Eco Perspectives

Essential budgetary support

09/29/2022
PDF

UK growth contracted slightly in Q2, but the economy should not enter a recession before Q4. On the one hand, the labour market continues to operate at full employment, which will partially absorb the sharp impact of inflation on purchasing power. On the other hand, the new government plan to support households and businesses should mitigate future energy price increases. Faced with persistent inflation, the Bank of England (BoE) is further accelerating its monetary normalisation, at the risk of precipitating a contraction in the economy.

United Kingdom: growth & inflation

The United Kingdom suffered a slight contraction in its GDP in Q2 2022 (-0.1% q/q), mainly due to the drop in household consumption (-0.2% q/q) and the fall in public spending (-2.9% q/q). According to our forecasts, the UK economy should rebound very slightly in Q3 thanks to Boris Johnson's government’s support plan, before experiencing a marked contraction in GDP in Q4 2022, against a backdrop of persistent inflation and rising interest rates. This contraction in GDP could be partially mitigated by the new support measures announced by Liz Truss. For the time being, business climate surveys indicate a contraction in industrial activity and a slowdown in activity on the services side.

Pursuing monetary normalisation

Although inflation slowed slightly in August (9.9% y/y), mainly reflecting a drop in fuel prices (86.2% y/y compared to 114.1% in July), it continued to spread, as evidenced by the increase in underlying inflation (6.3% y/y). Inflation should continue to rise to a peak probably at around 13.8% in Q1 2023[1], before slowing down but still staying well above the 2% inflation target.

Furthermore, tensions on the labour market, which is still operating at full employment (3.6% unemployment rate from May to July) are supporting wage growth (+5.5% y/y in nominal terms from May to June, i.e. -2.6% in real terms), which is slightly dampening the impact of inflation for households. Although there is no wage-price spiral at the moment, wage increases in certain sectors (transport, postal services, etc.) should slow down the pace of disinflation in 2023.

Faced with persistent inflation and a robust labour market, the BoE accelerated the hike in itbank rate, with a further hike by 50 basis points at its meeting on 22 September, bringing it to 2.25%. The BoE also announced the start of the sale of UK Treasury debt securities (gilts) held under its Asset Purchase Facility (APF) programme. This reduction from GBP 80 billion over the next 12 months should strengthen monetary normalisation.

"Low tax, big state"

To cope with the energy and cost of living crisis, Liz Truss had no choice but to implement a massive support plan for the economy. With a duration of two years from 1 October, this programme is structured around three measures.

The plan first provides for capping the average electricity and gas bill for households at GBP 2,500 per year, well below the GBP 3,548 estimated by Ofgem (the UK energy regulatory authority). To this end, the government is preparing an “energy price guarantee” at supplier level as well as the temporary abolition of the green levy. This programme is in addition to the household support plan (GBP 37 billion) announced in June, which included targeted aid (GBP 400) for the most vulnerable households.

On the business side, the government proposes to put in place a similar “energy price guarantee” mechanism, for a period of six months, before moving towards a more targeted system, the measures of which have not yet been specified.

The third flagship measure of the support plan aims to guarantee stability in the electricity market by ensuring sufficient liquidity. HM Treasury and the BoE will set up a GBP 40 billion liquidity fund (Energy Markets Financing Scheme) to facilitate the massive margin calls faced by market players.

Although the measures in this plan are necessary to mitigate the impact of inflation, its scale will weigh heavily on the public finances. According to government estimates, this plan would cost between GBP 100 and 200 billion (between 4.5 and 9% of GDP), well above the GBP 80 billion of the household support plan during the Covid-19 crisis. The Debt Management Office (DMO) should soon issue a more detailed estimate of the budgetary impact of this plan on the public finances. So far, no countervailing measures have been announced, so the plan would be financed by increased use of public borrowing.

The fiscal and budgetary policies announced will put pressure on the UK public finances. On the one hand, Liz Truss has announced a support plan without countervailing measures. On the other hand, her campaign promise to prioritise tax cuts for households and businesses (of around GBP 30 billion) could further widen the public deficit. As a direct consequence of this deterioration in the budget outlook, gilts (UK Treasury securities) saw their yield rise sharply across the maturity curve. For the first time since 2011, the yield on 10-year sovereign bonds (10Y gilts) exceeded 3.2%. The other notable development is on the currency market side: despite these higher interest rates, sterling continued to fall, particularly against the dollar. On September 19, GBP fell to 1.1410 USD, its lowest level since 1985.

