During the summer, the Italian economy continued to show a strong resilience against increasing uncertainty. In Q3 2022, real GDP rose by 0.5% q/q, benefiting from the recovery of services, while both manufacturing and construction suffered. Domestic demand more than offset the negative contribution of net exports. A wind of growth continues to blow on the Italian real estate market. In Q2 2022, residential sales recorded a +8.6% y/y growth, while house prices in the same quarter grew by 5.2% y/y. Although the carry-over for 2022 is 3.9%, the outlook for the Italian economy has become more uncertain. Households suffer from high inflation, with purchasing power declining, while firms have to cope with increasing costs of production.
Spain is now the eurozone country with the lowest inflation rate, standing at 6.7% in November. Government measures to curb the rise in energy prices are paying off, although the underlying CPI is still rising significantly. The slowdown in inflation is expected to continue in 2023, but the government will keep on providing significant support to the economy. The 2023 budget, discussed in parliament, extends most of the support measures until the end of next year. Faced with the rise in mortgage rates, Madrid eased repayment conditions for households via loan restructuring facilities while allowing for a temporary freeze on monthly payments
Belgian GDP avoided a dip in Q3, but our present forecast suggests Q4 could be worse. A short and shallow recession looks likely as record-shattering inflation is expected to gradually abate throughout 2023. Consumer spending and corporate investment remain sluggish, but the negative impact of energy prices on household budgets looks more limited than many had feared. Active government intervention played a big part here, but fiscal consolidation remains necessary.
After dynamic business activity during the first six months of the year, Austrian growth slowed very dramatically during Q3 2022, due to the economic downturn both nationally and internationally. GDP is not expected to rebound over the final months of the year and is even poised to stagnate in 2023. However, the downturn in business activity has not stopped the government from announcing an ambitious reduction in the public deficit, which would fall below 3% from next year. This would result in a sharp decrease in the public-debt-to-GDP ratio. These commitments appear to be credible, as the incumbent Green President, Alexander Van der Bellen, was easily re-elected on 9 October, offering political stability to the country following the debacle of the 2016 election.
Despite the significant rise in inflationary pressures, the Greek economy continued to grow quickly during the first half of 2022, at a rate of 4.1% over the period. Nonetheless, real GDP fell back 0.5% q/q in Q3 despite tourism activity holding up well and the labour market being resilient. Indeed, the unemployment rate dropped during Q3 2022 (-29k), hitting its lowest level since December 2009. Almost 80% of the rise in unemployment recorded during the economic crises in 2008 and 2011, which ran from autumn 2008 to spring 2013, was wiped out. As a result, even though it is still very high, the unemployment rate fell below 12% in October (11.6%)
UK growth contracted sharply in Q3, confirming that the economy has gone into recession. Household and business surveys confirm this fall in consumption and investment, which is likely to continue in the coming months. Faced with persistent inflation which continues to spread, the Bank of England is continuing to tighten its monetary policy, despite the economy entering recession. The simultaneous announcement of a support plan for households and fiscal consolidation measures by the new government should help in the fight against inflation while supporting the lowest income households.
Up until now the Danish economy has continued to impress, with a strong post-Covid rebound which has propelled its GDP well above its pre-crisis level, but the future now looks a lot less bright. If inflation had not yet been able to fully undermine household purchasing power due to significant job creation and a level of over-saving which helped to mitigate the impact, these one-off shock absorbers are coming to an end and real household income is expected to fall over the coming quarters. The government is remaining relatively impassive in the face of this brutal shock and the fiscal response remains very limited, with public accounts that are in surplus and likely to remain so. Public debt should converge towards only 32% of GDP by 2024..
The construction output index is defying the most pessimistic outlook. In October, it reached its best level since January 2021, up 1.1% month-on-month and 2.6% year-on-year, while new orders are eroding. However, the cumulative order books (8.7 months according to INSEE, close to the historical level of 9 months) remain substantial and their implementation is lagging behind.
Meeting the European Union’s climate-related and digital ambitions will require a huge additional annual investment effort. In the near term, against a background of slowing growth and the prospect of a recession in 2023, this represents a potential source of resilience. In the medium term, this demand impulse may underpin or even increase inflation, in addition to other factors that could lead to greenflation. This would influence the level of official interest rates as well as long-term interest rates. The latter could also be under upward pressure due to the huge additional financing needs compared to the normal financing flows. The financing mix -banks versus capital markets- plays a key role in this respect.
The economic landscape is not improving much in Germany. November’s economic surveys confirm that the German economy is not just facing a slower pace of growth, but is indeed getting bogged down. Although the country’s composite PMI was up slightly (46.3 from 45.1), it remained at a very low level, well below the theoretical threshold for expansion. On the other hand, activity in services, which had been a key driver for growth in the third quarter, fell significantly with a PMI published at 46.1 in November, down for the fifth consecutive month.
The first indicators available for October, both for household consumption and for industrial production, suggest that GDP growth would have entered into negative territory at the start of the fourth quarter. Our scenario is based on -0.3% q/q. Household consumption fell 2.8% m/m in October, penalised by the acceleration of inflation, particularly in food. This negative effect was compounded by the impact of fuel shortages, which reduced the presence of consumers in shopping centres in the middle of the month. Finally, two-thirds of the very sharp drop in energy consumption (energy, water and waste items) of 10
The latest European Commission surveys indicated an encouraging upturn in Italian households' confidence, which nevertheless remains very low. The confidence index improved by 8 points in November, the strongest monthly increase recorded by the survey since its inception in 1985. Consumers’ anticipations on inflation were less negative (the second biggest monthly drop since 1985) and clearly supported this renewed optimism.
