Eco Perspectives

China: Taking stock of 2023

02/01/2024
PDF

The post-Covid recovery in China’s economic activity was not as strong as expected in 2023. The property sector crisis seemingly deepened further at the end of the year, the demand for housing did not pick up again despite support measures from the authorities, and weak household confidence weighs on private consumption. Conversely, the export-oriented manufacturing sector has performed better than expected over the past few months, in contrast with the performances of domestically oriented sectors.

Chinese economic growth stood at 5.2% in 2023, up from 3% in 2022. This recovery is largely due to the post-Covid normalisation of domestic demand and base effects. It has also been supported by cautious monetary and fiscal policy easing since last summer. However, the Chinese economy continues to deal with a large number of fragilities that are likely to persist in the short term.

GROWTH & INFLATION

These fragilities are concentrated in domestically oriented sectors and weigh on investment and private consumption. In particular, the property sector is still in the depths of a major crisis, which further intensified in late 2023. Property investment contracted by around 8% last year, just as it did in 2022. Property transaction volumes plummeted 23% y/y in December and 18% over 2023 as a whole, and the apparent recovery in housing starts seen in November (after falling for 31 consecutive months) was seemingly a false dawn. Only the number of completed projects has continued to improve (+16% in 2023, after a drop of 15% in 2022) thanks to the measures implemented by the authorities to finance the completion of unfinished projects. Conversely, the measures introduced to rekindle demand for housing have not made a difference. For the first time, total mortgages outstanding shrank in 2023 (-1.5% y/y at the end of September). Unsold housing stocks are still excessively high, while property developers continue to face enormous financial difficulties. However, access to loans for the healthiest developers has improved slightly over the last 18 months (total bank loans to developers were up +4% y/y in September 2023, compared to +1.5% in mid-2022).

Property prices have continued to fall. In December, the average drop in housing prices in China’s 70 largest cities stood at 4.1% year-on-year and 0.8% month-on-month, which are the biggest falls since the correction in the property sector began in 2021. However, the overall fall in prices since the crisis began is relatively moderate: at the end of 2023, housing prices were estimated to be around 9% below their mid-2021 level on average.

The loss of confidence among households, private investors and lenders has significantly contributed to the property sector crisis not abating. Weak household confidence is also at the root of the weaker than expected recovery in private consumption in 2023, despite the effects resulting from the end of mobility restrictions. Retail sales volumes were up 7%, after contracting by around 2% in 2022.

At the same time, deflationary pressures emerged over the course of the year, as a result of not only weak domestic demand, but also falling food prices (-3% y/y on average in H2 2023, after rising 2.5% in H1), the correction in residential property prices and lower energy prices (fuel prices declined 5.1% in 2023). Consumer price inflation eased from +1.3% y/y in Q1 2023 to -0.3% in Q4. Core inflation stabilised at +0.6% y/y in the period from October to December, compared to +0.7% over the previous six months, which is low compared to the pre-Covid years (core inflation was 1.6% on average in 2019).

However, the increase in household purchasing power remained moderate in 2023 (disposable income per capita recovered +6.1% in real terms). Unemployment is still high among young people, and the employment prospects are uncertain, particularly in service sectors where the regulatory framework has become more stringent. All of these factors adversely affect consumer confidence and spending. They are also compounded by the negative wealth effects of falling property and stock prices.

The recovery in service sector activity weakened in late 2023 given the weakness of household demand and lower base effects. Services growth stood at +8.5% y/y in December, bringing an end to four consecutive months where it accelerated gradually; it is estimated to be +8% over 2023 as a whole (vs. -0.1% in 2022).

By contrast, the performance of the manufacturing and export sectors has recently strengthened. Growth in industrial production further accelerated slightly in December (+6.8% y/y) and stood at +4.6% in 2023 (compared to +3.6% in 2022). Investment in the manufacturing sector recovered slightly in Q4 2023. Activity was largely driven by exports, which performed better than expected in 2023 despite a sluggish international environment. Goods exports stabilised in November and rose again in December (+2.3% y/y in current USD), following six months of decline. Most notably, export volumes have recovered in recent months, boosted by the reduced prices offered by Chinese companies in order to strengthen their market shares. As a matter of fact, China has managed to develop its product range (from low value-added consumer goods to green technology products), gain a foothold on the electric vehicle market, and diversify its markets in an attempt to offset the drop in sales in the United States and the European Union.x

Article completed on 24 January 2024

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
2024: a critical year

2024: a critical year

2023 closed on a note of hope, with expectations of rate cuts and signs of stabilising, perhaps even improving confidence surveys. This hope has not dissipated in the early weeks of 2024 [...]

Read the article
United States
United States: Exceeding Expectations

United States: Exceeding Expectations

The possibility of a US recession triggered by monetary tightening is looking less and less likely given the resilience of an economy that continued to grow by 0.8% q/q in Q4 2023 and by 2.5% on average over the year [...]

Read the article
Japan
Japan: A monetary shift is drawing near

Japan: A monetary shift is drawing near

Faced with a natural disaster and a political crisis, 2024 is off to a rocky start for Japan [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
Eurozone: inflation falls, the ECB manages expectations

Eurozone: inflation falls, the ECB manages expectations

Eurozone activity is expected to pick up moderately in 2024, buoyed by the fall in inflation and the start of a cutting cycle of policy rates, which, according to our forecasts, will take place in April [...]

Read the article
Germany
Germany: When will growth return?

Germany: When will growth return?

The cyclical slowdown in the German economy, which is similar to the one being experienced in the Eurozone, is part of a longer-term stagnation, with Q3 2022 standing out as the last quarter with significant growth [...]

Read the article
France
France: Strengths and weaknesses of growth

France: Strengths and weaknesses of growth

French growth weakened in 2023, as evidenced by the low figures for the business climate indicators in December. However, 2024 should kickstart the road to recovery [...]

Read the article
Italy
Italy: a slower and more uncertain recovery

Italy: a slower and more uncertain recovery

In 2023, the recovery of the Italian economy slowed in a somewhat bumpy way. On the one hand, after supporting the first part of the recovery, fixed investment declined. But on the other hand, consumption surprised on the upside (+1 [...]

Read the article
Spain
Spain: Household consumption remains the primary growth driver

Spain: Household consumption remains the primary growth driver

In Q3 2023, Spanish growth eased slightly to 0.3% q/q. It was primarily driven by household consumption, which was itself supported by the resilience of the labour market and the increase in real wages. After an increase in H2 (from 1 [...]

Read the article
Netherlands
Netherlands: Mixed outlook in 2024 but better than 2023?

Netherlands: Mixed outlook in 2024 but better than 2023?

The country fell into recession during 2023, like in Germany across the border, but 2024 is expected to be better as the future government will have the financial resources to revitalise the economy [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Belgium: Double shock induces future-proofing investments

Belgium: Double shock induces future-proofing investments

The Belgian economy looks set to grow at its current trend rate for the next few quarters [...]

Read the article
Greece
Greece's recovery continues

Greece's recovery continues

Greece is expected to enjoy economic growth once again in 2024, but activity showed signs of slowing down in the second half of 2023. Real GDP stagnated in Q3 2023 and employment fell by 0.5% q/q [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
United Kingdom: In search of a second wind

United Kingdom: In search of a second wind

The UK economy is flirting with recession [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Sweden: After the recession, a slightly better outlook

Sweden: After the recession, a slightly better outlook

The combination of rising inflation and the monetary tightening to combat it led the Swedish economy into recession. Declining household consumption and residential investment were the main drivers [...]

Read the article