Eco Emerging

Resilient economy: at least in the short term

04/13/2020
PDF

Economic support measures

Faced with the COVID-19 pandemic, the government has so far taken measures to restrict movement and activity, but no confinement measures as such. All flights have been suspended. Economic support measures have come first in monetary form, with a 300 basis point cut in the Egyptian Central Bank’s (CBE) policy rate. This took the CBE deposit rate from 12.25% to 9.25%. The CBE has also announced a number of measures aimed at the banking sector with a view to supporting economic activity, including the postponement of credit payments for six months for individuals and companies, a debt relief initiative for individuals at risk of default, a cut in the preferential interest rate reserved for targeted debtors, and the creation of a guarantee fund to back the tourist sector. Meanwhile, the government has introduced support measures for the private sector (loans at subsidised rates for industry, support for the hotel sector, direct support to certain households) for the equivalent of around 2% of GDP.

Sharp economic growth slowdown is expected

Forecasts

The economic growth slowdown will be substantial, but the structure of the Egyptian economy will help limit its extent. The sectors most vulnerable to the consequences of the epidemic, where the impact on growth will be significant, are manufacturing (16% of GDP), construction and real estate (16% of GDP) and tourism[1]. This sector only represents a small share of GDP (around 3% of the total), but its contribution to GDP growth has been significant in recent quarters, accounting for around 1 point out of total GDP growth of 5% to 6%.

Monetary easing and yields on Tbills

The extractive industries, agriculture, communications and healthcare (around 25% of GDP in total) are likely to be relatively less affected.

In fiscal year (FY) 2018/2019, real GDP growth was 5.6%. This pace was maintained in H1 2019/2020. In Q3 2019/2020, estimated growth was still largely positive albeit somewhat slower (we expect a figure of 5.0% y/y). To date, the economy has been relatively little affected by the international slowdown given the limited integration in international value chains. Restrictions on economic activity were introduced in March 2020 and will therefore mainly affect the final quarter of FY2019/2020 (-4.1% y/y). In FY2019/2020 as a whole, real GDP growth is likely to drop sharply but remain positive at 2.6%.

The economic consequences of the health crisis are likely to persist at least into the early months of FY2020/2021 and will affect the high season for tourism. At the same time, the fiscal capacity to support and revitalise the economy is constrained, whilst the drop in consumer living standards could limit the scope for recovery. Real GDP is expected to grow by 3.4% in FY2020/2021.

Stable inflation

In the short term, trends in consumer prices are likely to be influenced by two opposing factors: the inflationary effects of the possible disruption of the food supply chain (40% of the consumer price index), offset by the impact of lower oil prices. Prices for all oil products (apart from butane) are now linked to market prices, given the complete removal of subsidies. They are likely to be reviewed downwards for Q4 2019/2020. Overall, we are not making any significant changes to our inflation estimate, which we put at an annual average of 5.9% for FY2019/2020.

A sustainable fiscal position

The direct support fiscal measures announced so far remain relatively limited (around 2% of GDP) and will fall mainly in FY2020/2021. In addition, falling oil prices will reduce the subsidies for butane (other energy subsidies have already been removed), but this will have only a very marginal effect on total spending.

On the revenue side, direct and indirect tax income will fall, as will revenue from the Suez Canal (6% of government revenue in FY 2018/2019). Although the fall in revenue will directly affect the final quarter of the current fiscal year, stimulus spending will be spread over a longer period. Having been in surplus at 1.35% of GDP in FY2018/2019, the primary budget balance is likely to turn negative this year, at -0.3% of GDP. In FY2020/2021, the primary balance is likely to be in deficit by -1.8% of GDP, given the need for fiscal support to the economy and the fall in receipts.

The hard-to-curb debt interest payments (47% of total revenue in FY2018/2019) are the main reason for significant and persistent budget deficits. The cut in the CBE’s interest rate should reduce interest payments by 0.3% of GDP over a full year (they were equivalent to 9.5% of GDP in FY2018/2019). The potential savings linked to a cut in interest rates (a 100 bp cut is equivalent to around EGP 8 billion to EGP 10 billion in savings) will be partially offset by an increase in the rates on the treasury bills market due to increasing risk aversion, and reduced liquidity as a result of the withdrawal of foreign investors. As a result, the total budget deficit is likely to increase this year to some 9.2% of GDP.

Whilst the budget deficit remains under control, its financing will be ensured, despite the increasing scarcity of external financing. The liquidity of the local banking system appears sufficient to cover financing needs. Total CBE liabilities linked to open-market operations were equivalent to 13% of GDP in February 2020. The fall in yields on these transactions could encourage banks to turn instead to government securities.

