The signs of the French economy cooling down intensified in December, with a further fall in the flash composite PMI to 43.7 (44.6 in November). The manufacturing PMI has been below 50 for 11 months and hit a new low in December, as did the services PMI.
Economic growth is slowing down in Italy. After contracting by 0.4% q/q in Q2, economic activity only grew by 0.1% q/q in Q3, almost standing still in that quarter. This small rebound was led by consumer spending (+0.6% q/q, contribution of 0.4 percentage points) and foreign trade (+0.8 points). Nevertheless, these positive developments were counterbalanced by significant destocking. For its part, investment recorded a quarterly change of -0.1% in Q3.
Contrary to the trend observed in the other three major eurozone countries, Spain recorded a more moderate fall in inflation in November. According to the INE, the growth in the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) slowed by 0.2 pp to 3.3% y/y this month (while the decline reached 0.7 points in France and Germany, and 1.1 points in Italy). Based on recent trends in the producer price index, which recorded its eighth consecutive month of deflation in October (-7.8% y/y), this consumer price slowdown is set to continue, and even accelerate, over the coming months.
In France, the housing sector has undergone profound changes over the past two decades in order to respond to the shift in demand towards building renovation and maintenance in particular. This transformation has gathered pace since 2016 against a buoyant economic backdrop, with a growing real estate market and particularly favourable financing conditions (low interest rates and few business insolvencies). However, while the sector will have to continue to adapt (i.e. the gradual ban on renting poorly insulated dwellings), it is grappling with a deterioration of its economic environment. Rising interest rates and business insolvencies could make this new adaptation more complicated to navigate, at least in the short term.
The ECB's latest macroeconomic projections show fairly marginal downward revisions to inflation (headline and core) and economic growth for both 2023 and 2024, compared to the September forecast. With real GDP growth now foreseen at 0.6% on average this year and 0.8% next year, the ECB's projections are slightly higher than ours, currently at 0.5% and 0.6% respectively.
Inflation remains high but, judging by the latest figures published for the Eurozone, it is much less so and, at first glance, it is no longer very far from the 2% target. Of course, there is still some way to go; the uncertainty relates in particular to how fast the “last mile” of disinflation will be covered, before reaching the 2% target. It is to be expected to be slow rather than quick, partly because favorable base effects on energy prices will play less.
Business insolvencies continued to rise in October and are now 10% higher than their pre-COVID level (2019 figures) in cumulative terms over the last three months, according to data from Banque de France.
In a recent speech, ECB President Christine Lagarde said that when the financing needs of an economic transformation exceed the capacities of fragmented financial markets, developing a capital markets union becomes crucial. This is the point at which the EU has arrived. According to European Commission estimates, financing the energy and digital transition will require more than EUR 700 billion annually. One way of reducing capital market fragmentation is by lowering the cost of information gathering for investors, e.g. through the harmonisation and, where possible, simplification of standards and regulations. This would increase the risk bearing capacity of investors and lower the cost of financing for issuers
German exports of goods fell in October according to Destatis, continuing the trend seen over previous months. As a result, exports have been contributing negatively to German growth for almost a year, most notably exports to China. However, in October, exports to the European Union fell, after being hit by the decline in growth in the region.
After several quarters of high job creation (89,000 on average between Q2 2022 and Q1 2023), Q3 confirmed the loss of momentum observed in Q2 (37,000 new jobs after 27,000). Payroll employment in construction and the temporary employment sector are contracting. However, industry continues to create jobs (12,000), as do non-temporary trade services (34,000).
Recent business surveys suggest that the cyclical environment in the Eurozone, Germany and France is stabilising but it would be premature to call it a bottoming out. Such a positive development seems unlikely in the near term. Monetary policy is expected to remain tight for some time and part of the effect of the past rate hikes still needs to manifest itself. Bank lending policy is expected to remain cautious because of rising credit risk in a stagnating, high interest rates economy and credit demand from firms and households is weak. Significant progress in terms of disinflation seems to be a necessary condition for a lasting upturn in the economic outlook.
Without falling significantly, confidence indicators for the euro area confirm the current phase of stagnation, which is expected to continue into Q4 2023. According to the flash estimate, the composite PMI edged up by 0.6 points to 47.1 in November, while the European Commission's Economic Sentiment Indicator fell slightly in October, down by 0.1 points to 93.3 (its lowest level in three years). Despite the current deceleration in inflation (from 4.3% y/y in September to 2.9% y/y in October in harmonised terms) and an unemployment rate that is close to its lowest ever (6.5% in September), household confidence is not recovering, against a still difficult backdrop in terms of purchasing power
Germany has just experienced four quarters of stagnation or negative growth, and business climate indicators suggest that economic activity remained broadly depressed at the beginning of Q4: current conditions of economic activity remain close to their lowest levels in both the IFO survey and the ZEW survey (-80 for the latter in November). In line with this depressed environment, production in key sectors (automotive, chemicals and metals) declined again in September (in Q3, it is now nearly 15% below the peak reached at the end of 2017 for each of these sectors). Exports do not drive growth as well (-6% y/y in Q3, trade balance figures in terms of value from Destatis).
