Despite a substantial increase in new Covid-19 infections since the start of November, the infection rate is currently below those in France or Germany. Meanwhile, concerns about the health situation have had little effect on business confidence so far: the PMI Composite index improved in November (up 1.9 points to 58.3) thanks to better prospects in services. The positive trend in this sector can also be seen in the European Commission survey, which reveals levels of optimism not seen for twenty years. This said, household confidence has fallen back, mainly due to fears of rising consumer prices.
The resurgence of the Covid-19 pandemic and the emergence of the new Omicron variant make the ECB’s task even harder. Although growth should hold at a high level, it is expected to ease, and this trend could worsen, at least in the short term. Meanwhile inflation continues to soar, while becoming more broadbased, and the risk in the coming months is on the upside. Faced with greater uncertainty, the ECB is arguing in favour of patience and constancy while saying it is ready to act in any direction. According to our scenario, which is somewhat optimistic in terms of growth and calls for persistent inflation, the ECB would end its Pandemic Emergency Purchase Programme (PEPP) in March 2022 and begin raising its key deposit rate in mid-2023.
After strong growth in Q2 and Q3, the business climate deteriorated due to supply problems, the increase in prices and the surge in Covid-19 infections. Output is likely to stagnate around the turn of the year. The new government will put the emphasis on social and environmental policies, while fully respecting the fiscal framework, important for Germany. Private consumption will be the major engine for growth in 2022.
Factors hampering growth in the short term are gaining strength (supply chain disruptions, surging inflation, and the resurgence in the Covid-19 pandemic), but the resilience of business sentiment through November as well as numerous targeted measures to support household purchasing power help allay fears. In Q4 2021, we are forecasting growth of 0.6%, although the risk is on the downside. In full-year 2021, growth is expected to average 6.7%. In 2022, it will remain a robust 4.2%, bolstered by the accommodative policy mix, the unblocking of excess savings, the catching-up of the services sector as well as strong investment and restocking needs.
After a modest expansion in Q1 2021, real GDP rose by more than 2.5% q/q in both Q2 and in Q3. This recovery was widespread. In Q3, net exports added 0.5 percentage point to GDP growth thanks to a stronger rise in exports than imports. Thanks to the easing of social restrictions, consumption has further increased, while favourable financing conditions and fiscal incentives have supported investment. During the summer, the recovery expanded to the services sector, which benefitted from higher tourist receipts. Manufacturing production has recovered entirely from the 2020 decline, ending up 2% higher than in Q4 2019. Labour market conditions are not as good as the recovery would suggest.
Despite a rather weak recovery in GDP, the Spanish economy has been much more resilient on the labour market front in 2021. Employment (November) and the participation rate (Q3) are at record levels. Inflation will be one of the biggest obstacles in 2022, the increase in production prices having accelerated markedly this autumn. Support for growth will remain a government priority in 2022. The country will benefit from a larger transfer of European funds that will help finance a record budget of EUR196 billion. The reduction in the government deficit will be again pushed into the background, the authorities mainly betting on economic growth to reduce the deficit-to-GDP ratio.
Q3 Belgian GDP growth came in at 2% q/q, which is well above consensus. GDP thus exceeded its pre-Covid level for the first time since the start of the pandemic. For this year, we estimate the growth rate to reach 6.1% in annual average terms, with a slower but still above-potential growth rate of 3.1% expected for next year. As it stands, the Belgian economy looks to have avoided additional scarring; however, with elevated public debt levels entering the limelight once again, the De Croo government has its work cut out.
Once Covid-related restrictions are lifted, the economy is projected to rebound strongly in 2022, driven initially by household consumption. Next year, the fiscal stance is likely to tighten because of the gradual withdrawal of the special support measures. A major political risk is the possible falling apart of coalition between the conservative ÖVP and the Greens.
Confronted like the rest of Europe by an upsurge in Covid-19 cases, Finland has reintroduced protective health measures that could temporarily dampen its recovery. Estimated at 3.4% in 2021, GDP growth could still reach 2.8% in 2022 according to the European Commission. After taking a reasonable approach to “whatever the cost”, the government is now seeking to consolidate public finances.
