Our Western Europe business insolvencies index has risen above its pre-COVID level. However, it is still far below the peaks seen after the 2008 crisis and during the eurozone crisis (between 2011 and 2015). In most countries, the business insolvencies level is now higher than it was before the pandemic. This has been the case since 2022 for the UK and Sweden, which were joined by France, Belgium and Germany during 2023. However, in Germany, Italy and the Netherlands, the insolvency levels are still far below their pre-COVID peaks. These diverging evolutions are also being reflected in sectors, with sharper deterioration in construction, trade and real estate agencies in the countries that have suffered the steepest decline in business activity.
GDP growth, inflation, exchange and interest rates
Oxford Insights’ AI 2023 preparedness index offers a great starting point to harness the digital divide across the region with Brazil and its vibrant Fintech sector on one end of the spectrum and Haiti on the other, lacking basic infrastructure. To that point-in-time snapshot, however, we can add a backward-looking component (investment rate over the past decade) and a forward-looking one (projected fiscal space) to get a more complete picture of some of the challenges lying ahead as the region furthers its digital transformation.
According to the latest economic data, the divergences in growth between the US, Europe and Japan are expected to remain at the beginning of 2024. In Europe, the economic situation in Q1 was once again disrupted by exceptional factors, this time linked to the Red Sea crisis, which particularly affected automotive production in January and, by extension, industrial production.
Disinflation in the euro zone continues to buoy household confidence. The European Commission index rose by 0.6 points to 14.9 points in March, according to the flash estimate. This is its highest level since February 2022 and the start of the war in Ukraine.
The first indicators available for January point to a continuing weak start to the quarter (after contraction in GDP of -0.3% q/q in Q4 2023), hence our forecast of a further drop in GDP of -0.1% q/q in Q1. Manufacturing production (up 1% m/m in January) remained 1.5% below the figure seen in November, due to a sharp drop in automotive production (down 10% in January from the level seen in November).
Q1 got off to a bad start, with a drop in manufacturing production in January (-1.6% m/m) linked to the shutdown of oil refineries for maintenance (with new difficulties in March), and a downturn in the automotive sector (supply problems, followed by a drop in demand affecting the production). At the same time, January’s foreign trade data do not suggest a rebound in imports of intermediate goods (inputs for other sectors).
Activity in the private sector in Italy continued to improve in February, according to the composite PMI index, which was up 0.4 points over a month, taking it to 51.1. However, unlike the current situation in Spain, the divergence between the manufacturing sector and the services sector is becoming more pronounced.
As expected, Spanish inflation slowed in February. In year-on-year terms, the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) rose by only 2.9% (-0.6 percentage points compared to January) due to an increase in energy price deflation, itself brought about by favourable weather conditions.1 Like other countries in the eurozone, inflation in services persists in Spain, the country remaining the main component contributing to overall inflation (contribution of 1.9 pp).
US economic activity slowed slightly in February, according to the ISM survey. It reported a deterioration in the business climate in the manufacturing sector, putting a halt to three months of increases, with the associated index standing at 47.8 (-1.3pp).
The UK economy remains deteriorated, but the latest activity figures show a slight improvement at the beginning of 2024. The monthly ONS estimate indicates growth in added value of 0.2% m/m in January, buoyed by a rebound in retail and wholesale (+1.8% m/m) and construction (+1.1% m/m). Nevertheless, this follows a difficult second half of 2023, marked by a 0.5% drop in real GDP.
March saw an improvement in activity in Japan, according to the Jibun Bank PMI survey. Both the manufacturing index (48.2, +1.0pp), thanks to a widespread rise in the main sub-components, and the non-manufacturing index (54.9, +1.3pp) recovered, allowing the Composite index to reach its highest level since August 2023 (52.3, +1.7pp).
In terms of the trade balance, 2023 largely unwound the problems of 2022, which, with itsburdens and shocks, constituted an annus horribilis for French foreign trade.
Economic indicators for the first two months of 2024 showed a slight improvement in activity, driven primarily by the export manufacturing sector. Growth in industrial production reached +7% y/y in real terms in January-February 2024 compared to +6% in Q4 2023, and manufacturing investment also strengthened slightly. It increased by +9.4% y/y in nominal terms over the first two months, after +6.5% over 2023 as a whole.
GDP growth, inflation, exchange and interest rates.
Since 2022, the French government has reduced several types of production tax. This is the case for tax based on corporate value added (CVAE), which was reduced gradually in 2021 and 2023, and will continue to be phased out in 2024, this process coming to an end in 2027.
Canada has experienced sluggish economic growth in 2023, owing to rising prices and higher credit costs, which had a direct impact on the investment and consumption channels, despite the benefits of the country’s growing population. Furthermore, one cannot expect a significant improvement over the short run. Canadian households are amongst the most indebted in the world. Admittedly, their level of net wealth contributes to offset this fact, but it still implies an increased vulnerability against the backdrop of monetary tightening and a deteriorating labour market
In the US, the latest Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF) of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia paints a rather upbeat picture of the economic outlook. A similar survey of the ECB points towards a gradual pickup in growth this year. In both cases, the level of disagreement is low. This provides reasons to be hopeful about the economic outlook. However, the alternative scenarios are predominantly negative for growth and inflation, and some have totally different implications for the evolution of bond yields. This would mean that as time goes by and the likelihood of the different alternative scenarios evolves, bond yield volatility could be high.
In the United States, economic policy uncertainty, based on media coverage, fell significantly in February, following a rebound in January. The index fell from 124 to 97, the lowest level since July 2023, when the policy rates were last raised. With US growth and the labour market continuing to hold up well, the economic outlook appears to be brighter and less uncertain. This gives greater credit to the scenario of a soft landing for the economy, and greater comfort for the Fed’s cautious stance and to take its time before cutting rates.
French growth has recorded a stop-and-go cycle during the last 4 years. While the Covid period initiated this phenomenon in response to successive lockdowns and reopenings of the economy, subsequent shocks generated precautionary behaviour: lowering inventories and sudden stop of growth at the time of the shock (energy crisis, impact of rising interest rates), and then inventories rebuilding and growth recovery thereafter. This phenomenon could contribute to growth during the course of 2024, after the stagnation recorded in the second half of 2023.
In February, the S&P Global Composite PMI improved for the fourth consecutive month (+0.3 points), to 52.1, its highest level since June 2023. This is a fairly clearly encouraging signal for Q1 global growth, especially as this improvement is being driven both by the manufacturing and services sectors. In February, the global PMI index in these two sectors reached its highest level since August 2022 and July 2023, at 50.3 and 52.4 respectively.
GDP growth, inflation, interest and exchange rates.
The economic situation in January and February highlights the uncertainties surrounding 2024 with, on the positive side, improvements in the business climate in several countries and resilient labour markets (Europe) or labour markets remaining dynamic (US). Combined with a disinflation trajectory not yet spreading to all sectors (services in particular), all these factors are tending to defer expectations of rate cuts.
With zero growth in the last quarter of 2023, the Eurozone has narrowly escaped recession, but economic activity is still hanging by a thread. Over 2023 as a whole, the increase in real GDP just reached 0.5%, and the carry-over effect for 2024 is null, as a result of a second half that was even weaker than the first one. Nevertheless, our Nowcast currently indicates growth of 0.3% q/q in Q1 2024, which is higher than our December forecast.
