Eco Perspectives

Eurozone | Constrained economic growth

12/18/2024
PDF

The upcoming protectionist shift in the United States, the structural difficulties in industry and the political instability in France and Germany will limit the eurozone's economic growth margins in 2025. However, the labour market is holding up well in many countries (the unemployment rate in the eurozone is still at a record low level). In addition, some of the shock will be cushioned by inflation falling back down to its target level and by the continued cycle of interest rate cuts. Under these conditions, there is still anticipation of a slight increase in eurozone economic growth in 2025, to 1.0%, which will, again, be underpinned by significant differences in growth levels between Member States.

Activity: a more uncertain outlook around stronger growth

GROWTH AND INFLATION

The scenario of tougher US protectionist measures remains a risk for the time being. However, while this policy will likely be implemented at least partially, it will not affect eurozone countries uniformly. Industry heavyweights, such as Germany, Italy and Ireland, which exported the equivalent of 3% or more of their GDP in goods to the United States in 2023 and which recorded major trade surpluses (principal focus of the Trump administration), are expected to be hit harder. However, trade agreements are possible in the long run, while the continued cycle of interest rate cuts and, to a lesser extent, the expected positive effects of the European Recovery Fund being ramped up on investment (see our focus : European Recovery Fund: a ramp-up expected in 2025) will support domestic demand. Differences in growth between Member States are expected to narrow in 2025, but the status quo from 2024 will not change. Spain should pull the eurozone average upwards again, with Italian and French growth standing at around the average level and Germany recording a more sluggish recovery.

Labour market: peripheral countries are holding up well

The labour market has been remarkably resilient in 2024, with nearly one million additional jobs created in the eurozone during the first three quarters of the year, and stable quarter-on-quarter growth of around 0.2%. There has been sustained employment growth in Spain and Italy, balancing out the declines seen in France and Germany. The eurozone labour market has been cooling but is still tight, with the vacancy rate moving slightly above its pre-COVID level during Q3 2024.[1] Under these conditions, the overall rise in unemployment in the eurozone should be fairly small in 2025, thanks, in particular, to economic activity in the peripheral countries holding up well. Nevertheless, if the downturns in Germany and France, which are already clear, were to intensify, this would affect the rest of the eurozone.

Monetary policy: halfway there

With four cuts in 2024 (the most recent occurring on 12 December), the process of normalising the eurozone monetary policy appears to be midway through, based on our forecasts. Interest rates are expected to settle at their neutral rate, which we estimate to be around 2%, in June 2025. However, should growth weaken further, the ECB could proceed with more rate cuts, which some members of the ECB’s Executive Board have alluded to[2]. At the same time, the ECB will accelerate its quantitative tightening from January 2025, with the reinvestment of maturing securities within the PEPP portfolio being phased out completely.

Inflation: down rather than up

After a two-year period of uninterrupted disinflation (initially spearheaded by energy, and subsequently by industrial goods and food products), which helped inflation to fall below 2% y/y in September, inflation rose again due to adverse base effects on energy. Core inflation, driven by services, has remained broadly stable since spring 2024. However, some momentum in the services CPI has ebbed away, with an annualised 3m/3m rate dropping to 1.3% in November, its lowest level since August 2021[3]. Therefore, the scenario of core inflation gradually coming down to the 2% target is still intact. In addition, median household inflation expectations fell sharply (2.1% in October for three-year expectations), which is consistent with a continued slowdown in wage growth. Higher customs tariffs in the United States will have limited effects on inflation in the eurozone, as a decline in the euro caused by this policy, which will likely fuel inflation within the monetary union, will be offset by the negative effects on business activity.

Fiscal policy: another great divide

EVOLUTION OF REAL GDP IN THE EUROZONE (INDEX 2002=100)

In 2025, fiscal policy is expected to be moderately restrictive in the eurozone, with greater control over current expenditure, particularly in Italy. The situation in France is still hanging on the adoption of a budget. Even with the deteriorating public finances of some countries, which have been subject to an excessive deficit procedure[4], we should not overlook the fact that fiscal consolidation has been continuing in the eurozone overall. The public deficit is expected to come down close to 3% of GDP in 2024, compared to 3.6% in 2023. In Italy, the deficit will plummet in 2024, due to the Superbonus and energy subsidies being reduced. In Portugal and Greece, the country’s fiscal consolidation and debt reduction are still a major policy focus, which should lead to a further increase in their primary surpluses in 2024.

Structural challenges: a productive base to be rebuilt.

For the eurozone, generating growth underpinned more strongly by productive investment and productivity gains is still a key challenge. Between 2002 and 2023, hourly labour productivity gains in the eurozone increased by an average of 0.7% each year (compared to +1.6% in the United States[5]). This weaker performance is mainly due to the gap in intangible investments (software and R&D) that has been constantly widening for nearly twenty years. These investments currently account for more than 6% of GDP in the United States (Q2 2024), compared to 3 to 4% in the eurozone.

