Based on the PMI data and the European Commission business surveys, it seems that in the Eurozone, industry is clearly slowing down, demand is softening and labour market bottlenecks have eased somewhat. In combination with input prices that are down, this should lead to an easing of output price inflation. In services, the picture is different. Hiring difficulties remain a big constraint on activity, momentum in terms of activity and orders has improved. Input price and output price inflation has eased only slightly. Such a dichotomy complicates the task of the ECB: ongoing strength in services would imply that past rate hikes didn’t yet have a significant impact and would justify more tightening, but this would only make things worse for the industrial sector
The reopening of the Chinese economy at the end of last year has finally had its effects with a few months’ delay. Exports from China jumped 19.8% m/m in March, according to preliminary figures released by the CPB.
GDP growth, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates
In April and May, there was a relative deterioration in the main OECD economies, with some divergences in the magnitude and extent of this deterioration across the economies. In Europe, the deterioration observed in the manufacturing sector over the past few months is beginning to spread to services, where confidence indices have begun a downward trend. In the United States, the ISM non-manufacturing rose moderately in April, compared to an ISM manufacturing index below 50 for the sixth consecutive month.
Eurozone growth in the first quarter of 2023 was +0.1% q/q according to the data available at the time of writing. This is below our forecast (+0.3% q/q), and therefore rather disappointing, even if it surprises favourably compared to our nowcast estimate (-0.0%). This low growth also puts into perspective the perceived resilience coming from most survey and activity data during the first quarter.
Industrial activity and new industrial orders experienced sizeable variability in Q1, with a strong rebound in January-February followed by a sharp drop in March. Overall, new orders remained stable during the first quarter (q/q). The IFO survey has even deteriorated in May, and the ZEW index has returned to negative territory.
The business climate surveys from the French National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE) deteriorated in April and May, raising fears that the upturn in business activity seen during the first quarter was temporary to a certain extent.
The preliminary estimate of Italian economic growth in the first quarter was a positive surprise, with real GDP rebounding by 0.5% q/q. However, we anticipate a slowdown in activity in Q2, before a contraction in Q3. At 0.9% in 2023, Italian GDP growth would still be above that of the eurozone as a whole.
Spanish growth strengthened slightly in Q1 2023, to +0.5% q/q, according to preliminary figures from INE. However, this acceleration, supported by investment and external demand, did not allow real GDP to cross the pre-Covid threshold. It still showed a small deficit of 0.2% compared to Q4 2019.
In the first quarter of 2023, US growth was +0.3% q/q. This is well below expectations: the figure is half the GDPNow estimate of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta and our forecast (0.6%). Growth appears then not to be so impervious to the inflationary shock and the monetary tightening implemented to cope with it.
The UK economy grew 0.1% q/q during Q1 2023, at the same pace as during Q4 2022. Growth was erratic in the first quarter. Real GDP initially bounced back in January (+0.5% m/m) following a contraction in December (-0.5% m/m), buoyed by the services sector (+0.8% m/m).
Japanese growth picked up again during Q1 2023, posting an increase of +0.4% q/q. However, this upturn needs to be put into perspective, as it follows two disappointing quarters (-0.2% q/q in Q3 2022 and 0.0% q/q in Q4 2022). As a result, Japanese GDP is still at the same level as in Q2 2022.
Continuing the downturn observed in April, INSEE’s business climate indicator fell again in May to 100, the lowest since April 2021. The downturn is widespread and particularly noteworthy regarding the manufacturing sector, where the confidence index even fell to 99, below its long-term average (100) for the first time since March 2021. At the same time, inflationary pressures are continuing to ease.
The French labour market continues to be surprisingly strong with 42,000 net job creations in the first quarter of 2023 according to the INSEE, even though the economy has shown numerous signs of cooling off for more than a year. There is nothing abnormal about the labour market’s resilience, which has still benefited from post-Covid catching-up effects, notably in market services. Yet several driving forces have seized up, especially in construction, and the labour market could begin to deteriorate.
Economic indicators for the month of April 2023 suggest that China’s economic recovery is rapidly running out of steam. Granted, health restrictions were lifted recently (December 2022) and there are still some major post-Covid catching-up effects that are bolstering household demand. However, growth in other demand components has weakened.
April was marked by the stabilisation of the Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) for the manufacturing sector, after a slight decline in March.
The Bank of England (BoE) delivered another 25bp rate hike on its May meeting on Thursday, raising its interest rate to 4.5%. The forward guidance has not been revised and is still hawkish and it appears from the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) minutes and report that the end of the tightening cycle might still be coming.
Public deficits in Greece, Portugal and, to a lesser extent, Spain, dropped significantly in 2022. According to Eurostat’s preliminary results – published on 21 April – the primary deficit nearly halved in Spain (-2.4% of GDP), it was erased in Greece, while Portugal once again posted a surplus (1.6% of GDP). In Greece and Portugal, the public deficit fell below the 3% GDP limit set by the Growth and Stability Pact, with which they had already realigned between 2016 and 2019. Although down sharply, the deficit in Spain remains significant, at 4.8% of GDP.Better-than-expected growth in activity and employment and high inflation generated strong tax revenues, which more than offset the rise in spending to cushion the inflationary shock
New factory orders in the industry fell sharply in Germany in March, after a fairly significant increase in February. Overall, these developments are offsetting each other. A very moderate increase over Q1 (0.2% q/q) is consistent with GDP growth, published at 0% q/q for Q1.
Growth in the French economy recovered slightly in Q1 2023, rising to 0.2% q/q following the relative stagnation seen during the second half of 2022. Despite the strengths driving this recovery, the French economy is also exposed to some weaknesses. An analysis across three sectors (transport equipment (including cars), food and housing), gives us an insight into these conflicting forces which imply that while growth is still positive, it can be very different across sectors.
Kenya's external solvency has been deteriorating for several months. After years of indebtedness to international markets and China, external public debt service rose significantly, accounting for 22% of export receipts in 2022. In addition, drought in the country has increased its dependence on imports, and the terms of trade have deteriorated significantly since the start of the war in Ukraine. On top of that are the dynamics of global monetary tightening.
Traditionally, monetary policy focuses on price stability and fiscal policy on other objectives. When inflation is well below (above) target on a sustained basis, this separation of roles implies that monetary policy may need to become extremely accommodative (restrictive). Consequently, interest rates have a large cyclical amplitude, which may have undesirable consequences for the economy and put financial stability at risk. Simulations show that a coordinated approach between monetary and fiscal policy reduces the optimal cumulative amount of rate cuts (hikes). However, putting this into practice would probably be very challenging.
