution of both net exports and inventories was negative. Investment rose by almost 1%, reflecting the improvement of economic and financial conditions for Italian firms. Italian households benefited from the strong recovery of nominal income, but still suffered from the purchasing power loss due to inflation. This latter remains among the highest in the euro zone, at 8% y/y in May (harmonised measure).
The drop in inflation in Spain has provided no respite for the coalition in power. The Socialist Party’s losses in the regional and local elections on 28 May to the People’s Party, led Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez to announce a snap general election on 23 July, five months before the originally scheduled date. Despite a still dynamic labour market, the drop in purchasing power and the housing crisis are penalising the party in power, which has fallen even further behind in the polls this spring. The property market is showing signs of a limited correction for the time being, but the continuation of monetary tightening and the resulting hike in lending rates are likely to accentuate this downturn.
At the start of this year, Belgian GDP growth remained at above-average levels. Inflation is currently slowing down alongside the cooling of the labour market. Rising interest rates have started to bite, as real estate spending is already declining, with firm capex to follow suit. A (brief) recession towards the end of the year remains possible but unlikely. Even if it does materialise, a debt-constrained government won’t be of much help, however.
GDP in the United Kingdom rose by 0.1% q/q in Q1 2023. The winter recession heralded in autumn 2022 did not materialise thanks to public investment, the momentum of services and the resilience of industry. This resilience is good news, but is likely to make inflation more persistent in the medium term, while the latest figures once again surprised on the upside. The Bank of England (BoE) will have to continue to raise interest rates. This will impact growth, which is likely to be zero in 2024, after already reaching just 0.4% in 2023.
Uncertainty about US economic policy, based on media coverage, fell in June after a rebound in May. The European Commission’s economic uncertainty index fell in June, continuing its decline since October 2022, as uncertainty in the various sectors of activity decreased, except in industry, where the index remained stable.
While it might have been hoped that the current drop in inflation would provide a stronger boost to household confidence, this, and consequently consumption, remains constrained. This is due to the impact of rising interest rates on purchasing intentions in both France and Germany.
In June, the main OECD economies experienced divergent trends, raising the question of the tipping point between a situation where growth continues – with inflationary pressures requiring further monetary tightening – and another where it slows down further and where the fall in inflation means that an end to rate hikes can be envisaged.
Despite the support of tourism, which has been at levels close to those of 2019 since the beginning of the year, the effects of the rise in interest rates and the drop in household purchasing power on the Spanish economy should worsen over the course of the year.
Continuing the downturn observed in April, INSEE’s business climate indicator fell again in May to 100, the lowest since April 2021. The downturn is widespread and particularly noteworthy regarding the manufacturing sector, where the confidence index even fell to 99, below its long-term average (100) for the first time since March 2021. At the same time, inflationary pressures are continuing to ease.