External accounts: support for the euro through the current account surplus

The eurozone’s external accounts are still strong. Over a 12-month cumulative period, the current account recorded a surplus of EUR 425 billion in September, i.e. nearly 3% of eurozone GDP[6]. Although the trade surplus in machinery and equipment has shrunk from its record levels in 2014, due to Chinese competition in this segment in particular, the surplus in chemicals (made up largely of pharmaceutical products) has more than doubled over the decade. Meanwhile, the strength of tourism activity is driving the surplus on services to record levels. The current account surplus remains a support for the currency and the effective exchange rate, which, following a period of decline between 2008 and 2015, has generally been appreciating.

FOCUS | European Recovery Fund: a ramp-up expected in 2025

DISBURSEMENT OF EU RECOVERY FUND (% GDP)

Almost four years after it was introduced (February 2022), the Recovery and Resilience Facility or RRF, commonly known as the “European Recovery Fund”, has allocated less than half of its funds.

At the beginning of December 2024, EUR 270 billion had been transferred to European Union Member States (EUR 95 billion in the form of loans and EUR 175 billion in the form of grants) out of a total budget of EUR 648 billion. With the official payment period spanning until the end of 2026, the next two years should see payments sped up, with more noticeable effects on investment as a result.

This is the expectation of the European Commission, which, in its assessment of the medium-term fiscal-structural plans[7], stated that the absorption rate would increase to 0.4% of GDP in 2025. So far, the impacts on investment have been rather limited, and the mid-term report published by the European Commission in February 2024 highlighted a series of obstacles to distributing these funds on the ground, which are mainly administrative issues (such as higher procedural costs and a lack of human resources), but also the substitution effects between RRF funds and the EU Cohesion Policy programme.


[1] According to Eurostat, the vacancy rate in the eurozone was 2.6% in Q3 2024, compared to 2.5% in Q4 2019.

[2] See Financial Times article, ECB must commit to faster rate cuts, says Bank of Italy Governor, 19 November 2024.

[3] Seasonally-adjusted data.

[4] Belgium, France, Italy, Malta and Slovakia.

[5] OECD source. Constant purchasing-power-parity data (2015 basis).

[6] Calculated against the 2023 nominal GDP.

[7] See 2025 European Semester: Autumn package, European Commission, 26 November 2024.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Editorial | How different will 2025 be from 2024?

Editorial | How different will 2025 be from 2024?

The year 2024 is coming to an end, but political and economic uncertainties persist and are expected to continue into 2025, albeit in new forms. Donald Trump’s economic agenda is known [...]

Read the article
United States
United States | Inflation set to pick up again

United States | Inflation set to pick up again

A turbulent 2025 is expected to follow a 2024 marked by dynamic growth and the start of a monetary easing cycle [...]

Read the article
Germany
Germany | Reforms or decline

Germany | Reforms or decline

After outperforming between 2005 and 2018, German growth has since underperformed [...]

Read the article
France
France | Growth eroded by uncertainty

France | Growth eroded by uncertainty

France's economic growth is set to slow over the next two years, and the unemployment rate is set to rise, at a time when the gains in purchasing power associated with disinflation are behind us and political uncertainty is likely to weigh heavily [...]

Read the article
Italy
Italy | The summer break for the Italian economy

Italy | The summer break for the Italian economy

In Q3 24, real GDP remained unchanged. Domestic demand added 0.5 percentage points to the overall growth, while the net exports contribution was negative. The economic slowdown reflects the disappointing performance of manufacturing (-1 [...]

Read the article
Spain
Spain | Can the driving force behind European growth sustain its momentum?

Spain | Can the driving force behind European growth sustain its momentum?

Spain's outperformance is set to continue throughout our forecast horizon. Private consumption is expected to remain the driving force behind GDP growth, buoyed by slowing inflation and a strong labour market [...]

Read the article
Netherlands
Netherlands | Growth catch-up

Netherlands | Growth catch-up

Following a period of economic stagnation in 2023, Dutch growth gathered momentum in 2024 on the back of solid consumer confidence and more favourable financial conditions thanks to the ECB interest rate cuts [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Belgium | Trade-offs abound

Belgium | Trade-offs abound

Belgian economic growth remains somewhat below but close to trend. Our nowcast for the 4th quarter indicated 0.3% QoQ growth [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
United Kingdom | Recovery expected, but the road to monetary normalisation will be long

United Kingdom | Recovery expected, but the road to monetary normalisation will be long

The UK’s policy mix (a combination of fiscal and monetary policies) is expected to be more accommodative in 2025 [...]

Read the article
Japan
Japan | Political instability and very gradual monetary normalisation

Japan | Political instability and very gradual monetary normalisation

The Japanese economy continues to be characterised by weak growth, which slowed in Q3. The positive momentum in inflation and wages is in line with the Bank of Japan's objectives [...]

Read the article