Eco Emerging

A fragile recovery

07/12/2021
PDF

Emerging countries have continued to recover since the beginning of the year, although the recovery remains fragile. Household confidence indicators are lagging behind those of business sentiment, illustrating the constraints on domestic demand: the pandemic risk persists, inflation is accelerating, and governments are facing rising financing costs, which reduces their fiscal manoeuvring room. Despite buoyant foreign trade, the horizon is not clear enough yet for investment to rebound. Fortunately, the vast majority of central banks have been maintaining a proactive stance so far, despite inflationary pressures. But monetary policy is bound to tighten across the board.

Real GDP growth continued to slow in the 27 main emerging countries in Q1 2021, although it held strong at 1% q/q, down from 3.5% in Q4 and 7.7% in Q3. For half of these countries, real GDP growth returned to or exceeded Q4 2019 levels. In general, exports were still the main growth engine, notably in Asia (China, Taiwan and Vietnam). Companies are rebuilding inventory, which is generating pricing pressures on commodities and raising transport costs. Private domestic demand is also picking up, but in a more hesitant manner, including in China, even though it is more advanced in the cycle than the other countries. Confidence indicators reflect this lag: for the large majority of countries, the Markit indexes for the manufacturing sector have returned to or surpassed pre-crisis levels, but this is not yet the case for household confidence indicators.

The recovery continues, but the risks are more on the downside than on the upside

There is still a major pandemic risk. New waves of Covid-19 infections were reported in Asia and Latin America in Q2 2021. The virus is mutating into more contagious variants, and vaccination coverage rates are still too low to ensure herd immunity (less than 10% in India and Indonesia, and less than 15% in Brazil and Russia, to cite only the countries with the largest populations). The authorities in several countries have had to reinstate lockdowns, and as a result, economic activity is expected to slow or even contract in several Asian and Latin American countries.

The upsurge in inflation is now widespread (in May, the median increase in the inflation rate was already 1.8 points above the 2020 average). Oil and agricultural commodities are the main drivers of inflation, which strains household purchasing power, notably for the most vulnerable households. In its most recent June outlook, the World Bank, following the IMF, reiterated its alarming estimates of the number of people who slid into poverty last year (nearly 100 million people live off less than USD 1.9 a day, or 164 million using a broader definition that also takes into account the deterioration of healthcare and education). Even under a recovery scenario, per capita income in 2023 will still be lower than in 2019 in at least 40% of the emerging and developing countries. In comparison, four years after the 2008-2009 shock, this figure was only 15%.

The upsurge in inflation also poses a problem for the central banks, because it will exceed the inflation targets in more than half of the countries that have them. Yet tightening monetary policy at this point in the cycle risks disrupting the recovery of domestic demand, and investment in particular. Monetary tightening would only make sense if it is necessary to anchor inflation expectations. On the whole, the central banks are taking care to be proactive.

Since the beginning of the year, governments have been faced with higher financing costs, both domestically and externally. The rebound in portfolio investment as a share of local currency public debt in H2 2020 helped contain the increase in bond yields that could have been triggered by swelling deficits. Since the beginning of the year, however, portfolio investment has been returning to normal levels (they were cut in half in H1 2021 compared to H2 2020), notably due to expectations of a tapering of US monetary policy. The big increase in debt ratios in 2020, will magnify the impact of higher bond yields on the interest burden, reducing by as much the fiscal manoeuvring room in case of a relapse into recession.

Lastly, it is uncertain that foreign direct investment (FDI) will recover. According to the CNUCED, the number of greenfield projects in the manufacturing sector – which was already tending to decline in the 2010s – was slashed in half in 2020. Project financing also declined through Q1 2021, and inertia is very strong (following the 2008-2009 crisis, it took two years for projects to pick up again). These two categories of FDI will make a smaller contribution to growth than during the previous crisis exit phases, because governments have less borrowing capacity and because multinational companies are planning to relocate their business.

Yet the rebound in commodity prices could stimulate investment and help raise the growth potential of the countries concerned. This was the case in Latin American countries in the 2000s, when the upward phase of the commodity price cycle increased potential growth rates by nearly a percentage point. But the current situation is not comparable to the 2000s. At that time, China had maximum leverage with a growth rate of 10%, nearly double its current rate.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

China
The economic recovery is still mixed

The economic recovery is still mixed

Economic growth rebounded very rapidly following the Covid-19 shock, but this rebound has also been characterised by mixed performances between sectors and between demand components [...]

Read the article
India
More turbulence

More turbulence

The second wave of the pandemic seems to have passed after new cases peaked in May. Economic activity is unlikely to contract as much as it did last year, and the decline should be limited to the second quarter [...]

Read the article
Philippines
Constrained recovery

Constrained recovery

The health crisis is barely improving in the Philippines. After a particularly severe second wave, the number of new Covid-19 cases seems to have levelled off, albeit at a high level [...]

Read the article
Russia
Risks under control despite the latest Covid wave

Risks under control despite the latest Covid wave

After a modest contraction in 2020, the Russian economy has registered a solid growth rebound since March 2021 driven by the strength of domestic demand and exports [...]

Read the article
Poland
Unchanged potential growth

Unchanged potential growth

Covid-19 was only a temporary brake on Polish growth. The economy is outperforming its neighbours’, with a shallower recession in 2020 and an earlier recovery [...]

Read the article
Romania
Vibrant growth

Vibrant growth

The Romanian economy is in the midst of a spectacular rebound. Real GDP has already returned to pre-Covid levels, and growth should reach 8.2% in 2021. But this performance has been accompanied by high fiscal and external deficits [...]

Read the article
Serbia
Favourable prospects

Favourable prospects

The Serbian economy was only moderately affected by the consequences of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020 [...]

Read the article
Brazil
A surprisingly resilient recovery

A surprisingly resilient recovery

The Brazilian economy has been surprisingly resilient given the challenging sanitary situation it faced in Q1 [...]

Read the article
Chile
New challenges

New challenges

The economy should rebound strongly in 2021 thanks to a successful vaccination campaign, improved prospects for global growth and higher copper prices [...]

Read the article
Saudi Arabia
A difficult economic transition

A difficult economic transition

The Saudi economy took a double hit in 2020: the consequences of the Covid-19 pandemic amplified the recessionary impact of falling oil prices and production [...]

Read the article
Nigeria
Struggling to rebound

Struggling to rebound

After declining 1.9% in 2020, Nigeria’s GDP is unlikely to rebound but mildly in 2021 due to persistent and significant macroeconomic imbalances [...]

Read the article
South Africa
A welcome export revenue windfall

A welcome export revenue windfall

South Africa has been severely hit by the Covid-19 crisis, after already several years of very low economic growth and social and political tensions. Real GDP collapsed by 7% in 2020 and public finances have deteriorated significantly [...]

Read the article