In the first quarter, real GDP growth in the United States and the Eurozone was almost on a par, at a quarterly rate of 0.4% for the United States and 0.3% for the Eurozone, according to initial estimates. However, on a year-on-year basis, the situation remains very much to the United States’ advantage, with growth of 3% when Eurozone growth is only 0.4%.
In line with previous months, the recovery in the private sector credit impulse continued in the first quarter of 2024, after the dip seen in the third quarter of 2023. This said, the recovery was slightly slower than at the end of 2023 and the overall trend is still negative. Developments in lending to business are traditionally more volatile over the cycle than those in lending to households. Recent ones have not deviated from this rule: in the autumn of 2023, at a time when the effects of the tightening of monetary policy were at their strongest, the impulse of lending to households did not fall as far, in absolute terms, as that for lending to businesses. Conversely, its recovery since then has been less vigorous
After two years – 2021 and 2022 – of significant improvement linked to the post-Covid recovery in activity, 2023 marked a halt in the recovery of public finances in the euro area. According to preliminary results published on Monday by Eurostat, the public deficit narrowed in 2023 by only 0.1 point of GDP, to 3.6%. The primary deficit also fell by the same magnitude, to 1.9% of GDP.
Economic activity in the eurozone is expected to gradually pick up over the course of 2024, buoyed by improving household purchasing power and falling interest rates. However, the industrial sector in the eurozone is facing major structural problems, which will not (or will only slightly) be addressed by lowering the ECB’s policy rates. The ramp-up of the EU’s recovery fund should, in theory, enable southern eurozone countries, which are the main recipients, to outperform again in 2024. However, so far, its effects have been relatively limited and the implementation problems, as highlighted in a recent European Commission report, will not go away completely this year.
The S&P Global manufacturing PMIs for the month of March point towards a pickup in economic momentum in most countries. In the Eurozone, the improvement is strong, especially in manufacturing and to a lesser degree in services. Momentum is slow however in terms of employment. In the US, the recent pickup in manufacturing sentiment is also strong compared to history. Against the background of these and other strong data, Fed officials have insisted on the need for caution in cutting rates, all the more so considering that the pace of disinflation has clearly slowed. The US soft landing view is increasingly being challenged and ‘no landing’ is put forward as an alternative
Disinflation in the euro zone continues to buoy household confidence. The European Commission index rose by 0.6 points to 14.9 points in March, according to the flash estimate. This is its highest level since February 2022 and the start of the war in Ukraine.
Monetary anchoring is one of the main arguments put forward by central banks to justify an eponymous digital currency. According to supporters of the digital euro, a reduction in the use of paper money or even its disappearance would be the natural next step and result in the creation of a digital form of central bank currency that would be the only guaranteed way of keeping the currency anchored in the digital era. Nothing could be less obvious.
With zero growth in the last quarter of 2023, the Eurozone has narrowly escaped recession, but economic activity is still hanging by a thread. Over 2023 as a whole, the increase in real GDP just reached 0.5%, and the carry-over effect for 2024 is null, as a result of a second half that was even weaker than the first one. Nevertheless, our Nowcast currently indicates growth of 0.3% q/q in Q1 2024, which is higher than our December forecast.
There is a broad consensus amongst forecasters that Eurozone quarterly growth in real GDP will gradually pick up over the year on the back of a further decline of inflation, cuts in official interest rates, investments in the energy transition and those related to NextGeneration EU. Foreign trade may also play a role. Survey data of the European Commission and S&P Global have improved since the autumn of last year but their level remains below the historical average. Based on historical relationships, their positive momentum -recent observations are better than those 3 months ago- increases the likelihood that GDP growth in the first quarter will be better than in the final quarter of 2023.
Despite the positive momentum it would be premature to say that the recovery has started in the Eurozone, but at least we are moving in the right direction.
The ECB’s tightening of monetary policy between the summer of 2022 and September 2023 continued to have its effects on euro zone bank lending in the fourth quarter of 2023. However, in the absence of a further turn of the screw since September 2023, these effects have not intensified further. Outstanding bank loans to the private sector even accelerated slightly, year-on-year, in the fourth quarter (up 0.5% in December 2023 compared to 0.3% in September) in line with GDP (up 0.1% in the fourth quarter from 0.0% in the third). The credit impulse remains negative but increased slightly for the first time since the ECB began to increase rates in July 2022.
Eurozone activity is expected to pick up moderately in 2024, buoyed by the fall in inflation and the start of a cutting cycle of policy rates, which, according to our forecasts, will take place in April. The labour market continues to surprise on the upside. However, industrial production is falling sharply and remains highly exposed to escalating tensions in the Red Sea and the repercussions on shipping and supply chains. 2024 will see a number of national parliamentary and presidential elections (Finland, Portugal, Belgium, Austria) and the European elections (6 to 9 June), which are likely to redraw the political landscape in the region and the balance of power within the European Parliament.
The eurozone narrowly escaped economic contraction in the last quarter of 2023, but the picture is mixed among countries. According to preliminary figures from Eurostat, real GDP in the euro area remained stable in Q4, following a slight decline of 0.1% q/q in Q3. Quarterly growth surprised to the upside in Spain (+0.6%), Italy (+0.2%), while the data for France (0.0%) and Germany (-0.3%) were in line with the consensus. The largest decline in the euro area came from Ireland (-0.7%) while Portugal’s growth rose the most (+0.8%).
