Eco Perspectives

A fiscal stimulus monitored closely by Brussels

12/16/2020
PDF

Forecasts made at the start of the year will probably turn out to be accurate. Spain is set to be the Eurozone’s economy hardest hit by the Covid-19 epidemic. We forecast GDP to shrink by 11.8% in 2020 before rebounding by 7.0% in 2021. The social situation has worsened again this year, forcing the government to introduce new large-scale welfare benefits (e.g. minimum living income), which will be reinforced in 2021. Spain’s huge €140 billion stimulus plan will support the recovery, should raise the country’s potential growth and create jobs. But the structural budget deficit is widening. Once the Covid-19 crisis is over and the recovery underway, Brussels will intensify the pressure on the Government to speed up certain key reforms, and in particular regarding the country’s pension system.

GROWTH AND INFLATION (%)

In all likelihood, the Spanish economy will contract again in the fourth quarter of 2020. Although the second wave of Covid-19 has been receding rapidly since its peak in mid-November, restrictions on activity have remained – until mid-December at least – severe and among the most stringent in Europe.

Despite the sizeable rebound in activity in Q3 (+16.7% q/q, non-annualised), Spanish GDP was still 9% below its end-2019 level, a recovery comparatively smaller than in other European countries.[1]

Breaking down the figures by expenditures, the recovery in service exports had unsurprisingly been the weakest (43.6% below the Q4 2019 level) – pulled down by the slump in tourism activity. Gross fixed capital formation and households spending were down 11.1% and 10.5%, respectively. However, within household consumption, spending on durable goods had rebounded rapidly, rising above its Q4 2019 level.[2]

For sure, job-protection measures – mainly the ERTE temporary unemployment scheme – have significantly cushioned the shock on the labour market, particularly in the service sector. According to the Spanish Employment Office (SEPE)[3], the number of workers affiliated to the social security system was 2.2% lower in November than in February in the industry, and 2.6% lower in services.[4]

Comparing these figures with the larger declines in GDP, we see that the government’s measures to protect jobs are having a positive effect, although this comes at a high cost for the public finances. According to the labour ministry, 746,900 workers were covered by a ERTE in November. The ERTE scheme has been extended until 31 January, which should limit the increase in unemployment until then. The unemployment rate was 16.2% in October.

Fiscal consolidation pushed back until 2022 at the earliest

THE IMPACT OF COVID-19 ON INEQUALITY IN SPAIN

Spain’s fiscal policy will therefore remain highly expansionary in 2021. The 2021 budget, which was approved by parliament in late November, will amount to a record of EUR239 billion. Key welfare measures put forward by coalition partner Podemos will be reinforced; this is the case of the minimum living income (IMV), for which a further EUR3 bn will be allocated (see box).

However, investment accounts for the largest increase in the budget, with significantly greater spending on R&D, apprenticeships and vocational training, as well as the modernisation of public infrastructure. On the revenue side, new taxes on high-earners will be introduced. The budget will also be partly funded by EUR 27 billion of subsidies granted by the European Commission to Spain in 2021 as part of the EU recovery fund (Next Generation EU).

GOVERNMENT PRIMARY STRUCTURAL BALANCE (% GDP)

This record budget has been built in line with the rapid implementation of Spain’s large-scale EUR 140 billion national recovery plan (the “Recovery, Transformation and Resilience plan”) for 2021-2026.

With this plan, the government is hoping to generate around 800,000 jobs by 2023 and boost GDP growth by 2.5 percentage points over the same period, by investing massively in the ecological and digital transitions. Half of the spending (EUR 72 bn) is due to take place in the next three years.

However, the public-sector deficit is expected to jump to around 120% of GDP at the end of 2020, an increase of 20 percentage points year-on-year.

RATIO OF 90TH PERCENTILE OF THE WAGE DISTRIBUTION TO 10TH PERCENTILE

Against these circumstances, and once the Covid-19 crisis is over, Spain’s government will be under pressure from Brussels again to address certain major structural issues that represent a long-term drag on Spain’s budget balance. In particular, the European Commission wants the Spanish government to commit to ensuring the future viability of its pension system, and to introduce new measures to reduce the proportion of people with temporary jobs[5].

Based on its November forecasts, the European Commission estimates that Spain’s structural primary deficit (i.e. the deficit excluding changes in income/expenditure related to the economic cycle and excluding interest payments on debt) will widen further in the next two years, reaching 5.2% of GDP in 2022 (see chart 2). This is by far the largest deficit in the Eurozone, and more than twice the Euro-area average (-2.3%).

NFCs and the Covid-19 shock

At this stage, it remains difficult to quantify precisely the impact of the Covid-19 crisis on the liquidity and solvency of the non-financial corporation (NFC) sector. A Bank of Spain study[6] estimates that between April and December, demand for liquidity from non-financial corporations could exceed EUR 230 billion, although almost three quarters of that would be covered by state-guaranteed loans.

Unsurprisingly, the sectors struggling the most are tourism and leisure, transport and automotive. However, it is worth bearing in mind that non-financial corporations went into the Covid-19 crisis with a more solid financial position than in the past. In particular the debt-to-GDP ratio had dropped steadily between 2010 and 2019, falling to levels unseen since the early 2000s.[7]

[1] For a comparison of recovery rates, see H. Baudchon and L. Boisset, Eurozone: from rebound to relapse, BNP Paribas Ecoflash, 4 November 2020.

