Eco Week
Editorial

Three headwinds to growth

12/05/2021
PDF
US TREASURY YIELD (IN %), 30 NOVEMBER 2021 (CET)

Everything is transitory, including life’. This (obvious) point was recently made by a US senator when introducing his question to Jerome Powell about the transitory nature of inflation[1]. The Fed Chairman acknowledged that inflation may very well be elevated for longer and hence less transitory than considered hitherto. Given that the economy is strong, he added this would justify a faster tapering than signaled following the latest FOMC meeting[2]. Unsurprisingly, markets reacted instantaneously to this more hawkish tone with 10 year Treasury yields moving about 6 basis points higher and the 2 year yield increasing slightly more, about 11 basis points (chart 1)[3].

RETAIL AND RECREATION MOBILITY (7-DAY MOVING AVERAGE, % FROM BASELINE*)

Thereafter, the short end of the yield curve fluctuated in a narrow range. More surprising was that after this knee-jerk reaction, the 10 year yield started drifting lower, leaving the yield at the close of Wall Street, barely above the level before Powell had spoken. This could reflect three things. One, investors might feel uncomfortable about the accelerated tapering and the increased likelihood that official rate hikes would come sooner rather than later. They probably fear that the economy would react quickly and quite negatively to such a policy tightening. Under such a scenario, the yield curve inevitably flattens.

Two, investors are less concerned about the economy but fear that the more hawkish stance of the Fed would weigh on the equity market. Under such an outcome, demand for safe assets would rise, causing an increase in bond prices and lower yields. The muted reaction of the bond market to Powell’s comments could reflect an anticipation of this scenario. Three, market participants may fear that, should the number of new cases of the Delta variant continue to increase, this might end up weighing on growth in the short run. It looks like we are already moving in that direction in several European countries, hence the concern about what might happen in the US. Chart 2 shows, based on Google mobility data, that in Europe, footfall in retail and recreation has declined quite significantly in recent weeks.[4] It remains to be seen whether this will weigh on aggregate spending, but it should clearly have sector effects –think of the negative impact on the leisure and hospitality sector- and could favour online purchases over in-store shopping. It is to feared that the new variant, Omicron, will reinforce these developments, although this depends on its transmissibility, on the effectiveness of existing vaccines and whether it causes severe disease or not. When the news about this variant started to spread, markets reacted by revising the growth outlook, witness the decline in oil prices –reflecting an expected drop in demand- and a weakening of the dollar versus the euro -reflecting the view that the Federal Reserve may be less inclined to tighten quickly. The decline in bond yields also points in that direction.

Omicron undeniably represents an uncertainty shock to the economy and raises the concern that, once again, the return to normality may take longer than expected. Research shows that such an uncertainty shock weighs on investment spending –companies preferring to wait until they see more clearly- but household spending, in particular on durable goods, can also suffer when households fear a hit to the labour market. At the current juncture, the reaction will probably be more muted, based on the hope that, again, successful vaccines will quickly be developed if need be. However, for households and companies, this uncertainty shock comes on top of a negative supply shock –supply disruption, a huge increase in producer prices and, albeit to a lesser degree, consumer prices- that is a clear headwind to demand. It clearly makes the task of central banks more complicated than ever when deciding how much of a monetary headwind they can create. Not only is there the question of how transitory inflation is, there is also the even more difficult one of how transitory the impact of the new variant might be.

FINANCIAL MARKETS ON 26 NOVEMBER 2021 (CET)

[1] Coronavirus and CARES Act, Testimony of Jerome H. Powell before the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, US Senate, 30 November 2021.

[2] This was held on 2 and 3 November 2021.

[3] The time shown on the chart is CET. The testimony started around 16.00 CET.

[4] The vertical axis shows how visits and length of stay at different places change compare to a baseline. The baseline is the median value, for the corresponding day of the week, during the 5-week period Jan 3–Feb 6, 2020. A figure of -30% indicates that traffic was down 30% compared to the baseline. In order to smooth the series, we use a seven-day moving average of the raw data in the Google Mobility Reports. Source: Google.

THE ECONOMISTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN THIS ARTICLE

Other articles from the same publication

Economic Pulse
PMI: Price pressures remain elevated

PMI: Price pressures remain elevated

The global manufacturing PMI has been stable since the month of August although over the same period, the data have weakened in the US and the Eurozone, whilst staying well above the global level [...]

Read the article
Economic Pulse
World trade tensions persist at the end of 2021

World trade tensions persist at the end of 2021

World trade tensions and supply chain frictions will continue to be major sources of uncertainty in 2022, given their impact on imports prices, and in turn, consumer prices [...]

Read the article
Economic Pulse
Hoisting the storm signal 

Hoisting the storm signal 

Our Pulse is clearly pointing to bad weather, as the blue area of the spider chart – the economic situation in the past three months – is clearly shrinking compared to the situation in the preceding three months – the area within the dashed line [...]

Read the article
Economic Pulse
Good vibes despite bottlenecks 

Good vibes despite bottlenecks 

The first indications for Q4 2021 suggest that the main confidence indicators are holding at high levels, especially business sentiment. The improvement in the French labour market observed over the past several months also seems to be continuing [...]

Read the article
Economic Pulse
Covid-19: A new variant has the world on edge

Covid-19: A new variant has the world on edge

According to the latest data from Johns Hopkins University, 3.97 million new Covid-19 cases were reported worldwide between 25 November and 1 December, a 3.2% increase over the previous week. Increases were reported in Europe (+5.9%), Asia (+3 [...]

Read the article