Eco Perspectives

Feeble growth but no recession

04/14/2022
PDF

Inflation continued to rise in early 2022 to the point that it began to erode household confidence in March. These purchasing power problems foreshadow a decline in consumer spending. With fiscal support measures limiting the increase in inflation (by nearly 2 percentage points in April), growth is expected to remain slightly positive (0.3% in Q1 and 0.1% in Q2 according to our estimates).

Since early 2021, the French economy has been buffeted by a series of headwinds and tailwinds, which have made economic trends more uncertain. The resurgence of the Covid-19 pandemic hit the services sector first as health restrictions were tightened in December and January. The lifting of these measures in February triggered a rebound in the services sector confidence index, suggesting a return to the dynamic growth rates of fall 2021. Yet the shock caused by the Russian war in Ukraine undercut this momentum and fuelled the acceleration of inflation with much higher pump prices in March. This trend is bound to continue in Q2 due to second round effects on the prices of manufactured goods, services and most food items.

GROWTH & INFLATION

Households anticipate more infaltion

According to the INSEE, household confidence fell by 6 points in March 2022 compared to February, the biggest decline since the recession of 1993 and the lockdown of April 2020. Household assessments of past inflation deteriorated in March, but did not change much compared to February. To the contrary, many more households are now anticipating further price increases over the next 12 months, with the balance of opinions deteriorating by 50 points in March to unprecedented levels. Initially hoping the shock would be only temporary, households now see it as a more lasting trend that will probably have an impact on consumer spending. According to our estimates, the share of energy-related spending (housing and transport) could reach 10.3% of household consumption in 2022 (assuming oil prices hold above USD 100 per barrel throughout 2022), the highest proportion since 1986.

Fiscal support helps buffer the shock. Without this support, the share of energy-related spending would temporarily approach the absolute record of 11.6% reported during the cold wave of early 1985. Purchasing power gains amounted to 0.8% q/q in Q4 2021, three quarters of which corresponds to the EUR 100 inflation premium distributed to nearly 23 million French citizens in late 2021 (as well as to another 15 million eligible citizens, who will receive the inflation premium in early 2022).

Other household support measures include a freeze on regulated prices for gas (since October 2021, recently extended to year-end 2022) and electricity (through year-end 2022, after an increase limited to 4% in February), as well as a EUR 0.18 per litre reduction on pump prices applicable between 1 April and 31 July (with an additional pricing effort at the discretion of service stations). Without these measures, April’s inflation rate would have been nearly 2 percentage points higher than our forecast of 4.7% (1.5 points for gas and electricity prices based on the INSEE’s calculations in February, and 0.5 points based on our estimates for the fuel price subsidy starting in April).

These measures also reduce by as much the negative impact on household purchasing power, albeit for a net overall cost for public finances that we estimate at EUR 21.5 bn (EUR 26 bn for additional measures offset by additional revenue of EUR 4.5 bn). In addition to measures dedicated to protect households, this also includes support measures for companies (coverage of half of higher energy costs for companies whose energy expenditures exceed 3% of turnover; a higher ceiling on state-backed loans, which was raised from 25% to 35% of turnover; and targeted sector measures).

Companies opt for caution

The AFTE/Rexecode survey on corporate cash flows shows that companies are also feeling the strain of inflationary pressures, with a 12-point deterioration in the balance of opinions concerning operating cash flow in March. According to the INSEE business climate surveys, companies are also increasingly constrained to pass through higher costs to sales prices, especially for household goods (including food products).

We must add the expected impact of the inflationary shock on household consumption to the difficulties companies are encountering, which is leading them to scale back production, especially in the automobile, chemical and IT & electronics sectors. Another reason to be cautious is the uncertainty over foreign demand and the security of industrial supply chains for energy and metals.

Consequently, we expect growth to slow to an estimated 0.3% q/q in Q1 (from 0.7% q/q in Q4 2021) and to 0.1% q/q in Q2, as economic policy buffers the price shock, helping to avoid recession in the short term. We have revised downwards our full-year 2022 growth forecast by 1 percentage point to an average annual rate of 3.2%.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Multiple shocks test resilience

Multiple shocks test resilience

The resilience of the global economy is tested by multiple shocks: rising Covid-19 infections in China, the war in Ukraine, the huge increase of several commodity prices, the prospect of aggressive monetary tightening in the US [...]

Read the article
United States
Stress tests

Stress tests

With inflation soaring, the US Federal Reserve announced that it would accelerate the process of normalising its monetary policy [...]

Read the article
China
New disruptions

New disruptions

After a strong start in 2022, China’s economic growth slowed in March. Headwinds are expected to persist in the very short term. Firstly, the rapid surge in the number of Covid-19 cases has led many regions to impose severe mobility restrictions [...]

Read the article
Japan
The Bank of Japan is in an uncomfortable spot

The Bank of Japan is in an uncomfortable spot

While the US Federal Reserve has begun raising its policy rate, the Bank of Japan continues to pursue a very accommodating monetary policy [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
To what extent should we worry about the risk of stagflation?

To what extent should we worry about the risk of stagflation?

The war in Ukraine compounds the ECB’s task of balancing the fight against inflationary risks with the need to support growth [...]

Read the article
Germany
Recession lurking behind growth?

Recession lurking behind growth?

Of the Eurozone’s four major economies, Germany has the least positive growth outlook for 2022. Its economy is expected to grow by around 2% this year, whereas we are forecasting around 3% in Italy and France, and around 5% in Spain [...]

Read the article
Italy
Slower growth in a more uncertain environment

Slower growth in a more uncertain environment

In Q4 2022, real GDP rose by 0.6%, after having increased by 2.7% and 2.5% in Q2 and Q3 respectively. This slowdown was widespread. Manufacturing stagnated and services suffered from the upsurge of Covid-19 cases [...]

Read the article
Spain
Employment holds up, but social tensions are rising

Employment holds up, but social tensions are rising

Although Spain is not the European country with the highest “structural” exposure to the war in Ukraine, it has been hard hit by the energy price shock. Inflation will certainly exceed 10% year-on-year this spring [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Brace for impact

Brace for impact

Belgian GDP grew by 0.5% in the fourth quarter of last year, full-year growth amounting to 6.1% [...]

Read the article
Portugal
A more contained inflationary shock

A more contained inflationary shock

The large victory of António Costa’s Socialist party in February’s legislative elections provides some welcome political stability in the current economic environment [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Green protection

Green protection

Sweden has bet heavily on renewable energy sources, a strategy that is now paying off at a time when oil and gas prices are soaring. Although accelerating, Sweden’s inflation rate is still one of the lowest in Europe, at a little more than 4% [...]

Read the article
Finland
On the front line

On the front line

Thwarted since the beginning of the year by a strong surge in the Covid-19 pandemic, the economic recovery is now threatened by the repercussions of Russia’s military offensive in Ukraine [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
A series of shocks

A series of shocks

The time has passed for unlimited fiscal and monetary support in the UK, and priority is now being given to reducing deficits and lowering inflation [...]

Read the article