Because of its significance and its many connections with the real and financial spheres, the residential property sector plays a central role in the economic cycle. The acceleration in property prices in the eurozone, which began in 2014, the year in which the monetary bloc emerged from recession, intensified after the "Great Lockdown" of 2020, peaking at almost 10% year-on-year in the first quarter of 2022. The tightening of monetary policy by the European Central Bank, unprecedented in its scale and speed, seems to have put a halt to this progress, although at this stage there are significant differences between countries. Economies where the property market had withstood the subprime crisis better now appear to be in greater difficulty in the face of tighter credit conditions
The end of the year is shaping up to be a difficult one for the eurozone, as displayed by the flash PMI indicators for December. The composite index, fell by 0.6 points to 47, and remains below the threshold of 50 (in contraction territory) for the seventh month in a row. The employment index has not plummeted, but has been gradually declining since April, reaching 49.6 in December, its lowest level in three years. At 6.5% in October, the unemployment rate in the eurozone stabilised at a historically-low level, which is increasingly looking like a floor. We expect the jobless rate to rise slightly over the next few months, in line with current trends in the PMI indices. The unemployment rate for young people (under 25) has already risen by one percentage point in six months, to 14
The ECB's latest macroeconomic projections show fairly marginal downward revisions to inflation (headline and core) and economic growth for both 2023 and 2024, compared to the September forecast. With real GDP growth now foreseen at 0.6% on average this year and 0.8% next year, the ECB's projections are slightly higher than ours, currently at 0.5% and 0.6% respectively.
Inflation remains high but, judging by the latest figures published for the Eurozone, it is much less so and, at first glance, it is no longer very far from the 2% target. Of course, there is still some way to go; the uncertainty relates in particular to how fast the “last mile” of disinflation will be covered, before reaching the 2% target. It is to be expected to be slow rather than quick, partly because favorable base effects on energy prices will play less.
Recent business surveys suggest that the cyclical environment in the Eurozone, Germany and France is stabilising but it would be premature to call it a bottoming out. Such a positive development seems unlikely in the near term. Monetary policy is expected to remain tight for some time and part of the effect of the past rate hikes still needs to manifest itself. Bank lending policy is expected to remain cautious because of rising credit risk in a stagnating, high interest rates economy and credit demand from firms and households is weak. Significant progress in terms of disinflation seems to be a necessary condition for a lasting upturn in the economic outlook.
Without falling significantly, confidence indicators for the euro area confirm the current phase of stagnation, which is expected to continue into Q4 2023. According to the flash estimate, the composite PMI edged up by 0.6 points to 47.1 in November, while the European Commission's Economic Sentiment Indicator fell slightly in October, down by 0.1 points to 93.3 (its lowest level in three years). Despite the current deceleration in inflation (from 4.3% y/y in September to 2.9% y/y in October in harmonised terms) and an unemployment rate that is close to its lowest ever (6.5% in September), household confidence is not recovering, against a still difficult backdrop in terms of purchasing power
The tightening of euro-zone monetary policy, which began in July 2022 and carried on until September 2023, continued to curb demand for loans and dampen economic activity in the third quarter of 2023. The initial effects on core inflation have also been apparent since the end of the summer.
The September data show that disinflation continues in the Eurozone. Moreover, this development is broad-based and for more than half of the HICP items, 3-month inflation is below the ECB’s target expressed on an equivalent basis. This increases the likelihood that the decline in inflation continues to spread through the Eurozone economy. However, despite the progress, inflation remains well above target. This implies that, if going forward monthly core inflation would correspond to the ECB’s target (expressed as a monthly number), it would still take until September next year for it to get back to 2% in terms of annual inflation
The inflation situation, in the Eurozone, is cooling. Added to this good news is the surprising continued drop in the unemployment rate (6.4% in August compared with 6.7% at the beginning of the year). But these positive developments are offset by a cooling also being seen in the European Commission Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI). Given the weakness of confidence surveys, real GDP growth – only just positive in Q1 and Q2 2023 (+0.1% q/q each quarter) – is expected to be close to zero. We expect nil growth in both Q3 and Q4 2023, a forecast aligned with our nowcast estimate, also at zero.
Eurozone company surveys (PMI, European Commission) continued to deteriorate throughout the summer, although a slight improvement was observed in September for the PMI. The rise in policy rates by 25 basis points in September – the last one according to our forecast – will amplify this phenomenon. We do not expect a recession in the euro zone as a whole in 2023, but moderate growth at 0.5%, mainly due to a favourable carry-over effect in 2022. After a slightly positive first semester, eurozone activity is likely to stall in the second semester. Significant growth differentials are expected between the Member States.
The impact on financial expenses of rising interest rates - the result of the European Central Bank tightening its monetary policy - is very mixed, depending on the euro zone country. The impact depends on the proportion of variable-rate loans in outstanding amounts, and also on levels and changes in the amounts borrowed.
Inflation in the Eurozone is declining and recent survey data point towards a possible stabilisation of economic activity. However, inflation remains well above target and business sentiment has reached a (very) low level. Based on the historical relationship, the current level of the S&P Global composite PMI and the economic sentiment index of the European Commission point towards, at best, a stagnation of activity in the coming months. Whether growth will turn out to be higher or lower will largely depend on how the environment will change. Downside risks are the delayed effect of past monetary tightening and, to a lesser degree, the recent rise in energy prices and the weaker growth environment in China