Foreign currency liquidity is resilient

Banking system external liquidity

The consequences of the oil price fall for external accounts are mixed. By volume, the country is a net importer of oil products (both crude and refined) and has returned to a position as a net exporter of LNG (although in limited volumes). By value, the total hydrocarbon balance has been slightly negative during 2019, reflecting a lag between value and volume, which is linked to the nature of the agreement between the Egyptian national oil company (EGPC) and international oil companies. The expected collapse in oil prices in 2020 is likely to have a slightly positive effect on the trade balance. Conversely, the tourist sector is likely to be hit hard and we estimate that tourism revenues could fall by around 25% in FY2019/2020, before recovering in FY2020/2021 but without returning to the level of USD 12 billion achieved in FY2018/2019. Similarly, private transfers from expatriates are likely to be severely affected by the sharp economic slowdown in the Gulf, whilst Suez Canal receipts will suffer from the contraction of global trade and the fall in the oil price. The current account deficit is likely to increase to 4.1% of GDP in FY2019/2020 and then 4% in 2020/2021.

In the short term, the foreign currency liquidity situation remains acceptable, even if confronted by capital outflows. In other words, the total of the current account deficit (USD 13 billion over a full year), amortisation on foreign debt (USD 7 bn in 2020) and those on T-bills held by foreign investors (around USD 20 bn in February 2020) is more than covered by total foreign currency assets held by the banking system as a whole. The net foreign asset position of commercial banks was positive to the tune of USD 7 bn in February 2020, whilst the CBE’s foreign currency holdings currently stand at USD 47 bn (end-March 2020) if we add Tier 2 reserves (intended to cover part of portfolio flows) to official reserves.

However, although the external position appears solid for the short term, the worsening of the current account deficit and the likely reduction in portfolio inflows could bring to an end the pound’s appreciation. Yet a number of factors are likely to limit any depreciation: a local debt market that remains attractive to international investors; foreign investment in the energy sector, although it could suffer from the depressed state of the oil market; and the renewed support of the Gulf monarchies should it be needed.

[1] According to the Ministry of International Cooperation, since the onset of the crisis, inbound tourism reservations have dropped by 80% in comparison to the same period last year.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Emerging Countries
Triple whammy

Triple whammy

Emerging countries have been severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic even though the official number of confirmed cases and deaths (excluding China) is still low compared to the figures for the developed countries [...]

Read the article
China
Is the worst over?

Is the worst over?

China’s population and its economy were the first to be struck by the coronavirus epidemic. Activity contracted abruptly during the month of February before rebounding thereafter at a very gradual pace [...]

Read the article
India
Limited resources to combat the pandemic

Limited resources to combat the pandemic

India was not spared the coronavirus pandemic. The economic slowdown will be all the more severe with a protracted lockdown of the population. The government also lacks the fiscal capacity of the other Asian countries to bolster its economy [...]

Read the article
Brazil
Tough luck

Tough luck

The massive economic shock resulting from the coronavirus sanitary crisis will delay Brazil’s economic recovery, suspend the process of fiscal consolidation and stall progress on reforms [...]

Read the article
Türkiye
Prepared for (soft) landing?

Prepared for (soft) landing?

The Turkish economy is facing problems of a sort it has dealt with in the past: a global crisis, that will trigger a sharp fall in exports, coupled with a contraction of external financing [...]

Read the article
Romania
Walking on a tightrope

Walking on a tightrope

Romania’s economy has become gradually unbalanced in recent years, ending 2019 with significant twin deficits, i.e. both a fiscal deficit and a current account deficit [...]

Read the article
Indonesia
A violent shock hits a solid economy

A violent shock hits a solid economy

The COVID-19 crisis will have a huge impact on an economy that was already weakened slightly by the slowdown in global trade in 2019 [...]

Read the article
Philippines
Stopped in mid flight

Stopped in mid flight

The coronavirus crisis has hit a fast-growing economy, which expanded by more than 6% year-on-year in H2 2019 and looked set to continue at the same pace in 2020 [...]

Read the article
Hong Kong
The Covid-19 crisis worsens the ongoing recession

The Covid-19 crisis worsens the ongoing recession

The Covid-19 pandemic strikes an economy that has already been weakened by several quarters of decline in merchandise exports, tourism, private consumption and investment [...]

Read the article
United Arab Emirates
Towards a new crisis in Dubai?

Towards a new crisis in Dubai?

As the most diversified economy of the Gulf countries and a major oil producer, the United Arab Emirates faces a double shock: the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic and plummeting oil prices [...]

Read the article
Morocco
Solid fundamentals to cope with the shock

Solid fundamentals to cope with the shock

The Moroccan economy will see significant consequences from the coronavirus pandemic. Tourism has been at a standstill since March and will remain so until May at the earliest [...]

Read the article
Kenya
Tough economic times forthcoming

Tough economic times forthcoming

Kenya’s real GDP growth was subdued last year and it will come under stress in 2020 due to coronavirus outbreak effects [...]

Read the article