Economic surveys remain deteriorated. The PMI indices indicate a contraction in activity that is now more widespread, although the downturn is particularly pronounced in the manufacturing sector. The manufacturing PMI fell by 1.9 points to 44.9 in October, while the services PMI dropped more sharply below the 50 mark, after recording a decline of 2.2 points to 47.7. The household consumer confidence index in Italy is decorrelating from inflation expectations– which have been stable since the spring – and is now falling due to the effect of more subdued economic and employment prospects. In fact, the monthly fall in the confidence indicator (-2.4 points) was the steepest in the last fifteen months
The Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) rose again to +3.5% y/y in October (+0.21 pp). Food inflation remains high, although it eased from September (+9.5% y/y in October, -1 pp). However, the surge in olive oil prices persisted (+73.5% y/y, +6.5 pp), contributing 0.37 points to overall inflation. As for energy, the deflation is subsiding but remains significant (-10.1% y/y, -3.7 pp). Core inflation meanwhile, eased to +3.8% over a year.
The momentum of private payroll employment has recently slowed in the euro area, as evidenced by job destruction in France and Germany in Q3. This destruction can be partly explained by cyclical sectors, particularly construction. It is a sign that demand constraints are increasingly impacting companies and the labour market.However, labour shortages remain high in the northern countries of the euro area and in Central Europe and, in general, in sectors where demand is not falling (aeronautics and building renovation in particular). Beyond an economic slowdown, which we expect to last until spring 2024, impacting employment, the low level of unemployment and historically high labour shortages should continue to characterise the European economy.
Key figures for the French economy compared with those of the main European countries, analysis of data on the population and the French labour market, activity by sector, publication administration figures, inflation, credit and interest rates, corporate and household accounts.
In Central Europe, national accounts for the third quarter were published earlier this week. Hungary has exited recession after 4 quarters of negative growth. Poland continues to experience erratic growth with a rebound this time. However, other Central European countries saw a slowdown in economic activity. Romania is no exception. Q3 GDP growth came in at 0.4% quarter on quarter after 0.9% in Q2. Romania’s economy should overall show resilience this year while some countries such as Hungary and Czech Republic may post a negative GDP growth in 2023.
Both France and Germany shed jobs in Q3 2023 as more and more companies struggled with sluggish demand. Against this backdrop, labour shortages are limiting less production, particularly in Germany, where they were more acute. However, these shortages are persisting, as they are structural, against a backdrop of low unemployment. Output from sectors with the strongest demand (i.e. aeronautics particularly in France) may suffer as a result, as well as development of sectors with the highest labour needs, particularly industries associated with the green transition (electrification and renovation).
The dynamism of French exports has noticeably slowed over the past few months. Although exports over the first 9 months of the year are EUR 14 billion higher than those recorded over the same period in 2022, most of this gain was achieved in Q1. Over Q2 and Q3, the cumulative increase in exports was limited to EUR 1 billion (compared to Q2 and Q3 2022), with aeronautical exports (+5.5 billion) leading the increase.
The tightening of euro-zone monetary policy, which began in July 2022 and carried on until September 2023, continued to curb demand for loans and dampen economic activity in the third quarter of 2023. The initial effects on core inflation have also been apparent since the end of the summer.
The September data show that disinflation continues in the Eurozone. Moreover, this development is broad-based and for more than half of the HICP items, 3-month inflation is below the ECB’s target expressed on an equivalent basis. This increases the likelihood that the decline in inflation continues to spread through the Eurozone economy. However, despite the progress, inflation remains well above target. This implies that, if going forward monthly core inflation would correspond to the ECB’s target (expressed as a monthly number), it would still take until September next year for it to get back to 2% in terms of annual inflation
The inflation situation, in the Eurozone, is cooling. Added to this good news is the surprising continued drop in the unemployment rate (6.4% in August compared with 6.7% at the beginning of the year). But these positive developments are offset by a cooling also being seen in the European Commission Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI). Given the weakness of confidence surveys, real GDP growth – only just positive in Q1 and Q2 2023 (+0.1% q/q each quarter) – is expected to be close to zero. We expect nil growth in both Q3 and Q4 2023, a forecast aligned with our nowcast estimate, also at zero.
German inflation resumed its downward trend, after stabilising between May and August (6.4% y/y in August according to the harmonised index), to reach 4.3% in September, due, firstly, to base effects (seasonally adjusted inflation was 2.3% m/m in September 2022, compared to a more normal 0.3% in September 2023). We expect a further drop in inflation of nearly 1 pp in October for the same reason (+1.1% m/m in September 2022 1 pp above the average for October over the last 15 years). Underlying inflation also fell to 4.8% y/y in September after a high of 6.3% in August 2023
The hierarchy has changed: French inflation, which was well below inflation in the eurozone, is now higher (5.7% in September compared to 4.3% y/y, according to the harmonised index). On average, French inflation even exceeded its June-July level by nearly 0.5 points in August-September (compared to a drop of 0.6 points in the euro zone). This was due to the rebound in energy prices, which was stronger in France, particularly with the increase in the regulated electricity tariff in August 2023 (+10%). Conversely, the drop in underlying inflation continued (3.6% y/y in September compared to 4.3% in July). This is mainly due to stabilisation of the (seasonally adjusted) index for manufactured goods prices between April and September.