Completed on 16 September 2022


[1]This figure does not take into account the effects of the new support plan. Recent government measures should significantly reduce inflation.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
The recession narrative

The recession narrative

Inflation has been the dominant economic theme for months, but, under the influence of aggressive monetary tightening, one can expect this won’t last. At the same time, recession concerns are mounting [...]

Read the article
United States
Close to inflation peak?

Close to inflation peak?

Following a second contraction in its GDP in Q2, the outlook for the US economy is at least uncertain. Inflationary pressures are showing signs of easing, but the pace of disinflation could be longer than expected [...]

Read the article
China
Malaise

Malaise

The recovery in activity since the end of the lockdowns imposed in Shanghai in the spring has been very gradual. It picked up in August, notably supported by public investment and tax measures, but it is likely to lose steam again in September [...]

Read the article
Japan
Bank of Japan keeps on track

Bank of Japan keeps on track

The Yen continued to plunge this summer, reaching its lowest level against the dollar in 24 years [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
Heading for a recession ?

Heading for a recession ?

The current unprecedented combination of shocks (inflation, health crisis, geopolitical issues, energy crisis, climate, monetary issues) is likely to overburden the Eurozone resilience and push the region into recession over the coming quarters [...]

Read the article
Germany
Dark clouds gathering

Dark clouds gathering

The question is no longer whether or not Germany will slide into recession, but rather when and to what extent. The surprising resilience of German GDP in the 2nd quarter should not disguise the significantly worse outlook for the rest of the year [...]

Read the article
France
Is a recession coming?

Is a recession coming?

French growth was surprisingly up in the second quarter (+0.5% q/q), supported by the positive impact of the lifting of Covid-19-related restrictions on tourism and leisure. The rest of the economy was almost flat according to our estimates (+0 [...]

Read the article
Italy
From a robust recovery to an uncertain outlook

From a robust recovery to an uncertain outlook

During the first half of 2022, the Italian economy has gradually gained strength. In Q2 2022, the real GDP was 1.1% higher than in Q4 of 2019. The carry-over for 2022 is 3.5%. The recovery that resulted was widespread in a variety of sectors [...]

Read the article
Spain
The inflationary shock is severe

The inflationary shock is severe

Spain is unlikely to avoid a difficult winter. Although its economy is structurally less vulnerable to energy shortages, the inflationary shock is severe and is not slowing down, with an inflation rate of over 10% in August [...]

Read the article
Belgium
The tension is rising

The tension is rising

Belgian GDP grew by 0.2% in the second quarter of this year. Private consumption continued its upward trajectory in the first half of 2022 but is expected to slow down as inflation remains at an all-time high [...]

Read the article
Portugal
A less severe energy shock than elsewhere

A less severe energy shock than elsewhere

With a relatively limited risk of energy shortages, Portugal should record some of the largest economic growth in the eurozone this year. A number of favourable factors are driving these growth levels [...]

Read the article
Finland
Housing policy: a great success story

Housing policy: a great success story

Finland, like other Nordic countries, has so far shown itself to be particularly resilient to the current financial shocks, but the clouds are gathering over the “Land of the Midnight Sun” [...]

Read the article
Sweden
Could its institutions grind to a halt?

Could its institutions grind to a halt?

After eight years in opposition, the conservatives have returned to power in Sweden in rather unfavourable circumstances. Although economic activity has proved resilient so far, it is showing clear signs of a slowdown [...]

Read the article
Switzerland
The Swiss franc: an unwavering shield against inflation

The Swiss franc: an unwavering shield against inflation

Switzerland differs from other European countries in that it has significantly lower inflationary pressures, protected as it is by its strong currency and by resilient business activity which should continue to grow for the rest of 2022 and during 2023. Although the Swiss National Bank (SNB) is likely to argue that 3.5% inflation year-on-year in August is a reason to raise its key rate by 75 bps on 22 September, and so exit from its policy of negative interest rates, it is unlikely that this monetary tightening will last over the longer term, as inflation is already showing signs of slowing down. [...]

Read the article