The Greek economy has surprised on the upside so far in 2021. Real GDP growth is expected to exceed 7% this year. The unemployment rate has fallen to 13% in September. This improvement has allowed the banking sector to continue its clean-up, with a non-performing loan ratio close to the 20% threshold at the beginning of the summer. Difficulties on the economic, social and banking front remain amongst the most pressing in the European Union. This said, unless there is a further complication on the health front, Greece will go into 2022 on a much better basis than in previous years.
The public and private moratoria granted since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic to the Portuguese non-financial private sector[1] have, to a very large extent, now expired. The outstanding amount of loans under moratoria stood at EUR3.1 bn in October 2021, from EUR3.6 bn in March 2020 and a peak of EUR46.3 bn in September 2020. Moratoria now cover only 1.5% of outstanding loans to households and non-financial corporations, from 1.9% in March 2020 and 23.5% in September 2020. The expiry of moratoria since September 2021 has not, so far, resulted in a significant increase in non-performing loans[2]. Their outstanding amount (EUR4.0 billion) and ratio (2.0% of loans) have returned to their July 2008 levels
In most European countries, the structural primary deficit should shrink next year. This reduction represents a negative fiscal impulse, raising concern that it would act as a headwind to growth. However, the level of the primary deficit is such that it still corresponds to an accommodative fiscal stance. Taking into account national fiscal policies as well as expenditures financed by the Recovery and Resilience Facility and other EU grants, fiscal policy in the euro area should have a significant positive impact on GDP growth next year, thereby accompanying and strengthening the ongoing recovery. In addition, it should enhance the effectiveness of the ECB’s accommodative policy.
The ECB’s meeting on 16 December is highly anticipated, primarily for the central bank’s new growth and inflation forecasts. When it comes to growth, the ECB’s September forecast was for annual average growth of 5% in 2021, 4.6% in 2022 and 2.1% in 2023. It could leave its 2021 forecast unchanged, with the positive figures for Q3 offset by a less positive view of Q4, due to the effect of supply constraints, inflationary pressures and a resurgence of the pandemic. Growth in 2022 will be weakened by the same factors. The scale of the forecast downward revision will indicate the level of the ECB’s concerns. It will also be interesting to see whether any growth ‘lost’ in 2022 will be shifted, in part at least, into a higher forecast for 2023.
Our Pulse is clearly pointing to bad weather, as the blue area of the spider chart – the economic situation in the past three months – is clearly shrinking compared to the situation in the preceding three months – the area within the dashed line. The deterioration is noticeable in all sectors, with the exception of the construction industry. Ifo reported that the business climate in the manufacturing sector worsened in November for the fifth consecutive month. Industrial activity is dampened by supply bottlenecks and rising input prices. The improvement in expectations, in particular in the car industry, could signal that the shortages of parts in this sector are diminishing.
The first indications for Q4 2021 suggest that the main confidence indicators are holding at high levels, especially business sentiment. The improvement in the French labour market observed over the past several months also seems to be continuing. With Q3 GDP growth recently confirmed at 3% q/q, France should have no trouble reaching our full-year 2021 forecast of 6.7%. Even so, our Pulse seems to suggest that growth is slowing, held back by several headwinds. The first is the lag between order books and the turnaround time necessary for companies to meet demand. Order books have been full for several months, but supply disruptions are accumulating.
In September 2021 a slight acceleration in lending to eurozone non-financial companies (NFCs), which rose 2.1% y/y from 1.9% in June, interrupted the deterioration of the credit impulse (which reflects the year-on-year change in outstanding loans). However, this remained negative (-1.4% in September, from -1.9% in June) due to a high basi of comparison.
