Based in Paris, BNP Paribas' Economic Research Department is composed of economists and statisticians:
The Economic Research department’s mission is to cater to the economic research needs of the clients, business lines and functions of BNP Paribas. Our team of economists and statisticians covers a large number of advanced, developing and emerging countries, the real economy, financial markets and banking. As we foster the sharing of our research output with anyone who is interested in the economic situation or who needs insight into specific economic issues, this website presents our analysis, videos and podcasts.
+ 33 1 42 98 26 77 stephane.colliac@bnpparibas.com
The household savings rate in France has risen further, up from 17.6% of households' gross disposable income (GDI) in Q1 2024 to 17.9% in Q2 2024, according to the INSEE, i.e. 1 point more in a year. This is also an early sign of an upward trend underway in the Eurozone. While the figures for Q2 are not yet available, the Q1 figures pointed to a savings rate 3 points higher than its pre-COVID level (at 15.4%).
In August 2024, French inflation is expected to fall back below 2% year-on-year for the first time in three years (August 2021). This disinflation is mainly linked to energy prices and is expected to increase further at the start of 2025 for the same reasons (expected drop in electricity prices). By contrast, inflation in services, which has been impacted by an Olympic effect in particular, is expected to remain high in the short term, but will not prevent further disinflation.
Growth in exports to the United States (Germany's biggest export customer) has continued to drive German foreign trade in recent years, while trade with the eurozone and China has been relatively stagnant. For the past four months, however, the German PMI for export conditions has been above the threshold of 50 (albeit lower in June at 50.8 than in May at 51.9), suggesting a more global dynamic.
The French economy is once again feeling the weight of economic uncertainty, as shown by the rebound in the Banque de France's uncertainty indicator, which in July reached its highest level since autumn 2022 (energy crisis). This could weaken a business climate that is already a little less favourable in France (composite PMI at 48.8 in June) than in the eurozone (PMI above 50 for the past four months).
According to the expression “goods things come in threes”, France would meet Germany for the third time in the three lasts Euro football tournaments and win a third consecutive success. On the economic front, French results have already outpaced German results in three important areas over the past five years: job creation, investment growth and the transition to services. As a result, it is not surprising that France generated an additional 0.5 percentage point growth per year compared to Germany.
German growth is expected to be supported, in the short term, by the upturn in the country's industry, which should offset some of the loss of production associated with the rise in the cost of energy following the outbreak of the war in Ukraine. As an open economy, Germany is also expected to benefit from the rebound in growth in the eurozone since the beginning of 2024. However, in the longer term, German growth potential is likely to continue to suffer from labour shortages, from the weight of its industry (weakened by the low-carbon transition), and also from the consequences of insufficient investment against a backdrop of a surge in new competitors.
The French economy is characterised by growth, a statement that is all the clearer following the changeover of the national accounts to the 2020 base and the publication of the 2023 annual accounts, which led INSEE to raise its 2023 GDP estimate by almost EUR 20 billion. However, there are winners and losers from this growth. In 2024, it should be sustained mainly by market services, which account for the bulk of job creation and growth in demand. However, this growth in services substitutes that for goods, while inflation and interest rate shocks continue to weigh on investment.
In this Audiobrief, Stéphane Colliac discusses selfemployment in France. It has been growing again for almost 20 years, particularly in household services, but also in business services. In France, which has created nearly 420000 jobs a year over the last 5 years, self-employment has represented almost one job creation out of 5
In May 2024, cumulative 12-month business insolvencies exceeded 60,000 for the first time since August 2016, according to Banque de France data. This threshold has only been exceeded four times in the past. However, the dynamism of business creations and the specific nature of post-Covid normalisation reveal a clear difference between the recent and previous peaks in business insolvencies.
After a long period of decline from the late 1940s to the early 2000s, self-employment has been on the rise once again in France for almost 20 years. This resurgence of self-employment, initiated by tax incentives in favour of home-based employment or craft industries (non-market services, domestic services, building crafts), was also fuelled by the outsourcing by companies of certain tasks (for the purpose of controlling costs on non-essential activities, incubating innovation) and the emergence of new needs (in particular in terms of maintenance and renovation in building)
Europe is experiencing a losing trend in market share, due to the growth of other producers (Japan in the 1980s, China subsequently). In Germany, it even increased after the Covid-19 pandemic (-0.7 points in 2023 compared to 2019). The German chemical industry has been hit hard by rising energy prices and increasing competition from China and the US. Its automotive industry (which accounted for 17% of its exports in 2023) is suffering directly from Chinese competition.
Q1 2024 saw the household savings rate rise to 17.6% (from 17.2% in Q4 2023), thanks to moderate growth in consumption (+0.1% q/q in volume terms) in Q1 and higher growth in purchasing power (+0.6% q/q). While the savings rate has fluctuated at around 2.5 points above its pre-COVID level (14.6% in 2019) since mid-2021, we expect it to now fall back down to this 2019 level by the end of 2025. Significant support for household consumption.