Household confidence has dropped slightly since April. This reflects a decline in purchasing intentions for durable goods and a deterioration in the outlook for unemployment. Nevertheless, the Italian labour market remains on track. Unemployment fell to 7.3% in August, its lowest rate in fifteen years. As a result of this drop, recruitment problems are intensifying: the proportion of companies citing labour shortages as a factor limiting production was, in Q2 2023, the largest seen since the early 1990s. Although the working population is far from having closed the gap between the levels seen in 2019 (the deficit was 1.3% in August compared to the peak in April 2019), employment has continued to rise very significantly. This has helped to raise the employment rate (to 61
In September, the European Commission’s economic sentiment indicator fell to its lowest level of the year in Spain. This reflects a slowdown in activity which, according to our forecasts, will result in a slowdown in growth to 0.3% q/q in Q3 and 0.2% q/q in Q4. Inflation is also regaining ground and is again weighing on household confidence, as is the modest deterioration in the unemployment expectations index. It should be noted that the outlook for price developments differs quite significantly depending on the sector, according to the European Commission’s survey: it indicates a new pullback in price pressures in construction (-1.9 pts) and industry (-1.6 pts, the lowest since January 2021), while an upturn is observed in services (+3
In Central Europe, capital flows (foreign direct investments, portfolio flows and bank lending flows) have resisted rather well despite geopolitical uncertainties. Similarly, they do not seem to be affected, for the time being, by the weakening of economic activity in the region.
The current government is running for a third term in the general elections on 15th October. Whatever the outcome, the future government will face three major economic challenges: a marked slowdown in growth, a deterioration in budget deficit and an increase in credit risk. However, this increase in risk is not a real cause for concern. There are safeguards against rising public debt. The country also has comfortable external liquidity and the banking sector is strong. The decline in inflation has facilitated the shift in gear in monetary policy, but this seems premature given strong pressure on wages.
Despite the unprecedented rise in interest rates, in Spain, the non-performing loan ratio for households and corporations remains at an all-time low.
Eurozone company surveys (PMI, European Commission) continued to deteriorate throughout the summer, although a slight improvement was observed in September for the PMI. The rise in policy rates by 25 basis points in September – the last one according to our forecast – will amplify this phenomenon. We do not expect a recession in the euro zone as a whole in 2023, but moderate growth at 0.5%, mainly due to a favourable carry-over effect in 2022. After a slightly positive first semester, eurozone activity is likely to stall in the second semester. Significant growth differentials are expected between the Member States.
The German economy is affected by the transmission of the inflationary shock to household consumption. However, the underperformance of the German economy also reflects more structural difficulties, reminding the “Standort Deutschland[1]” debate. These difficulties began in 2018 shortly before the first European regulations aimed at adapting the automotive sector to climate change were implemented. Manufacturing output has never returned to the November 2017 peak and production capacity in the sector has declined. Against a backdrop that is still difficult, we expect another recession in the second half of 2023.
The French economy is characterised by a dichotomy. Household spending – consumption and investment – has decreased in volume (-1.4% and -6.6% in Q2 compared to Q4 2021), while corporate investment has increased (+6.7% between Q4 2021 and Q2 2023). This factor, combined with the reduction in constraints on the production of transport equipment, has enabled high growth in Q2 (0.5% q/q). While these factors should continue to support economic activity in the medium term, growth may be constrained in the coming quarters by the fall in demand against the background of high household savings.
In Q2, real GDP declined by 0.4%, driven by weakening domestic demand. Investment in machinery and equipment fell, reflecting the worsening of firms’ economic and financial conditions. Consumption slightly recovered in real terms. Italian households suffer, however, from both higher consumer prices and increasing interest rates. In Q2, there was a contraction across many sectors. Services value added unexpectedly declined, reflecting the slower recovery of tourism. Inflation is slowly falling: in September it grew +5.7% y/y. Contrary to most predictions, in Q2 2023 house prices increased by 2.0% q/q.
Until this summer, the Spanish economy had proved resilient to the interest rate shock. Private consumption and investment were up respectively, 2.7% y/y and 2.0% in Q2 2023. The positive trend in the labour market and the savings accumulated during the pandemic supported household spending, along with the decline in inflation, which allowed purchasing power to stabilise. However, these supports are falling off. Economic activity will slow in H2 2023 but will not come to a standstill. However, with growth now forecast at 2.2% in 2023 as a whole, Spain will remain one of the drivers of the euro zone this year.
Negative revisions to GDP figures have darkened the mood of the Belgian economy. We expect GDP to remain flat throughout the second half of this year as monetary policy does its job. Short-term volatility in inflation numbers looks likely, resulting in a temporary bout of deflation near year’s end. The labour market remains in good health, suggesting a soft landing is in the cards. Successful government bond emissions could tempt some last-minute pre-election spending by the De Croo-government, but the long-term outlook for public finances remains bleak.
The impact on financial expenses of rising interest rates - the result of the European Central Bank tightening its monetary policy - is very mixed, depending on the euro zone country. The impact depends on the proportion of variable-rate loans in outstanding amounts, and also on levels and changes in the amounts borrowed.
