Eco Perspectives

2020: a year of living dangerously

01/23/2020
PDF
Growth and inflation

One is taking off, the other coming in to land. Whilst the US economy has been on a slowing trajectory for more than a year now, with the industrial sector dropping into recession, the equity market is still setting new records. In 2019, the Standard & Poor’s index of the 500 biggest listed companies gained nearly 30%; at 3,230 on 31 December it was 106% above the record high of October 2007. The Nasdaq tech stocks index surged by 35% in 2019, taking its gains over the past seven years to 200%.

Higher, faster, riskier

Increased risk taking

Is this irrational exuberance? The fact is that in the United States, rising equity prices display a fairly distant relationship with the slower growth in earnings, resulting in stretched valuations (Figure 2 and IMF, 2019)[1]. With interest rates remaining low, equities’ gains are based on an amplification of the leverage effect. In its latest Global Financial Stability Report, the IMF highlights the importance of borrowing in M&A activity and in share buybacks. The increase in the weighting of goodwill in total assets, and the high multiples used in LBO (leveraged buy-out) deals reflect increasingly ambitious bets on the future[2]. Increased risk taking can also be illustrated by the narrowing of spreads on high-yield debt (Figure 2), a market sector that the IMF also considers to be overvalued.

In the current phase of rising asset prices, institutional investors (investment and pension funds, life assurance companies) have played an increasingly important role. Whilst banks have, overall, slowed the expansion of their balance sheets and improved their resilience since the 2008 financial crisis, institutional investors have expanded their activity, taking a growing share of financing.

Debt grows, margins shrink

They have also widened the scope of their quest for returns, in a context of falling interest rates on sovereign debt, the traditional core of their investment portfolios. A reallocation has taken place, away from cash and investment-grade bonds, to less liquid and more risky assets such as unlisted private debt, real estate and infrastructure. This has produced greater vulnerability to negative shocks or changes in expectations.[3]

In these early weeks of 2020, the increase in tensions between the United States and Iran does not appear to have provided a tipping point. Markets have been bolstered by the prospect of continued monetary accommodation[4], and hopes for the settlement of the trade war between China and the USA.

Pressure on margins and investment

The leverage effect

A scenario of calmer waters ahead is far from guaranteed. Granted, a deal between Washington and Beijing was signed on 15 January. ‘Phase 1’ of this agreement will bring a pause in the escalation of tariffs and, on the Chinese side, an increase in imports, notably of farmed products, guarantees on respect for intellectual property rights and greater market openness in the financial sector. The fact remains that the roots of the conflict – the battle for technological leadership – go deep[5] and that any real de-escalation in a possible ‘Phase 2’ has been pushed down the road, most probably beyond the presidential election on 3 November. Most of the tariffs enforced by the Trump administration will therefore continue to apply in 2020. This will take the average tariff on imports from China from 3% (in 2017) to 19%, increasing the cost of Chinese imports by some USD70 billion[6].

For US companies, the additional costs come at a moment when the effects of the 2018 tax cuts are diminishing and no longer serve to offset narrower operating margins. Pressure on earnings is rising, whilst the leverage is increasing; such a configuration often precedes or comes alongside an inversion in the US economic cycle (Figure 3 and Box 4). The tide has already clearly turned in the shale oil and gas sector, which has seen marginal returns fall and is cutting capacity in response.

Although employment and consumer spending are showing little sign of slowing, company investment has been falling since the autumn of last year. It is now the main vector by which the US economy is coming in to land. Surveys of purchasing managers suggest that this trend had not improved as we moved into 2020[7]. GDP growth has slowed, with the respective New York and Atlanta Fed’s nowcasts suggesting a rate between 1% and 1.8% per year.

[1] International Monetary Fund (2019), Global Financial Stability Report, Chapter 1, October, pp 1-4. In September 2019, the IMF’s valuation model suggested that US equity valuations were more than 2.5 standard deviations above fair value.

[2] Ibid, pp 25-37. 60% of LBO debt is for deals valuing the target company at more than six times annual operating income.

[3] Ibid, pp 41-49.

[4]In 2019, the US Federal Reserve cut its Fed Funds target rate by three-quarters of a point, taking the upper bound from 2.50% to 1.75%. Since October 2019, it has also increased the size of its balance sheet in response to tensions in the repo market.