Companies in the euro area report record-high levels of labour shortages. These are partly cyclical in nature but structural factors also play a role. Last year’s annual investment survey of the European Investment Bank shows that the availability of staff with the right skills is the second most important factor weighing on long-term investment decisions in the EU. Structural labour shortages can weigh on potential GDP growth through its impact on capital formation, innovation and productivity. Economic and, in particular, education policy including vocational training and lifelong learning schemes will have to make sure that, going forward, the available skills, both in quantity and quality, fit the evolving needs.
According to our Pulse, the Eurozone’s cyclical situation has deteriorated over the past three months (the blue area is smaller than the area within the dotted lines). Hard data have dropped sharply but the decline in business climate surveys has been much milder. This difference is due to statistical distortions. For retail sales and production, the sharp decline in growth rates in year-on-year terms since May reflects a normalisation after the previous 3-month average was inflated by very favourable base effects in March and April.
After two solid quarters, Italian GDP growth is expected to slow in Q4 2021. Real GDP rose 2.7% q/q in Q2 2021 and 2.6% q/q in Q3. Yet there was an encouraging catching-up movement through the fall, which led the European Commission to revise strongly upwards its 2021 growth forecast, to 6.2%, from its previous outlook of 4.2% last spring. While a new epidemic wave could weigh on activity in the coming weeks, Italy is currently facing a level of contamination much lower than most other European countries.
Like other economies, Spain is currently facing several headwinds, including labour shortages, supply-chain problems and inflation. The country is now also facing the risk of another upsurge in the pandemic. In mid-November, the number of Covid-19 cases was still holding at a very moderate level, but it now seems to be ticking upward, a movement that is bound to accelerate with the approach of winter. Even so, Spain benefits from a high vaccine coverage ratio (more than 80% of the population is fully covered by the vaccine), meaning that the country can look forward to a less perilous winter than last year.
Employment in Spain continues to pleasantly surprise this autumn. The number of employees affiliated with the social security system increased in October (+102,474), reaching a record level of 19,662,163. Significant numbers of jobs created were recorded in sectors that have partly "benefited" from the health crisis and the structural changes it has caused or amplified (information and communications, health and social care, logistics and transport). The unemployment rate remained high (14.6% in September), as did underemployment (7.4% of the total working population), but the participation rate for 16 to 64-year-olds was at a historically-high level (75.8% in Q3 2021). While the first GDP estimate for Q3 2021 was disappointing overall (+2.0% q/q after an increase of just 1
In the euro area, business surveys report record-high staff shortages. They represent a headwind to growth and raise the possibility of faster wage growth and a pick-up in inflation. Thus far, growth of negotiated wages has been subdued but, given its historical relationship with labour market bottlenecks, an acceleration seems likely. Despite the difficulties of companies in filling vacancies, labour market slack has remained above pre-pandemic levels. This situation should improve in the coming months but whether this eases labour market tensions depends on companies’ hiring intentions. Based on recent surveys, these should remain elevated.
Manufacturing in Poland, as in the other central European countries, has been hit by increasingly severe shortages of inputs. Numerous components are in short supply, from semi-conductors to plastic parts. As a result, automobile production is down 15% from the high of year-end 2020, while electrical equipment is down 8% compared to the May 2021 peak. In both cases, production declined even though order books are relatively strong. Moreover, they have had a direct impact on the current account balance, which suddenly dropped from an average monthly surplus of EUR 500 m in H1 2021 to a deficit of about EUR 1.5 bn a month starting in July
Markets have been pricing in an early lift-off of the ECB’s deposit rate. The ECB argues that, considering its inflation outlook, this is not warranted. This difference in view could reflect a loss of central bank credibility. More likely is that market participants and the ECB disagree on the inflation outlook. Another explanation is that investors focus on the distribution of possible inflation outcomes and are concerned about the risks of inflation surprising to the upside.
The German economy further recovered in the third quarter, as GDP strengthened by 1.8% from the preceding quarter. Growth is mainly driven by higher consumer spending related to improved labour market conditions and a further relaxation of sanitary measures. However, our Pulse chart indicates that this favourable environment is unlikely to last: the situation in the three months to October (blue area) worsened compared to the situation in the preceding three-month period (area within the broken line).