The underperformance of German growth in recent years continued in 2023. However, even though it is no longer a driving force, the German economy is seemingly benefiting from the recovery seen elsewhere in the Eurozone, which could boost its growth in the coming quarters. This was reflected in a relatively good performance (0.2% q/q) in Q1, which, like the Eurozone's performance (0.3% q/q), surprised on the upside. The business climate (IFO) shows an improvement, albeit still partial, with an index of 89.3 in both May and April, making them the best two months since May 2023.
French growth surprised on the upside in Q1, hitting 0.2% q/q as a preliminary estimate, supported by household consumption and business investment in services. Our forecast for Q2 is for more of the same (our nowcast, at 0.3% q/q, even suggests an upside risk), confirming the return to slightly stronger growth, after a second half of 2023 at +0.1% per quarter.
April could see core inflation (according to the INSEE definition) fall back down to 2%. Disinflation is gradually spreading to more and more items (particularly to manufactured goods and food), resulting in inflation remaining above 2% year-on-year for just half of these items over the first three months of the year.
In recent years there has been a substitution between consumption of goods and consumption of services. This substitution even accelerated after Covid, with inflation accelerating, and is expected to continue in the coming years. Thus, while consumption of goods has declined since the beginning of 2022, this deterioration is partly due to this substitution effect and not to a reduction in household spending, since total consumption is higher than its pre-inflation level (end 2021).
The publication of INSEE’s business climate survey on Thursday 25 April confirms the prospect of an improvement in demand, which has remained depressed in recent months. Ahead of the publication of important data from 30 April, we anticipate that growth, having remained weak in Q1, should accelerate in Q2, benefiting from the disinflation observed. However, the improvement may not be sufficient to rule out the risk of business insolvencies remaining high.
The German economy has been significantly underperforming the eurozone average and past standards for just over 6 years. The country might even be in recession again in Q4 2023 and Q1 2024. So has Germany bottomed out? From an economic point of view, this is likely because the moment of weakness, posted this winter, is partly due to exceptional effects. From a structural point of view, the German economy is expected to continue to post moderate growth, which would not allow it to regain its status as a driver of European growth.
Just as in 2022 and 2023, the French economy got off to a weak start this year and is expected to see its growth accelerate in Q2. Although not in the same way as in previous years, headwinds affected the French economy in Q1 2024. Beyond this purely cyclical upturn, to return to more durable growth, we will need to wait for the return of French consumers, which we also expect to see in Q2. And lastly, corporate investment should once again bolster French growth, with the implementation of the France Green Industry plan in particular.
In Q1 2024, business insolvencies in France reached nearly 15,000 units. This is only slightly less than in Q4 2023, which was marked by a sharp rise. Although the construction and retail trade sectors are facing a significant increase in the number of businesses affected, insolvencies in these sectors remain below historic highs. On the other hand, records were set in business services and in transport and storage services.
Our Western Europe business insolvencies index has risen above its pre-COVID level. However, it is still far below the peaks seen after the 2008 crisis and during the eurozone crisis (between 2011 and 2015). In most countries, the business insolvencies level is now higher than it was before the pandemic. This has been the case since 2022 for the UK and Sweden, which were joined by France, Belgium and Germany during 2023. However, in Germany, Italy and the Netherlands, the insolvency levels are still far below their pre-COVID peaks. These diverging evolutions are also being reflected in sectors, with sharper deterioration in construction, trade and real estate agencies in the countries that have suffered the steepest decline in business activity.
The first indicators available for January point to a continuing weak start to the quarter (after contraction in GDP of -0.3% q/q in Q4 2023), hence our forecast of a further drop in GDP of -0.1% q/q in Q1. Manufacturing production (up 1% m/m in January) remained 1.5% below the figure seen in November, due to a sharp drop in automotive production (down 10% in January from the level seen in November).
Q1 got off to a bad start, with a drop in manufacturing production in January (-1.6% m/m) linked to the shutdown of oil refineries for maintenance (with new difficulties in March), and a downturn in the automotive sector (supply problems, followed by a drop in demand affecting the production). At the same time, January’s foreign trade data do not suggest a rebound in imports of intermediate goods (inputs for other sectors).
In terms of the trade balance, 2023 largely unwound the problems of 2022, which, with itsburdens and shocks, constituted an annus horribilis for French foreign trade.
According to our forecast, inflation is expected to have fallen again in March to 2.4% y/y compared to 3% in February, due to the marked easing in food prices. However, French inflation is expected to then remain between 2 and 2.5% y/y until the end of August, due to depletion of the favourable effects linked to the end of inflation on food and manufactured goods and the continuation of inflation on services, before probably falling below 2% in September.