[5]Even while it was negotiating with the USA, the Chinese government announced its plan to replace, within three years, foreign IT equipment (computers, software, etc.) in use across government with Chinese equipment. See Financial Times (2019), Beijing orders state offices to replace foreign PCs and software, Dec. 8.

[6]Estimated impact in 2020. Under the terms of the Phase 1 agreement, the US administration cancelled proposed tariffs on a final list of products (list ‘4B’), consisting mainly of consumer goods, and also cut the tariff rate applied in September 2019 on USD 100 bn in imports from 15% to 7.5%. The earlier tariff increases (25% on USD 250 bn in imports) have been confirmed. In the final analysis, nearly two-thirds (65%) of US imports from China will be subject to tariffs.

See: Brown C.P. (2019), Phase One China Deal: Steep Tariffs Are the New Normal, Peterson Institute for International Economics, December 19.

[7]At 46.8 in December 2019, the industrial orders index calculated by the Institute for Supply Management (ISM), which has traditionally been strongly correlated with company investment, is at its lowest since April 2009.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
Towards a slight growth pick-up

Towards a slight growth pick-up

In recent months, the global manufacturing cycle has been bottoming out whereas in services a slight uptick has been noted [...]

Read the article
China
The year starts with a reprieve

The year starts with a reprieve

In 2019, economic growth slowed to 6.1%. Total exports contracted and domestic demand continued to weaken [...]

Read the article
Japan
The impact of fiscal stimulus is uncertain

The impact of fiscal stimulus is uncertain

In December 2019, the Japanese authorities decided to launch a major fiscal stimulus for the years ahead. A large part of the programme will target disaster prevention after the country was hit by a series of natural disasters recently [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
2020: the year the economy begins to pick up?

2020: the year the economy begins to pick up?

Will the year 2020 be marked by a rebound in eurozone economic growth? More favourable signs seem to be emerging, although they have yet to show up clearly in hard data. In any case, eurozone growth is bound to remain low [...]

Read the article
Germany
Nearing a turning point

Nearing a turning point

Economic activity increased by only 0.6% in 2019, as the decline in manufacturing production was offset by increased activity in more domestically oriented sectors [...]

Read the article
France
2020: new year, same trends

2020: new year, same trends

The year 2020 is expected to follow along similar lines as in 2019, a mixed performance marked by slow but resilient growth bolstered by the strength of final domestic demand. The economy is expected to keep running at about the same rate (1 [...]

Read the article
Italy
Addressing present and future challenges

Addressing present and future challenges

Italy continues to record a cycle of subdued activity, with the annual growth rate of real GDP slightly above zero, as a result of the feeble growth in services, the modest recovery in construction and the persisting contraction in the industrial sector. From Q1 2018 to Q3 2019, manufacturing production has fallen by more than 3%, with the strongest declines in the sector of means of transport, in that of metal products and in that of textile, clothes and leather items. Together with the short term slow down, Italy is going to face long term challenges due to the ageing population and its impact on the labour force and the pension spending. [...]

Read the article
Spain
The new coalition takes its first steps

The new coalition takes its first steps

Although Spanish growth remains solid, it is by no means sheltered from the European slowdown. In 2020, growth is expected to continue slowing to about 1.7%, after reaching 2% in 2019 [...]

Read the article
Netherlands
Pension and climate challenges

Pension and climate challenges

Economic activity may have substantially weakened in Q4, due to the slowdown in world trade and the nitrogen and PFAS problems [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Domestic demand under pressure to keep delivering

Domestic demand under pressure to keep delivering

Belgian GDP growth is expected to drop to 0.8% in 2020, down from 1.3% in 2019. Domestic demand remains the key engine of growth, partially offset by a negative contribution from net trade [...]

Read the article
Greece
The recovery continues

The recovery continues

Supported by catching-up effects, the Greek economy managed to accelerate slightly despite a slowing European environment. Confidence indices have improved strongly and the Greek state has successfully returned to the capital markets [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
Brexit update

Brexit update

On 31 January 2020, the United Kingdom will officially leave the European Union and all of its constituent institutions [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Growth continues to slow

Growth continues to slow

GDP growth slowed sharply in 2019, and this trend is expected to be confirmed in 2020. Uncertainty surrounding the business climate and international trade are straining exports and investment [...]

Read the article
Denmark
Resilient growth

Resilient growth

In a less buoyant international environment, Denmark’s small open economy managed to maintain a rather dynamic pace. Thanks to its sector specialisation (pharmaceuticals, digital, etc [...]

Read the article