An update of the GDP Growth and inflation data, interest and exchange rates
In Turkey, growth has held up well (+4% year-on-year in Q3 2022) despite the rise in inflation. Consumer spending was the main supporting element, with an increase of 18%. However, the acceleration in inflation (from 19% year-on-year in Q3 2021 to 74% in Q2 2022) led to a contraction in the wage bill in real terms up to Q2 2022, despite a strong recovery in employment. Since mid-2022, inflation has continued to accelerate (+84.4% in November) but a wages catch-up has occurred following the revaluation of the minimum wage. However, this cannot explain the difference between consumption and the wage bill purchasing power.
The manufacturing PMI shows a contrasting picture in November, with another significant drop in the US and a rebound, from a low level, in the euro area. France, Germany, Greece, Italy and Spain recorded an improvement but the index declined in the Netherlands. Brazil saw an exceptional drop so next month’s data will be key to see whether this was a one-off. Also noteworthy is the drop in Vietnam from 50.6 to 47.4. New orders dropped again in the US although the index remains above that in the euro area, where it has rebounded. France, Germany and Italy benefited from a particularly strong increase, but the levels remain very low and well below the 50 mark. The situation worsened in Japan and Vietnam and even more so in Brazil. India saw an improvement from an already high level.
According to the latest estimate by the Atlanta Federal Reserve (GDPnow) on 1st December, quarterly annualised growth in US GDP could be 2.8% in Q4 2022, which would be hardly different from the Q3 performance (+2.9% q/q), but well above the first two quarters (-1.6% in Q1 and -0.6% in Q2). This latest estimate strengthens the idea that the US economy is resilient and is not expected to enter a recession in 2022.
The downside risks are increasing for French growth, to the extent that growth could turn out to be lower than the level incorporated by the government in its draft budget bill. For 2023 we estimate that growth could be 1 pp below the government’s assumed figure and that this is likely to imply a limited gap between a deficit of 5.4% of GDP at budget implementation and a level of 5% of GDP included in the draft budget bill. Indeed, the risks appear to be moderate in nature, between a deterioration in the labour market which is expected to remain relatively limited and a cyclical rise in business insolvencies, but at a level which should remain below that of 2019. Moreover, the support of public finances, in particular for purchasing power, remains substantial.
The United Kingdom’s exit from the European single market and the customs union on 31 January 2020 caused a significant economic shock which has had an adverse impact on growth and inflation in the UK, particularly on foreign trade. Since 1st January 2021 and the coming into effect of the post-Brexit Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), bilateral trade in goods between the United Kingdom and the European Union has fallen sharply. The United Kingdom has made changes which mean that some of its imported goods now come from countries outside the European Union.
Economic forecasting in the run-up to and during recessions is particularly challenging. An analysis of the Federal Reserve of Philadelphia’s survey of professional forecasters shows that, since 1968, forecast errors during recessions are significantly higher than during non-recession periods. Moreover, forecast errors during recessions are predominantly positive, so forecasts tend to be too optimistic, even if they concern the next quarter. At the current juncture, there is broad consensus, if not unanimity, that downside risks to growth dominate due to the multiple headwinds and uncertainties. The historical forecast record is another reason to be mindful of these risks.
Our different uncertainty gauges are complementary, in terms of scope and methodology. Starting top left and continuing clockwise, US economic policy uncertainty based on media coverage has been on a rising trend over the past twelve months. This is related to the policy tightening by the Federal Reserve. The latest observations however do not show a clear trend.
The latest activity data point to a widespread slowdown in the Chinese economy in October 2022. Industrial growth slowed to 5% year-on-year (y/y) from 6.3% in September, bringing an end to the acceleration seen during Q3 2022. The effects of tax incentives for purchasing cars have worn off, leading to a slowdown in car production. Most notably, the manufacturing sector adjusted its production (the electronics sector, in particular) in response to the rapid slowdown in exports.
Italy is facing an unprecedented and widespread surge in inflation and is unlikely to escape falling into recession this winter. Even though real GDP surprised on the upside in Q3 (+0.5% q/q according to initial estimates by the Italian National Institute of Statistics (Istat)), the barometer clearly indicates that the economic outlook is getting gloomier.
According to the preliminary estimate by the Office for National Statistics (ONS), quarterly growth in UK GDP fell by 0.2% (q/q) in Q3 (compared with +0.7% in Q1 and +0.2% in Q2). This contraction is mainly due to higher-than-expected destocking, particularly in the manufacturing and retail sectors.
For several years, Romania has been running a structural current account deficit. This year, the deficit is expected to worsen and could come close to 10% of GDP after -7.3% in 2021. The deficit had already reached EUR 20.2 billion over the first nine months of the year, well above the figure seen for 2021 as a whole. Romania's deficit is the largest amongst Central European countries. The main reason stems from the deterioration in the energy trade balance, which according to the latest figures reached EUR -4.5 billion for the January-July period. Imports of food and industrial goods have also contributed, but to a lesser degree compared to energy. By contrast, imports of consumer durables have remained soft. Exports were still relatively dynamic (up by a year-on-year rate of 26
Harmonised inflation in the Eurozone surprised again unfavourably in October, reaching 10.7% year-on-year according to Eurostat’s preliminary estimate, compared to the Bloomberg consensus forecast of 10.2%. It was the second month in a row of such a large acceleration in prices (+0.8 points). This was not the only bad news: half of this acceleration can be attributed to core inflation, 0.3 points to food inflation and 0.1 points to the energy component. Inflation therefore continues to spread and to strengthen. While the persistent and common component of inflation (PCCI) seems to have peaked in May this year (at 6.4%), its decline since then (5.5% in September, latest available figure) is not yet visible in the other measures of inflation.
