The cyclical slowdown in the German economy, which is similar to the one being experienced in the Eurozone, is part of a longer-term stagnation, with Q3 2022 standing out as the last quarter with significant growth. Even so, this figure is biased upwards, as the period benefitted from the post-Covid rebound. While the rise in energy prices was steep enough in 2022 to highlight the clear weaknesses of the German economy, which is specialized on energy-intensive sectors, some of these weaknesses had existed earlier. Against this backdrop, the prospect of a return to growth, which is our scenario for spring 2024, due to the drop in inflation in particular, is still shrouded in deep uncertainty and downside risk.
French growth weakened in 2023, as evidenced by the low figures for the business climate indicators in December. However, 2024 should kickstart the road to recovery. The major drop in energy prices from the levels seen at the start of 2023 will contribute to inflation continuing to fall, which is not expected to be jeopardised by most of the price-cap mechanism still in place for electricity being removed. The upturn in real wages, the healthy state of the aeronautics sector and the continued greening of the economy should enable a soft landing for growth in 2024, with an annual average figure of +0.6%. The expected slight rise in unemployment and the more pronounced increase in business insolvencies pose downside risks, however.
In 2023, the recovery of the Italian economy slowed in a somewhat bumpy way. On the one hand, after supporting the first part of the recovery, fixed investment declined. But on the other hand, consumption surprised on the upside (+1.5% with respect to Q4 2022). Italian households benefited from both a significant improvement of labour market conditions and deceleration of inflation. Consumer confidence recovered, supporting private expenditures. In Q4 2023, inflation marked a decisive slowdown: the declining trend is mainly due to the deceleration of energy prices (up +1.2% on average in 2023 compared to +50.9% in 2022).
In Q3 2023, Spanish growth eased slightly to 0.3% q/q. It was primarily driven by household consumption, which was itself supported by the resilience of the labour market and the increase in real wages. After an increase in H2 (from 1.6% y/y in June to 3.3% in December according to the harmonised price index), inflation is expected to fall again in 2024 and drop below the target of 2% in Q3. We expect growth to remain moderate at the end of 2023 and in early 2024 (0.2% q/q), before returning to positive territory. Spain will remain one of the drivers of the euro area for another year, with expected growth of 1.5% on an annual average versus 0.6% for the euro area.
The country fell into recession during 2023, like in Germany across the border, but 2024 is expected to be better as the future government will have the financial resources to revitalise the economy. A little bit of patience will be needed though for things to settle down. The Dutch economy remains heavily exposed to the global environment, which is very tense at the start of this year.
The Belgian economy looks set to grow at its current trend rate for the next few quarters. Despite a challenging international environment, characterised by restrictive monetary tightening combined with economic slowdowns in key trading partners, the economy has held up remarkably well. Consumer spending, supported by wage indexation, and robust investment are leading the charge. Capex expenditures are directed towards automation and climate transition in the wake of energy and labour costs hikes.
Greece is expected to enjoy economic growth once again in 2024, but activity showed signs of slowing down in the second half of 2023. Real GDP stagnated in Q3 2023 and employment fell by 0.5% q/q. While strong tourism activity, against a backdrop of high inflation, is boosting tax revenue, its impact on real GDP is more muted. The sharp drop in the unemployment rate (which is now below 10%), the drastic improvement in public finances and the decline in public and private debt testify to Greece’s solid recovery, which has been welcomed by the rise in equity and bond markets, and by the sharp tightening of spreads between Greek sovereign debt and the German Bund
The UK economy is flirting with recession. The downturn in activity in the second half of 2023 is expected to continue until spring 2024 before an expected sluggish recovery, which nonetheless will be supported by the Bank of England (BoE) beginning its monetary easing cycle. Despite an uptick in December 2023, inflation remains on its downward trajectory, which is clearly reflected in production prices and CBI surveys. The turnaround in the labour market, which is still muted, is helping to reduce upward pressures on wages. While this is good news for inflationary momentum, it is also weakening private consumption. The BoE has little room for manoeuvre, with an initial policy rate cut expected to occur in June 2024
The combination of rising inflation and the monetary tightening to combat it led the Swedish economy into recession. Declining household consumption and residential investment were the main drivers. Although the situation is not expected to deteriorate further in 2024, this does not mean that a dynamic recovery is to be expected. However, although Sweden is experiencing significant difficulties, it still has many assets to support activity in the medium term.
The narrative of the last mile of disinflation being the hardest, which in 2023 became popular in the world of central banking, reflects concern that after having dropped significantly, further declines in inflation would be more difficult.However, it seems that relevance of this narrative is increasingly being questioned. The account of the December 2023 meeting of the ECB governing council mentions that it has been debated. It seemed that the disinflation of 2023 had been faster than in previous episodes, raising doubts about the relevance of the narrative. A paper of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta analyses this topic for the US. Based on recent research on the Phillips curve, it concludes that the ‘last mile’ is likely not significantly more arduous than the rest
The Red Sea conflict has already had a substantial impact on global shipping. While maritime freight prices are, at this stage, still well below the levels seen in 2021, when the global economy was recovering post-lockdown, they have spiked in January 2024. The Freightos index (chart 5) shows that transportation costs have tripled on average compared to the end of last year. Due to their geographical locations, China and Europe have been the regions most directly affected by these disruptions, and are already facing threefold (China-Europe route) to fivefold (Europe-China route) increases in transportation costs. However, the effects are gradually being felt on all global shipping routes
GDP growth, inflation, exchange and interest rates.