[2] A large part of the increase can be traced to automobile sales, which bounced back thanks to the government’s decision in June to offer subsidies for the purchase of cleaner vehicles (Renove 2020 programme).

[3] Seasonally-adjusted figures.

[4] Employment in the construction industry was only 1.1% lower than the February level.

[5] Bruselas apremia a España a reformar las pensiones y el mercado laboral, El País, 7 December 2020.

[6] Blanco et al. (2020), Spanish non-financial corporations’ liquidity needs and solvency after the Covid-19 shock, occasional paper, Banco de España.

[7] As a proportion of GDP, the consolidated debts of non-financial corporations fell from 108.2% in Q2 2010 to 61.0% in Q4 2019 (Bank of France data).

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Global
After a most difficult year, cautiously hopeful for 2021

After a most difficult year, cautiously hopeful for 2021

Until the very end, 2020 has been a difficult year, to say the least. However, there are reasons to be cautiously hopeful about the economy in 2021. Vaccination should reduce the uncertainty about the economic outlook [...]

Read the article
United States
Change of scenery

Change of scenery

The 46th president of the United States, Joe Biden, will face a difficult mandate [...]

Read the article
China
The tightening in credit conditions is a delicate exercise

The tightening in credit conditions is a delicate exercise

Economic activity has rebounded rapidly since March and has gradually spread from industry to services [...]

Read the article
Japan
A very gradual normalisation process

A very gradual normalisation process

As in other economies across the globe, Japan will report a record-breaking recession in 2020. The path to a full economic recovery will be probably longer because growth would remain very subdued [...]

Read the article
Eurozone
Cautious but hopeful

Cautious but hopeful

The resurgence of the Covid-19 pandemic halted the Eurozone’s economic recovery. It looks like year-end 2020 will be harder than expected due to new social distancing measures and lockdown restrictions set up in most of the member states [...]

Read the article
Germany
Income uncertainty boosts precautionary savings

Income uncertainty boosts precautionary savings

The second lockdown interrupted an already stalling recovery. However, the business climate is likely to improve soon on the expectation that several vaccines might soon be available [...]

Read the article
France
Light at the end of the tunnel

Light at the end of the tunnel

The huge recessionary shock in H1 was followed by an equally spectacular rebound of economic activity in Q3, with an 18.7% jump in real GDP, although it will remain short-lived [...]

Read the article
Italy
Coping with the second wave

Coping with the second wave

Following an impressive decline in the first half of 2020, the Italian economy rebounded over the summer. Value added rose strongly in construction and manufacturing, while the recovery in the services sector was less substantial [...]

Read the article
Belgium
Structural impact limited so far, but eventually bill comes due

Structural impact limited so far, but eventually bill comes due

We expect the Belgian economy to lose 7.2% of its size this year, followed by a 3.8% increase next year [...]

Read the article
Austria
Corporate sector severely weakened by Covid-19 crisis

Corporate sector severely weakened by Covid-19 crisis

The government decreed a second lockdown in November due to the rapid rise in Covid-19 infections. Business indicators point to a fall in activity. Thanks to the short-time work scheme, unemployment has only risen moderately [...]

Read the article
Finland
A resilient, but not very dynamic, economy

A resilient, but not very dynamic, economy

In Q2 2020, Finland stood out from the rest of Europe as the country that reported the smallest decline in GDP – “only” –4.4% [...]

Read the article
Greece
A slower recovery than other countries in 2021?

A slower recovery than other countries in 2021?

Greece’s economic recovery will be fraught with uncertainty in 2021. The Covid-19 hit to activity could last longer in the tourism industry – a key sector for the country – than in other sectors [...]

Read the article
United Kingdom
Another contraction in Q4, before a definitive recovery?

Another contraction in Q4, before a definitive recovery?

The record fall in UK GDP in the second quarter gave way to unprecedented growth in the third, and the news that an effective vaccine against Covid-19 will soon be widely available suggests that the economy could start its definitive recovery in 2021. However, the UK is not out of the woods yet. Given that a second national lockdown was introduced in England in November, there is little doubt that economic activity will drop again in the fourth quarter. Moreover, the strength of the recovery is, because of Brexit, more uncertain than elsewhere. This not only because of the UK’s decision to leave the EU’s single market and customs union, but also due to continued uncertainty over whether a free-trade agreement will be found.  [...]

Read the article
Sweden
A hard-hit economy

A hard-hit economy

Since March 2020, Sweden has adopted a more relaxed approach to the COVID19 outbreak as no lockdown has been imposed to the population. However, the recent pick up in new infections could slow the recovery down in Q4 2020 [...]

Read the article
Norway
One of the least affected developed economies

One of the least affected developed economies

Norway was not hit as hard by the Covid-19 pandemic as most its European neighbours. Moreover, the economy has been able to count on considerable support from the fiscal and monetary authorities [...]

Read the article
Denmark
Uncertainty remains

Uncertainty remains

The Danish economy has quickly rebounded after the reopening of the borders but a complete catch-up will take time since the resurgence of the Coronavirus epidemic keeps the country’s economic situation uncertain [...]

Read the article