The French economy is marked by growing signs of cooling, in terms of economic activity, employment and inflation. While growth has so far remained in positive territory, the INSEE business climate, which fell to 97 in November (compared to 100 between July and September), points to a deterioration. According to this survey, the decline in economic activity already present in part of the economy (housing, food trade) has spread to industry, new construction (excluding housing) and the motor vehicles trade.
Economic surveys remain deteriorated. The PMI indices indicate a contraction in activity that is now more widespread, although the downturn is particularly pronounced in the manufacturing sector. The manufacturing PMI fell by 1.9 points to 44.9 in October, while the services PMI dropped more sharply below the 50 mark, after recording a decline of 2.2 points to 47.7. The household consumer confidence index in Italy is decorrelating from inflation expectations– which have been stable since the spring – and is now falling due to the effect of more subdued economic and employment prospects. In fact, the monthly fall in the confidence indicator (-2.4 points) was the steepest in the last fifteen months
The Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) rose again to +3.5% y/y in October (+0.21 pp). Food inflation remains high, although it eased from September (+9.5% y/y in October, -1 pp). However, the surge in olive oil prices persisted (+73.5% y/y, +6.5 pp), contributing 0.37 points to overall inflation. As for energy, the deflation is subsiding but remains significant (-10.1% y/y, -3.7 pp). Core inflation meanwhile, eased to +3.8% over a year.
The momentum of private payroll employment has recently slowed in the euro area, as evidenced by job destruction in France and Germany in Q3. This destruction can be partly explained by cyclical sectors, particularly construction. It is a sign that demand constraints are increasingly impacting companies and the labour market.However, labour shortages remain high in the northern countries of the euro area and in Central Europe and, in general, in sectors where demand is not falling (aeronautics and building renovation in particular). Beyond an economic slowdown, which we expect to last until spring 2024, impacting employment, the low level of unemployment and historically high labour shortages should continue to characterise the European economy.
Key figures for the French economy compared with those of the main European countries, analysis of data on the population and the French labour market, activity by sector, publication administration figures, inflation, credit and interest rates, corporate and household accounts.
In Central Europe, national accounts for the third quarter were published earlier this week. Hungary has exited recession after 4 quarters of negative growth. Poland continues to experience erratic growth with a rebound this time. However, other Central European countries saw a slowdown in economic activity. Romania is no exception. Q3 GDP growth came in at 0.4% quarter on quarter after 0.9% in Q2. Romania’s economy should overall show resilience this year while some countries such as Hungary and Czech Republic may post a negative GDP growth in 2023.
Both France and Germany shed jobs in Q3 2023 as more and more companies struggled with sluggish demand. Against this backdrop, labour shortages are limiting less production, particularly in Germany, where they were more acute. However, these shortages are persisting, as they are structural, against a backdrop of low unemployment. Output from sectors with the strongest demand (i.e. aeronautics particularly in France) may suffer as a result, as well as development of sectors with the highest labour needs, particularly industries associated with the green transition (electrification and renovation).
The dynamism of French exports has noticeably slowed over the past few months. Although exports over the first 9 months of the year are EUR 14 billion higher than those recorded over the same period in 2022, most of this gain was achieved in Q1. Over Q2 and Q3, the cumulative increase in exports was limited to EUR 1 billion (compared to Q2 and Q3 2022), with aeronautical exports (+5.5 billion) leading the increase.
The tightening of euro-zone monetary policy, which began in July 2022 and carried on until September 2023, continued to curb demand for loans and dampen economic activity in the third quarter of 2023. The initial effects on core inflation have also been apparent since the end of the summer.
The September data show that disinflation continues in the Eurozone. Moreover, this development is broad-based and for more than half of the HICP items, 3-month inflation is below the ECB’s target expressed on an equivalent basis. This increases the likelihood that the decline in inflation continues to spread through the Eurozone economy. However, despite the progress, inflation remains well above target. This implies that, if going forward monthly core inflation would correspond to the ECB’s target (expressed as a monthly number), it would still take until September next year for it to get back to 2% in terms of annual inflation
The inflation situation, in the Eurozone, is cooling. Added to this good news is the surprising continued drop in the unemployment rate (6.4% in August compared with 6.7% at the beginning of the year). But these positive developments are offset by a cooling also being seen in the European Commission Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI). Given the weakness of confidence surveys, real GDP growth – only just positive in Q1 and Q2 2023 (+0.1% q/q each quarter) – is expected to be close to zero. We expect nil growth in both Q3 and Q4 2023, a forecast aligned with our nowcast estimate, also at zero.