The eurozone narrowly escaped economic contraction in the last quarter of 2023, but the picture is mixed among countries. According to preliminary figures from Eurostat, real GDP in the euro area remained stable in Q4, following a slight decline of 0.1% q/q in Q3. Quarterly growth surprised to the upside in Spain (+0.6%), Italy (+0.2%), while the data for France (0.0%) and Germany (-0.3%) were in line with the consensus. The largest decline in the euro area came from Ireland (-0.7%) while Portugal’s growth rose the most (+0.8%).
INSEE has published its business climate survey for January along with its quarterly industry survey. These two surveys reflect a lack of momentum, without marking any further deterioration. Regarding sales prices, the changes observed are encouraging, although recent events in the Red Sea could reverse the trend.
In recent speeches and interviews, officials of the Federal Reserve and the ECB have cooled down market enthusiasm about the timing and number of rate cuts this year. In the US, the message is that there is no reason to move as quickly or cut as rapidly as in the past, considering the healthy state of the economy. In the Eurozone, despite the drop in inflation in 2023, there is still uncertainty about the inflation outlook, particularly due to the pace of wage growth. Moreover, there is also a concern that the easing of financial conditions -due to overly optimistic market assumptions about the policy rate path- would be counterproductive from a monetary policy perspective. Both the Federal Reserve and the ECB want to tread carefully in deciding when to start cutting rates
In Q4 2023, Chinese economic growth accelerated slightly to 5.2% year-on-year (y/y), compared to 4.9% in Q3. However, it lost momentum in quarter-on-quarter terms, standing at +1% q/q in Q4 vs. +1.5% in Q3. Our barometer seems to indicate a widespread improvement in activity in the last quarter of 2023 compared to the previous quarter, but this is still largely due to the post-Covid normalisation of domestic demand and significant base effects. Actually, the Chinese economy continues to face a large number of vulnerabilities, which are likely to persist in the short term.
GDP growth, inflation, interest and exchange rates.
The latest economic data paint a mixed picture. In both the eurozone and the US, the signal from most confidence surveys in December is encouraging. But it is still too early to conclude to a bottoming out. Non-farm payrolls in the US remained robust in December. But the collapse of the employment component of the ISM survey in the non-manufacturing sector looks alarming. Business failures are on the rise. The economic situation also remains vulnerable to geopolitical tensions. On the other hand, there is no reason to worry about the inflation rebound in December. And the dynamics appear more favourable in the eurozone than in the US.
In the United States, economic policy uncertainty, based on media coverage, fell in December, after rising for three months in a row. This drop can probably be attributed in part to the anticipated Federal Reserve rate cuts and the hopes that they are raising.
Croissance du PIB, inflation, taux d'intérêt et de change.
When looking ahead and formulating the forecasts for 2024, it is always relevant to look back at the recent past and to have a final look at 2023. It was a year with many surprises. The resilience of the Labor market in the US and in the euro area faced with aggressive monetary tightening, the resilience of the US economy in general with a staggering growth performance, the stagnation in the euro area, but also the decline in inflation. But the thing that has been the defining characteristic for 2023 to treat undoubtedly, has been the fact that the peak in policy rates has been reached in the United States and in the euro area. When we now look at 2024, we can say that there are two quote unquote certainties.
In December, the S and P Global Composite PMI index for worldwide business activity rose again slightly (+0.5 points), reaching 51, its highest level since August 2023. This is the second consecutive month of improvement, after five months of decline. The signal remains encouraging for global activity at the end of Q4 2023. However, this improvement masks a fairly clear divergence between the services sector and the manufacturing sector. In December, the global services index reached its highest level since August 2023 (51.6), while the manufacturing index recorded its lowest level since the same month (49).
The economic picture during November and December reveals some divergence between Europe, on the one hand, and the US and Japan, on the other hand.
The end of the year is shaping up to be a difficult one for the eurozone, as displayed by the flash PMI indicators for December. The composite index, fell by 0.6 points to 47, and remains below the threshold of 50 (in contraction territory) for the seventh month in a row. The employment index has not plummeted, but has been gradually declining since April, reaching 49.6 in December, its lowest level in three years. At 6.5% in October, the unemployment rate in the eurozone stabilised at a historically-low level, which is increasingly looking like a floor. We expect the jobless rate to rise slightly over the next few months, in line with current trends in the PMI indices. The unemployment rate for young people (under 25) has already risen by one percentage point in six months, to 14
