Eco Perspectives

Firm government measures support economy but add to long term fiscal worries

04/07/2020
PDF

Most sectors of the economy will suffer

GDP Growth and inflation (Y/Y, %)

Already before it became clear to what extent the Covid-19 virus would impact the global economy, Belgian GDP growth was expected to slacken. For a small open economy, a slowdown in international activity would inevitably have negative effects on its growth. The strong job creation under the Michel-I government’s rule was a persistent boost to private consumption. Also, investment growth picked up again in the last quarter of 2019. For 2020, the heavy-lifting was expected to be done mostly by government spending, with a strong focus on large infrastructure projects, like Oosterweel, a highway infrastructure project around the city of Antwerp.

As much as we emphasised the government role in supporting economic growth for the country in earlier publications, its actual impact in supporting domestic activity over the next coming months will be crucial. Measures include an increase in payment to those in temporary unemployment and delayed tax-payments by corporations. Negotiations about a EUR 50 bn-program carried by the government, the largest banks and the National Bank of Belgium are expected to reach their conclusion over the next coming days.

Still, the 3.5% decline in GDP we are currently forecasting is the largest such dip since the 2nd World War. This takes into account the current measures taken by the government to support household income and keep businesses from going broke.

To reflect the expected impact of the Covid-19 virus and its subsequent disruptions, we put aside the traditional “expenditure”-approach to calculate total GDP. Instead, we focussed on a “production”-approach, a framework that allows to more clearly specify changes to the added value on a sector level.

The subsequent analysis showed that most sectors of the economy will indeed suffer over the coming weeks and months, bar notable exceptions such as healthcare. For Belgium, the largest slowdown in activity is expected in the construction sector and for real estate related activities. For the former, the physical nature of the job renders it almost impossible for most businesses to comply with the strict social distancing rules, whereas the latter’s sector federation actually supported a recent government decision to forbid house-visits by prospective buyers.

The forced closing of certain aspects of social life obviously adversely impacts the demand in all sectors, but also on the supply side there are issues. According to the Secretary of Labour Nathalie Muylle, at least one million workers (20% of the total workforce) are, at currently, temporarily unemployed. Under this scheme, these workers are eligible to receive social support to the tune of 70% of their normal earnings, within some constraints.

In addition, there has been a strong focus on telework. Data from 2017 show that about 17% of all employees regularly works from home, with public workers actually well ahead of their peers in the private sector. However, as schools and daycare centres increasingly only take in children from parents with jobs considered essential, the amount of telework will presumably be closer to 50% today. Many of these workers (and their employers) might not yet be as experienced in the technological side of such setup. Combined with potential round-the-clock childcare, a slump in productivity seems inevitable.

Public finance

At the time of the first Covid-19 outbreak in Europe, the political situation in Belgium was still best described by a deadlock, following the May 2019 elections. In the meantime, Prime Minister Wilmés, who inherited a minority-backed government from Charles Michel when he became European Council President, received support from all but two parties in the federal parliament to execute a “corona”-mandate. This in theory authorizes the PM and her secretaries to fight the current crisis without consulting parliament on a regular basis.

Public finance was already deteriorating in 2019, as the deficit shot up again from a post-crisis low of 0.7% in both 2017 and 2018 . A recent publication from the National Bank of Belgium investigates how large GDP-shocks could adversely impact the deficit in various European countries. This analysis identified the strong automatic stabilisers in Belgium as a prime reason for the country’s high budget sensitivity, coming in a close second to France. Based on the analysis by the NBB, the budget deficit for 2020 could increase again by an additional 4 % points to an estimated 7%. But even with this kind of deficit, Belgium will be far from the worst pupil in the class. We’re living in different times.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Sudden stop to be followed by a gradual, uneven recovery

Sudden stop to be followed by a gradual, uneven recovery

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused a sudden stop in an increasing number of countries [...]

Read the article
United States
State of emergency

State of emergency

The American people and the US economy will no longer be spared the coronavirus pandemic, no more than any other country [...]

Read the article
China
Is the worst over?

Is the worst over?

China’s population and its economy were the first to be struck by the coronavirus epidemic. Activity contracted abruptly during the month of February before rebounding thereafter at a very gradual pace [...]

Read the article
Japan
Recession on the cards despite new fiscal stimulus package

Recession on the cards despite new fiscal stimulus package

The shock of the Covid-19 pandemic comes hard on the heels of a difficult second half of 2019 for the Japanese economy. Like many others, the country is exposed to the economic fallout from this crisis [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
A new, massive shock

A new, massive shock

The Covid-19 pandemic has triggered a recession in the Eurozone that looks likely to be deep but short-lived [...]

Read the article
Germany
Historic stimulus for fighting corona crisis

Historic stimulus for fighting corona crisis

The German economy has come to a standstill because of the almost complete lockdown. To fight the economic consequences, the government launched a massive stimulus plan to increase spending in the health sector, protect jobs and support businesses [...]

Read the article
France
Massive recessionary shock

Massive recessionary shock

Clearly, 2020 will not be another year of slow but resilient growth as we were forecasting just last quarter. We must now expect a massive recessionary shock triggered by the Covid-19 pandemic [...]

Read the article
Italy
At war with the virus

At war with the virus

The outbreak of Covid-19 hit Italy while the economy was already contracting [...]

Read the article
Spain
Badly hit by the Covid-19

Badly hit by the Covid-19

Spain is Europe’s second hardest-hit country by the coronavirus pandemic, and is likely to suffer a sharp economic contraction this year. The economic impact remains hard to quantify [...]

Read the article
Netherlands
Emergency package to protect jobs and businesses

Emergency package to protect jobs and businesses

As the country went into a selected lockdown, business confidence plummeted [...]

Read the article
Portugal
Caught up by the crisis

Caught up by the crisis

After what proved to be a rather mild slowdown, Portugal’s GDP growth ended up in the upper range of expectations at 2.2% in 2019 [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
Put to the test

Put to the test

Now a global phenomenon, the Covid-19 pandemic reached the United Kingdom relatively late and did not give rise to immediate protective measures [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Resilient but not off the hook

Resilient but not off the hook

After the economic slowdown was confirmed in 2019, the global shock of the coronavirus pandemic will probably drive Sweden into recession in 2020 [...]

Read the article
Norway
The other shock

The other shock

With the coronavirus epidemic and its impact on oil prices, which are plummeting, the Norwegian economy is heading for a contraction in 2020. Exports, which account for 41% of GDP, are likely to be hit first [...]

Read the article
Denmark
Not spared

Not spared

The Coronavirus epidemic is also sweeping Denmark, which has now introduced relatively strict lockdown measures. With its very open economy (exports account for more than 50% of GDP), GDP growth will contract in 2020 [...]

Read the article
Finland
Entering recession

Entering recession

Economic activity will plummet under the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, but not only via the export channel. The recession could become more virulent if household consumption and production channels were also to freeze up [...]

Read the article